July 21, 2000 5:00 AM PDT
Online stalwarts beef up privacy initiatives
- Related Stories
Microsoft offers tracking alert for IE 5.5July 20, 2000
House approves anti-spam legislationJuly 18, 2000
IE 5.5 bugged in first weekJuly 14, 2000
Nearly undetectable tracking device raises concernJuly 12, 2000
Privacy activists lobby Congress for greater Net protectionsApril 6, 2000
DoubleClick postpones data-merging planMarch 2, 2000
"Cookies" targeted as Congress, advocates address Net privacyFebruary 11, 2000
Blocking software firms to release new programsFebruary 8, 2000
The initiatives come at a time of increased public awareness about the tracking practices of many Web sites and third-party advertisers. Last month, for example, the White House came under fire by privacy advocates for using tracking tags on its anti-drug site Freevibe.com. The White House immediately ordered its drug policy office to stop using cookies and issued strict new rules regulating federal use of the technology, which can surreptitiously collect personal information.
In a related move, the House of Representatives last night approved an amendment directing the Treasury Department, Postal Service and other federal agencies to show how they collect personal information from visitors to their Internet sites.
"There's a general trend here to not keep cookies behind the curtains," said Jason Catlett, president of privacy group Junkbusters.
But this trend is merely a signal of what is to come.
"These are all partial answers, as long as we start including education, privacy-enhancing technologies and baseline legislation to do the enforcement that's necessary," he said.
The idea is to give people more control of cookies, long a hot-button issue between ad networks and privacy advocates, who say the technology erodes personal privacy by tracking online activities.
The Internet Explorer 5.5 update, available by the end of August, will let people specify which kind of cookies they will accept. Through a small pop-up window, people will see whether the cookie is from the current site, which may want to set the tag to arrange for personalized stock quotes, or is from a third-party ad network such as DoubleClick. The online visitor can also opt out of receiving any cookies at all.
Engage's proposal recommends that cookies come with a digitally signed label that represents the purpose of the tag, such as how the information it tracks will be used. People could specify through their browser which kind of label-specific cookies they want to accept.
Microsoft said Internet Explorer 5.5 may be used in conjunction with TrustLabels, which gives consumers the "choice of visiting only those sites that respect their personal privacy preferences, thus reducing the problem of invisible bad actors," said Daniel Jaye, chief technology officer for Engage.
Added Andrew Shen, policy analyst at the Electronic Privacy Information Center: "(This) illustrates that even the ad networks see a problem with third-party cookies."
"This is the first time we're seeing Microsoft develop a privacy-enhancing technology where they are receiving consumer feedback--and that's a good sign for the future of privacy on the Internet," Schwartz said.
"Cookies were not built with privacy in mind," he said. "We need to have technologies that give users more control."
Yahoo's new, two-page-long policy is linked to areas on the site where visitors may be concerned about their personal information.
But no one solution is the total answer.
"We need to be working on self-regulation, baseline legislation and privacy-enhancing technology all at the same time," Schwartz said. "Anyone who says that one of those areas can solve the whole problem alone is not being realistic when looking at the global decentralized Internet."