Webware

Read all 'Shelfari' posts in Webware
July 11, 2007 10:35 AM PDT

Shelve Shelfari until it matures

by Candace Lombardi
  • 8 comments

As Nick Hornby once wrote, what you're like is not as important as what you like.

That philosophy seems to be spreading across the Internet as more and more opportunities for rating and sharing opinions present themselves. Now you can keep the late-night debates over pop culture going all week long.

Shelfari, a social-networking site centered on books, is like GoodReads in that you can add and rate books, post reviews and share your thoughts with friends.

The company just added a widget function that works with Facebook and other social-networking sites, so that other friends--maybe those who are not quite as literary-minded as your smug self--can see what you're reading and take a hint. Shelfari offers a blog paste-in, but Facebook seems to require that you add Shelfari's widget through its Application portal.

Sample book shelf in Shelfari

Sample book shelf in Shelfari

(Credit: Shelfari)

The site looked really promising at first, despite the fact that the name and interface look as if they're geared toward children's books. But then I found its navigation a bit awkward.

Each time I wanted to update the status of a book, add a tag or rating or delete the book from my shelf, I had to deal with a pop-up window. After making a change, I then had to click "submit" and wait for the window to update. I could scroll from within the pop-up to other books, but the process was slow and the black interface over the rest of the screen ugly.

Even worse, the site would not let me rate my friend's books on the fly. Clicking on one of his books brought me to a completely new page with reviews and info dedicated to that particular book. I then had to add the book to my shelf before I could rate it. It did link directly to Amazon when I clicked up by from the mini menu that pops up when you mouse over a book. You also can choose which book cover you would like to display.

This is very different from GoodReads, which lets you both rate and add new books from either search-result lists or friends' libraries.

Shelfari widget in Facebook

Shelfari widget in Facebook

(Credit: Shelfari/Facebook)

The widget tool, on the other hand, is very nice. Though you can't choose which particular books you'd like to display, you can customize the way they rank and the widget size and layout.

And for anyone who has used a scanning tool to organize their personal collection of books, you may be able to import that list into Shelfari. I personally had trouble importing a .txt file that included a list of about 200 books from yet another book social-networking site that I've tried. But in Shelfari's defense, I had converted it to a .txt from a .csv file.

March 1, 2007 4:58 PM PST

Shelfari: Social bookmarking for books

by Josh Lowensohn
  • Post a comment

Shelfari is a social network and recommendation service that lets you flaunt your book collection to others, and discover new titles worth reading. Yesterday Shelfari announced a round of funding, with Amazon.com being the top contributor.

If you've ever seen Delicious Monster, Shelfari is visually similar, with virtual bookshelves that house your collection as long as you're willing to manually input all your titles. The result is a slick-looking listing to share with others on your blog or Web site (see below), and make friends with people who have similar tastes to swap recommendations.

Each Shelfari book page is essentially an extension of what you'd find on Amazon.com, with buyer reviews and a five-star rating system. Shelfari employs a fair bit of Amazon.com integration, using Amazon's comments and purchasing options. Clicking the option to buy the book actually takes you off-site to the book's page on Amazon.

From a user perspective, Shelfari's real draw is groups. Users can create their own groups based on very specific genres, like "banned books" or "19th century English literature." Each group has a common shelf, where users can contribute titles. There's also an attached forum for discussion, and an introductory page with room for a description and any worthwhile URLs.

Shelfari is a great way to pick up book recommendations. I often find books worth reading through friends, so it's only natural to have a social network that fosters a similar service. But there's still something to be said about exploring a bookstore, which despite its good looks, Shelfari can't match.

Here's an example of Shelfari's embeddable shelf:

  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

About Webware

Say No to boxed software! The future of applications is online delivery and access. Software is passé. Webware is the new way to get things done.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Webware topics

15 sites that went kaput in 2009

Web sites launch all the time, but they also shut their doors. We highlight 15 that bit the dust this year.

Top 10 news stories of the decade

Let the debate begin: Was the iPhone more important than iTunes? Was anything bigger than Google finding a great business model? CNET offers its list of the 10 most important stories of the '00s.

Most Discussed

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right