April 25, 2007 4:00 AM PDT

FCC to reveal spectrum auction plan

(continued from previous page)

But critics point out that four of the nation's largest broadband providers also have a stake in a mobile wireless provider. This means that even if wireless broadband competes with fixed-line broadband, those services are likely provided by the same companies offering DSL or cable modem service.

With the acquisition of BellSouth, AT&T now owns all of Cingular Wireless, making the new AT&T the largest wire-line telephone and cell phone operator in the country. Verizon Wireless is majority owned by Verizon Communications, which is the second-largest phone company in the nation. And Comcast and Time Warner, the No. 1 and No. 2 cable operators in the nation, respectively, are in a joint venture with the third-largest wireless operator in the country, Sprint Nextel.

Control by the incumbents?
Consumer advocates say some of these vertically integrated communications companies used the rules to manipulate the outcome of the most recent wireless spectrum auction. The Advanced Wireless Services auction, held in the summer of 2006, sold 90MHz of spectrum licenses in the 1710-1755 and 2110-2155MHz bands, which had been used by military and law enforcement.

Many in the industry deemed the AWS auction a huge success, since it raised almost $14 billion for the government. On Monday the public-interest law firm Media Access Project issued a study analyzing the bidding history in the AWS auction.

"Recent history with the AWS auction shows that large incumbent carriers were able to control the outcome of the auction," said Kenney of Consumers Union.

In the report, Media Access Project described how incumbent broadband carriers and mobile operators successfully blocked potential new competitors, including a consortium formed by satellite TV providers EchoStar and DirecTV.

The way it worked was that several operators, like T-Mobile and Cingular Wireless, would target key bidders with "retaliatory" bids. And once the competitive bidder dropped out of the auction, most of these other bidders would also drop out of that auction, leaving only a couple of bidders.

Wireless DBS, which was formed by EchoStar and DirecTV, dropped out after the 11th round of bidding. And a group backed by the Dolan family, which controls Cablevision Systems, was also targeted and withdrew from bidding after 20 rounds.

Meanwhile, SpectrumCo, the consortium formed by Comcast, Time Warner Cable, Cox Communications, Advance/Newhouse Communications and Sprint Nextel, won about 61 percent of the licenses on which it bid, according to Media Access Project. T-Mobile and Cingular, which also used this targeting tactic, also ended up with significant slivers of bandwidth from the auction, the report notes.

"The blocking behavior was very targeted," Feld said. "And the fact that on most occasions once the new entrant dropped out of the bidding so did the other bidders indicates the purpose was to control the bidding process and block new entrants from amassing spectrum. And it worked."

Media Access Project along with several other consumer advocacy groups have formed a coalition, called Save Our Spectrum, to fight for new rules to protect new entrants in the bidding process. The group filed a proposal with the FCC earlier this month, which recommends, among other things, that the FCC adopt anonymous bidding to alleviate the issue of targeted bidding.

"Anonymous bidding would help solve a lot of these issues," Feld said. "In particular, it would help new entrants seeking to build a national footprint."

While open versus blind, or anonymous, bidding is likely to be hotly debated for the 700MHz spectrum, Feld said it isn't likely to be resolved during Wednesday's meeting. Instead he believes the commission will handle some of the most basic rules for the auction, such as establishing the geographic size of the licenses.

Companies looking to establish a nationwide footprint, such as the satellite TV providers, are likely pushing for fewer, larger licenses. Smaller licenses benefit rural carriers because they reduce the cost of the licenses, allowing smaller players--often companies already serving rural areas--to afford the price. They are also good for large operators, like AT&T and T-Mobile, that are looking to fill gaps in their coverage areas.

The FCC will likely offer a mix of large and small licenses, much like it did for the AWS auction that took place last summer, Feld predicts.

He also predicts the commission will also seek public comment on a proposal submitted in late February by a company called Frontline Wireless, which wants the FCC to block off a 10MHz chunk of the 700MHz spectrum for companies interested in building a nationwide infrastructure to support a broadband network for public safety agencies. The licensee would also be required to allow open access, offering the spectrum to local public safety agencies on a wholesale basis.

"Wednesday represents the first cut on how the FCC will proceed and the general direction it will go for the auction," Feld said in his blog posted Tuesday. "Will it favor the incumbent push for large license blocks and open bidding? Will it allow the Frontline proposal to go forward?"

Previous page
Page 1 | 2

See more CNET content tagged:
spectrum, auction, rule, band, broadband


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
Wrong information
Regards to the line: The reason is simple. By nature, on the
700MHz frequency band, signals travel about four times farther
than those on bands used by the wireless and electronics
industries today...

Cellphones use frequencies from 800 MHz to 2 GHz. There is
little difference between 700 MHz and 800 MHz. 700MHz will
propogate somewhat further than 2 GHz (but doesn't "bounce"
as well in city canyons). But not "4x further".
Posted by mongo6 (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag
Where's the White Space?
In spite of the big numbers thrown about in terms of spectrum, the big money maker for the government is 2.4 and 5.7 GHz spectrum, two of the free bands.

WI-FI and Bluetooth equipment sales, and the revenue from operating hot spots generate much more revenue for the government (feds and local) than all other spectrum combined, according to a speech by the previous FCC chairman at a WI-FI Internet provider's meeting.

New MIMO technology such as 802.11N, which the carriers are attempting to block in the standards process, provides infinite re-use of spectrum. Allowing greedy cheaters like the incumbent cell phone companies to "own" this valuable public resource is a big step backwards in providing low cost broadband to the public.
Posted by disco-legend-zeke (448 comments )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.