When you purchase an XBox yes you may mod anything you want on it you now own it. When you log into a service that is designed for fair play and fair gaming, microsoft reserves the right to not allow certian people into there PRIVATE NETWORK. Any person with a moded xbox that is willing to complin forfited there right the day they decided to MOD there box and must suffer the conquences.
i dont see why everyone is going all phyco over these "mod-chips" they'er not ruining your company or anything like that. yea its stealing but its not like you always do things the your supposed to. come on just give them a break. you banning these chips is just pushing them to make more and more
Microsoft has every right to say who can & who cannot participate online... I kinda expected them to ban hardware hackers from participation. That's just a risk those hackers take when they decide to insert a mod chip, or anything else for that matter, into the X-Box.
I think that there should be Xbox Live banning; Microsoft has every right to do so because it is their private gaming network and they have the right to deny connection to it. BUT, the citeria for banning should be different, because a larger hard drive alone poses no threat to the Xbox Live community.
Formerly, Microsoft would only ban for modified BIOSes and other threatening modifications, because these did pose a threat to the community. But, as it is the owner's property, if he choses to run something perfectly legal such as an Xbox release of Linux on his Xbox with more space than the default 8-10GB, he should be allowed to do so without retribution. The new restrictions, which check your hard drive size, are aimed stopping modifications that posed no threat whatsoever to the Xbox Live community.
I think that it would be acceptable for Microsoft to somehow scan the hard drive for pirated games, but this would be hard because game owners are legally allowed to make a backup of their games. The scans that Microsoft performs should probably be limited to checking for modified, illegal BIOSes and modified dashboards because these are the things that truely prove a threat; without a modified BIOS, there is nothing you can do with a larger hard drive besides have more storage for music or gamesaves.
You can take it seriously or not there are contracts that limit Games or Hardware to be sold elsewhere. Now I as european gamer know that 99% of the time I would prefer an US/JP Version of the Hardware or the Game over the localized version simply for the reason that they are original and most of the time come with "better or unchanged" HW design. EU Consoles (note that I do not name any in particular) lack speed or performance ... same with games where graphics are changed or some games are never released for one or the other reason. In the case of any of these reasons you may even need a MOD chip just to run every game on every HW. More to think about is the "saving of whole Game Images on XBoxes Harddrive" which the Xecuter allows... ok new possibilities (HD in Console) new features will be added to the MOD software and as soon as XBOX Live locks out MODed Machines, there will come a new release that just goes arround the blacklists .... its always that way and has been in the past. And against everything that MS may allow you to do or not --- there is always a way arround limitations ... just the same way as MS improves ;)
When you purchase an xbox.. It says that when you crack that seal you are bound by the terms of the licence.. Don't like that.. Don't buy an XBOX.. As far as modding.. I personally believe that when you purchase something that you "own" it and therefore you can do WHATEVER you want to it.. However you did crack that seal on the box.. So if ms says you violated your license and can't play on thier "PRIVATELY" owned network.. well there you go.. Not hard to understand.. Play nice or don't play at all.. That's M$'s logic.. As much as I hate M$ I do respect a license...
Well banning moded xbox owners is just wrong thing to do...I dont own Xbox and never will do...but Imagine next scenario u buy a car and want to "upgrade" it......add extra horse power or whatever....then u get stopped buy police officer who tells you can't drive that car here on this road...Make your own private road and drive it there....Not to mention other products/hardware u can buy today. So even considering applying licence to the hardware you buy should be treated as crime too....
i just learned the basics of modding but by the sound of it alot of people like it so why not make only certain specific places wher modders can go play with other modders but not the regular players and vice versa for the normal players. and whats wrong with alot of memory?
every right to do so because it is their private gaming network
and they have the right to deny connection to it. BUT, the citeria
for banning should be different, because a larger hard drive
alone poses no threat to the Xbox Live community.
Formerly, Microsoft would only ban for modified BIOSes and
other threatening modifications, because these did pose a threat
to the community. But, as it is the owner's property, if he choses
to run something perfectly legal such as an Xbox release of
Linux on his Xbox with more space than the default 8-10GB, he
should be allowed to do so without retribution. The new
restrictions, which check your hard drive size, are aimed
stopping modifications that posed no threat whatsoever to the
Xbox Live community.
I think that it would be acceptable for Microsoft to somehow
scan the hard drive for pirated games, but this would be hard
because game owners are legally allowed to make a backup of
their games. The scans that Microsoft performs should probably
be limited to checking for modified, illegal BIOSes and modified
dashboards because these are the things that truely prove a
threat; without a modified BIOS, there is nothing you can do with
a larger hard drive besides have more storage for music or
gamesaves.
And against everything that MS may allow you to do or not --- there is always a way arround limitations ... just the same way as MS improves ;)
When you purchase an xbox.. It says that when you crack that seal you are bound by the terms of the licence.. Don't like that.. Don't buy an XBOX.. As far as modding.. I personally believe that when you purchase something that you "own" it and therefore you can do WHATEVER you want to it.. However you did crack that seal on the box.. So if ms says you violated your license and can't play on thier "PRIVATELY" owned network.. well there you go.. Not hard to understand.. Play nice or don't play at all.. That's M$'s logic.. As much as I hate M$ I do respect a license...
- modding
- by patches04 February 8, 2006 4:57 PM PST
- i just learned the basics of modding but by the sound of it alot of people like it so why not make only certain specific places wher modders can go play with other modders but not the regular players and vice versa for the normal players. and whats wrong with alot of memory?
- Like this Reply to this comment
-
(9 Comments)