August 4, 2006 11:40 AM PDT
Printers a weak link in network security
In a presentation at the Black Hat security conference, Brendan O'Connor, a security expert at an unnamed U.S. financial company, showed how he could gain control over a Xerox device and wreak all kinds of havoc.
"Stop treating them as printers. Treat them as servers, as workstations," O'Connor said in his presentation on Thursday. Printers should be part of a company's patch program and be carefully managed, not forgotten by IT and handled by the most junior person on staff, he said.
In the case of the Xerox system, O'Connor said the multifunction device was, in essence, a Linux server. He was able to exploit a weakness in the security of the device and gain full control of the machine. O'Connor noted that he also looked at devices from other manufacturers and found similar security faults, but did not list any names.
Once a printer was under his control, O'Connor said he would be able to use it to map an organization's internal network--a situation that could help stage further attacks. The breach gave him access to any of the information printed, copied or faxed from the device. He could also change the internal job counter--which can reduce, or increase, a company's bill if the device is leased, he said.
The printer break-in also enables a number of practical jokes, such as sending print and scan jobs to arbitrary workers' desktops, O'Connor said. Also, devices could be programmed to include, for example, an image of a paper clip on every print, fax or copy, ultimately driving office staffers to take the machine apart looking for the paper clip.
One of the weaknesses in the Xerox system is an unsecured boot loader, the technology that loads the basic software on the device, O'Connor said. Other flaws lie in the device's Web interface and in the availability of services such as the Simple Network Management Protocol and Telnet, he said.
O'Connor informed Xerox of the problems in January. The company did issue a fix for its WorkCentre 200 series, it said in a statement. "Thanks to Brendan's efforts, we were able to post a patch for our customers in mid-January which fixes the issues," a Xerox representative said in an e-mailed statement.
However, O'Connor believes the fix is inadequate, and therefore he decided to make the presentation at Black Hat. The threat is real, even though printers are mostly on internal networks, he said. "There is always the insider threat," O'Connor said.