10 comments

Join the conversation!
Add your comment (Log in or register)
iPod rules
get over yourself c|net - iPod rules - why always is there some
sort of "but" when covering apple products? jeezus, Apple
products are magnificent tools / tech.
Posted by (54 comments )
Reply Link Flag
ok
did you not read the "headline" and the body copy of the story? Yes, we all know the ipod rocks now go put your player on you geek.
Posted by (35 comments )
Link Flag
iPod rocks BIG time
iPod is always the best. Don't think anyone can beat Apple iPod. It's the best mp3 player out there.
Posted by kittyangel_12 (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag
yet again
Thanks for the plentiful cornucopia of useful information. You should be a writer for cnet BIGtime.
Posted by (35 comments )
Link Flag
In the end, iPod = just another consumer electronics product
People are really strange. After lining up to spend $250 to $600 on the latest gadget, they report that owning this gadget makes them feel special. Some feel superior to people who own the older version, or the version with the smaller capacity, or the version in the color that didn't sell out, or the version made by a different company. Others feel "counter-cultural" despite having bought a mass-market product that millions of other people also own. It's nuts to elevate any consumer electronics product to this level.

It's also nuts to say that there's a single "best" portable music solution. Some people want an unbreakable, coin-sized flash memory player from BenQ. Some want a power-efficient, sub-miniature hard drive player from Sony. Some are content to line up at OfficeMax the day after Thanksgiving, to pick up a free internal CD burner from I/O Magic, a free 100-pack of blank CDs from kHypermedia, and a $9.99 portable CD player from Emerson.

I'd congratulate the guy on the bus who paid cash for his $9.99 CD player -- not the guy who bought the $599 iPod Photo on credit. I'd congratulate the gal at the gym who dropped her flash player, picked it up, and found it still working -- not the gal who dropped her iPod Mini and had to get the hard drive replaced. I'd congratulate the guy whose Sony was still playing after 25 hours -- not the guy who was recharging his iPod after 12.

There are lots of choices in the portable audio market, and the "best" one differs from person to person.

[http://Please, no flames -- I've been using Apple products for over 20 years, since the days of the Apple II.|http://Please, no flames -- I've been using Apple products for over 20 years, since the days of the Apple II.]
Posted by rpms (96 comments )
Link Flag
Thanks!
Thanks for a balanced and very thoughtful reply, Dustin. The examples you mention -- of how a refurbished iPod was right for you and an alternative product was right for your colleague -- are just what I was thinking of.

I agree that Apple will continue to enjoy tremendous success* with the iPod, and that the marketing is very effective.

Incidentally, I saw a knock-off billboard today in San Jose. Creative had lined up about ten of its Zen players -- each in a different color (I have no idea whether so many colors are available) -- against a plain black background. The only information was in the form of a slogan, "The power of Zen". It really made me laugh! Creative and the other competitors ought to highlight the particular benefits of their products, rather than just trying to duplicate Apple's marketing.

Happy listening on the music player that's right for *you*!

Paul Marcelin-Sampson
Santa Cruz, California, USA

* I am worried that Apple will suffer when margins decline. It is alarming that so much of Apple's revenue and profit now come from a single product in a market where competition is rising and prices are falling.
Posted by rpms (96 comments )
Reply Link Flag
You Bet
I enjoy this type of discussion when it doesn't digress into
religious zeal.

As far as your concern with Apple's reliance on iPod
revenue... I think they're leveraging. They build an iMac
whose design spins off the iPod, the Apple Stores have
been a success, analysts are predicting a boost in Apple
computer sales because of the success of the iPod. It's a
gateway product. Also, Apple is the poster child for
keeping your product from becoming a commodity. What
other consumer PC manufacturer has done that? They're
continually innovating and re-innovating the iPod to keep it
new and fresh and "better" than the competition.

They're creating great music software and upcoming
hardware that can play off the iPod success. They continue
to be the defacto choice for graphics, have a hold in film
editing/production, and have created great consumer
software for photos, music, and video.

Are they out of the woods? Maybe not, but overall I like
Apple's situation a lot more than I did 3 years ago... let
alone 10 years ago.
Posted by (6 comments )
Link Flag
 

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.