November 16, 2005 3:52 PM PST

Attack targets Sony 'rootkit' fix

Sony BMG took another blow Wednesday, when a security company said it has found malicious attacks based on software designed to defuse the record label's "rootkit" problems.

Websense's security labs reported that it has discovered several Web sites designed to exploit security flaws in a rootkit uninstaller program issued by Sony BMG Music Entertainment. As reported earlier, some Sony CDs deposit rootkit-like code onto people's computers that leave them open to attacks.

Websense has uncovered only a couple of Web sites set up to attack flaws in the initial uninstall program, and the damage they cause appears to be minimal so far. One of them, hosted in the United States, simply restarts infected computers.

Reader response
What should Sony do?
Debate how the debacle will
affect the label's policies.

"It's someone trying to make a point," said Dan Hubbard, senior director of security and technology research at Websense. "They could have done a lot worse."

Sony became embroiled in controversy earlier this month after the record label was discovered to be distributing secret code similar to a rootkit with certain music CDs as a copy-protection mechanism. Sony BMG recalled millions of these CDs on Tuesday, after viruses exploiting flaws in the rootkits began to appear.

The company also released programs to uninstall the rootkits, but the initial Web-based version has its own set of flaws, Princeton University computer science professor Ed Felten wrote in his blog Tuesday.

Web site attack page

In the case of the U.S.-hosted malicious site, the attacker may have compromised the site without the owner's knowledge, Websense's Hubbard said. The site appears to be associated with Canada's version of the American Idol TV show. Websense also found the following message in the site's malicious code: "Sony DRM Christmas Gift." DRM stands for digital rights management, a type of copy-protection technology.

"Any user who has downloaded and run the Sony uninstaller program is susceptible to this attack," Websense said in a statement.

A Sony BMG representative did not immediately respond to inquiries about the alert.

However, in response to concerns about the security of its uninstall software, Sony has removed the program from its Web site, and promised to release another version soon.

"We currently are working on a new tool to uninstall First4Internet XCP software," the Sony site now reads. "In the meantime, we have temporarily suspended distribution of the existing uninstall tool for this software. We encourage you to return to this site over the next few days."

The flaw in Sony's uninstall software was based on an ActiveX progam installed on hard drives, which allowed Web sites to run malicious code automatically in the Internet Explorer Web browser. Some security experts are advising people who think they might have used Sony's uninstall tool to use the Firefox Web browser, which does not support automatic ActiveX controls.

Princeton computer science professor Ed Felten and researcher Alex Haldeman have created a page that tests whether a computer might be at risk as a result of running the uninstall tool.

CNET News reporter John Borland contributed to this story.


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
I ran the uninstaller to find that I didnt have the rootkit, I thought sonicstage (that came wit my sony cd player) may have installed it.

****, any ports I could block?
Posted by wazzledoozle (288 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Sony is evil AND incompetent
Boycott Sony
Posted by llaitner (8 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Boycott all that is SONY!
The problem with the uninstaller/reinfection software is with the ACTIVE X switch being left on, so IE6, has its front, back, side and roof wide open to everything, when you surf the net! One cure, use either mozilla firefox or opera to surf the web, end of problem regarding the active X component. Another, is total system reinstall after hard drive wipe and clean. Further the problem with sony/F4i 'XCP' is that these disc's are sold world wide! In a recent snapshot check of 9.9 million web surfers on 3 million DNS servers, Dan Kaminsky found, approximately 568,000 , showing a unique signature to sony's DRM malware/nightmare! Interestingly, whilst all countries have infected machines, the report shows japan has 200,000 ; USA has 130,000 and UK has 44,000, followed by the Netherlands and Spain with 27,000 and even Australia has some 8,000 infections as well. So the only real cure, is either manual disinfect shown by Mark Russinovich, or a complete harddrive wipe clean/format and reininstall from clean backup copies, create a user/administrator and thereafter disable windows, autorun step for all optical drives! Further it seems that some of the newer released Sony DVD's like the just released "Bewitched" marked copy protection, may have some form of strange DRM check program included for free to mess up windows core as well! The only true cure is Boycott all that is SONY from A- Z! A bankrupt SONY/BMG , will give the major remaining labels, the hint don't mess with the customers computers or basic rights, for this is what happens if you do! Information to hand shows Sony electronics wholesale is now engaged in predatory illegal pricing tatics as well! Let the class action law suits and the criminal trespass to jail the corporate crooks responsible for this fiacsco!, destroy SONY as a business/trading entity, and make the trademark worthless! It's your choice, don't reward dishonesty, by purchasing any goods, manufacted by an entity that treats all end users as thieves!
Posted by heystoopid (691 comments )
Reply Link Flag
What is infected?
I only have one product by Sony on anything except my Xbox.
This product is Star Wars Galaxies, by SOE. Is it possible for me
or anyone else to confirm that Sony has the copy protection
devices installed on my computer?

If so, I would appreciate an explanation of the removal
procedure, barring a total system sweep. I would also like to
know exactly what kind of infringement this is on Sony's part.
This sounds pretty illegal to me. I am going to read the liscence
agreement one more time, but I am intent upon setting this
Posted by eupoth (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag
Many consumers have echoed the sentiments of some tech columnists who recommend a boycott of Sony CDs. One columnist even recommended boycotting ALL CDs since other manufacturers were considering similar measures. I agree with the Sony boycott approach but will extend that to ALL Sony products ... even films at theaters. It will be interesting to watch CD sales figures in the coming months. If sales take a nosedive, it will be that much harder to use piracy as an excuse if a significant boycott materializes. But this may have another effect. Sony/BMG artists who are approaching the ends of their contract periods might consider jumping ship to another CD conglomerate. It would be a survival issue for them if a boycott cut heavily into sales. What a mess. The executives behind this rootkit deployment need to be given their walking papers.
Posted by AlecWest (84 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Boycott Sony, Boycott Blu-Ray
Boycott Sony, boycott Blu-Ray. I was a Blu-Ray fan before this, now it's HD-DVD all the way baby.
Posted by anarchyreigns (299 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Why Blu - Ray?
maybe Sony supports it, but so df a lot of other big names!
boycot blu-ray? Over HD? Are you kidding me?

HD DVD has a fraction of space compared with Blu_ray, and blu-ray
has backwards capability - unlike HD.

I can understand not buying sony - but not supporting bluray
because of this is dumb.
Posted by NeverFade (402 comments )
Link Flag
doesn't vista support hd-dvd?
Didn't microsoft just say that they're going to be supporting hd-dvd? That'll pretty much shove that standard down our throats anyway.

It's funny, I had a friend that had a sony music cd with drm and I almost allowed him to put in in my machine, but I stopped him before he got to do it.

We listened to the music through my dvd player hooked up to my dvd.
Posted by thedreaming (573 comments )
Reply Link Flag
That's it Sony, no more of your DRM infested music
for me! Which means no more Sony products for me!
Posted by bobby_brady (765 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Don't Use IE At All, Not Just A Sony Issue
Beyond Sony's incompetance in implementing DRM, this story illustrates that despite all the so-called security fixes from Microsoft for Internet Explorer it is still unsafe to use. ActiveX should be called ActiveHex. Dump IE for good and use other browsers like Firefox or Opera. Do not be conned yet again by Microsoft. Also, I'd like to see CNET do a test with Windows Vista/IE7 to see how it handles the Sony uninstaller. If it succumbs to the same ActiveX vulnerability then it is a stinging indictment to Microsoft's woeful lack of security.
Posted by Stating (869 comments )
Reply Link Flag
How about
giving M$ time to fix IE7 before saying "DUMP IT!"

Yeah, right!!!
Posted by royc (78 comments )
Link Flag
Sony Has NOT Pulled The Uninstaller
I just downloaded the flawed uninstaller from (11/17 11 A.M. PST) so Sony has lied yet again. CNET should have checked this out before taking Sony's word. The tool can be downloaded from
<a class="jive-link-external" href="" target="_newWindow"></a>. The .exe is dated 11/08/2005 version Sony's statement reads:
November 8, 2005 - This Service Pack removes the cloaking technology component that has been recently discussed in a number of articles published regarding the XCP Technology used on SONY BMG content protected CDs. To alleviate any concerns that users may have about the cloaking component posing potential security vulnerabilities, this update has been released to enable users to remove this component from their computers."

Additional info about Sony BMG:
Sony music labels:
Arista Records
BMG Classics
BMG Heritage
BMG International Companies
Columbia Records
Epic Records
J Records
Jive Records
LaFace Records
Legacy Recordings
Provident Music Group
RCA Records
RCA Victor Group
RLG - Nashville
Sony Classical
Sony Music International
Sony Music Nashville
Sony Wonder
Sony Urban Music
So So Def Records
Verity Records
Posted by Stating (869 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Is Blu-ray DRM a non-issue too?
Is Blu-ray DRM a non-issue too? Look it up.
Posted by anarchyreigns (299 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Sony and YOU
Hello everyone,

I am glad that you all are interested enough to read this.

Today I was reading up on this sony problem again. This time in the washington post. Here is an excerpt from it that really caught my attention:

Sony BMG's latest moves have not erased its legal and public relations troubles. Last week, an attorney in California filed a lawsuit seeking damages for residents who bought the defective CDs, and on Monday, a lawyer in New York filed a nationwide class-action case against the company.

Mark Russinovich, chief software architect at Sysinternals, the security expert whose initial research into the anti-piracy program sparked the controversy, welcomed the class-action suits, saying withdrawal of the software wasn't enough.

"What I'm most concerned about is: If nothing serious happens to Sony that's visible to other companies, then we run the risk of this kind of thing becoming standard corporate behavior," Russinovich said.

This last paragraph says a mouthful. Ok, so now we had to deal with this crap from sony, but they may be only the tip of the iceberg. We as consumers need to use our backbones and show not only sony, what we think of this play that they seemed to think was "not so serious", but also as a warning to other companies who just might get it in their head to follow suit, that we are not going to stand for this sort of behavior.

Personally, this did not happen to me, but I do not condone this sort of thing from any company. To those that it did happen to, I hope that you get back the normalcy that you had before sony did this to you.

Stand strong together people and put sony where they belong--out of business. Do not buy anything from them or from any company affilliated with them. Phillips is one. Boycott them. This will get the bad apple out of the barrel and let all the other apples know what is gonna happen if they try something like this.

For the full story from the washington post newpaper the link is:

<a class="jive-link-external" href="" target="_newWindow"></a>

Have a good day all

Posted by Eskiegirl302 (82 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Virus 2.0! Cool!
"However, in response to concerns about the security of its uninstall software, Sony has removed the program from its Web site, and promised to release another version soon."

I dont want a new version of Sony's virus, I don't think anyone does, if Sony had any idea of how to even start to make things right, they would remove the software, 100% and try to win back the population that knows of their evil.
Posted by (37 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Sony a Hypocrite
Sony invented and has promoted music sharing since
the 60s with every thing from Vinyl records to 8 track reel to reel,cassette's, CD/DVDRW's including the software.
This is why we have antitrust laws, Sony should be forced to divest itself from 1 of these industries.
It's trying to control the entire dying market,with
lawsuits, malicious software and attacks on 3rd party software providers (check Lame dll)
Foreign Corporations running our lives.

Elwood Blue
Posted by Elwood Blue (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.