No update for you naughty Twitterers, Apple says
Since this report was published, Apple has decided to approve the app for the App Store. Read the updated story here.
Updated at 3:10 p.m. PDT with comment from Tweetie developer.
Remember the time your mom withheld your dessert because you said a bad word? Apple is doing something along those lines, with one major difference: it's because a bad word has been heard in the neighborhood.
Tweetie won't be getting an update, at least not right now, due to the Trends report above.
(Credit: twitpic)According to iLounge, Apple has rejected version 1.3 of Tweetie, the popular Twitter client application for the iPhone and iPod Touch. The reason? An offensive word appeared in Twitter's Trends data.
Somewhat similar to Google Trends, Twitter's Trends is a list of the most frequently used topics or words on Twitter at any given moment. This means this live list of words/topics changes constantly (I checked it just now and the offensive word--which starts with an "F," by the way--has gone). Yet, somehow it still bothers Apple enough to take action.
It seems that Apple, as a matter of policy, does not comment on the approval process for Apple applications. We have, however, contacted the company, and will update this post if we hear back.
In an e-mail to CNET News, however, Tweetie developer Loren Brichter said Apple quoted this part of the company's guidelines as a reason for the decision:
"Applications must not contain any obscene, pornographic, offensive, or defamatory content or materials of any kind (text, graphics, images, photographs, etc.), or other content or materials that in Apple's reasonable judgement may be found objectionable by iPhone or iPod Touch users."
"The question then becomes whether is it an individual app's responsibility to censor everything it gets from the Internet," Brichter said. "Twitter themselves create the "top trends" list; Tweetie just displays it. The consensus is pretty much that it would be ridiculous to expect that.
"At the same time," the developer added, "this could have been just a goof on Apple's part. The App Store is still very young, they're working out the kinks."
Here's the long list of improvements in Tweetie 1.3 that all you naughty Twitterers with iPhones and iPod Touches are gonna miss out on--at least for now:
- Post pictures with Mobypicture and yfrog (in addition to TwitPic)
- New "Link" button to add to Instapaper faster, and repost individual links
- View full-size profile images
- Dark theme
- Ping.fm integration
- Tweetshrink integration
- Twitlonger integration
- German localization
- Russian localization
- Allow DMs up to 255 characters
- Many UI tweaks
- Play back Song.ly links
- Option to use "RT" syntax
- Better feedback for posting a Map link
- Improved international date formatting
- Detect invalid profile images
- Fixed account sorting
- Fixed profile image URL decoding
- Fixed links with # anchors
- Fixed "(null)" problem when using bookmarklet
- Fixed problem with @ character in password field
Well, the good news is you can still get and use the existing Twitter 1.2.1, which can be purchased for $3 at Apple's App Store.
If the fact that Apple rejected Tweetie 1.3 due to an offensive word was true--and it appears to be, according to Brichter--I wonder why it hasn't removed Tweetie overall. It's not like you can only tweet naughty words with the updated version.
But mom and dad can be crazy and illogical like that.
Dong Ngo is a CNET editor who covers networking and network storage, and writes about anything else he finds interesting. You can also listen to his podcast at insidecnetlabs.cnet.com. E-mail Dong. 
Did you pay to post on cnet?
It is in the dictionary. Only a "bad word" because we are told to believe it is a bad word.
Did you knows PANTS, yes pants, used to be considered a naughty word. It is just stupid.
:-D
(No, I'm not "reporting" it because I agree, it's just a word. Words don't kill, people do.)
Signed,
- An Apple Professional Tired of Apologizing For Cupertino
LOL.
(Sorry folks, just suffered an old Monty Python flashback moment there.)
Apple those poor folks what new zaniness can you come up with? A very expensive Dictionary of NEWSPEAK? all written in that Bullshoit Textmessage shorthand, and encoded with DRMS so that they can track down and send us off to the camps to build overpriced shiny things that you can caress....
AHA! Sexual, Healthy caresing between two consenting adults should be replaced with technoFetishism and carressing of iCRAP, that's why they're so JAzzed about touch this and touch that and you're iDENTITY Belongs to the iNTERNATIONAL iCONNECTED iFRONT? as iWAS saying, that'sd why it's all so Clear like an Apple Monitor.... iGIV iN
ONE OF i/US One of i/US.....
Refer to the first American Pie Movie and the Pie Poking Scene....That's a suggestion for AppleiPIES, That should be the New logo
yes no one expects the Inquisition, amongst our Chief weapons are .....
Amendment One Foegoes any corporate and FCC regulation...So ******* your terms of use...
I am so not getting an iPhone
I'm fine with WinMo since I can at least curse while using it (more like at it) without MS interfering
I really wanted to love the iPhone, but Apple's policies have forced my hand, and until they decide to loosen up, they won't be seeing any of my money for an iPhone.
Just so you know the difference, Perry.
;-)
LOL.
(Note: Apple isn't so stupid to think there are no such things as curse words on the internet, so the only logical explanation is they counted them and found there are too many. We all know what happens when you abuse curse words and invoke the ancient curse, right? They're just doing their part to save us all!)
End sarcastic transmission ...
Apparently, you are bothered using the word '****'. A perfectly normal word, around - in its various forms - since the Angles invaded what is now England, and fully explained in the Oxford dictionary.
Get real Crapple.
I can't believe with the smartphone wars starting to heat up that Apple is dumb enough to pull a stunt like this. I don't see how Apple is going to keep customers if developers will be defecting to less restrictive systems like Andriod. I can see why so many are choosing to jail break the I-Phones and I-Pods.
I'm a businessman and I tell no way, no how would I EVER develope anything for Apple.
U nless apple changes, it's
C ontrol freak nature will eventually
K ill off some of it's customer base
Y et they will continue to
O perate in this fashion
U nless consumers vote with their pocketbooks.
U sing the this
C omment section.
K nowingly or unknowingly. :)
;-)
Microsoft become the big IBM.
I hate Microsoft
I use Apple's product.
Apple become the big Microsoft
I hate Apple
Any suggestion, guy?
Let's look at a few irons in their fire:
- Palm Pre coming soon
- Google's G1 and App Store is up and running
- jailbreaking is easy (and popular)
- competing Apps Stores, with potential for serious issues
- Mac Clones, also with different, but still serious issues
- creating Netbook Hackentoshes is easy and getting good reviews in tech community
- New Apple style netbook coming out this year?
- new iPhone coming out next June?
- Snow Leopard coming soon
- Google services comparing very favorably (and free) to MobileMe services
- Economy sucks
- Their highly respected, legendary leader is ill
Lastly, but not least, the Apps Store was probably more popular by a magnitude then they planned. Their overwhelmed reviewers probably don't have enough time to fully vet every submission so they're in the mindset of looking for any excuse to axe an app.
MySpace is another one. People feel way too self-important these days.
People feel way too self-important these days.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I've been saying that for decades now, ever since seeing my first moron blow through a red light with a cell phone held up to his ear (after having first stopped for the light, I might add. Cross traffic was green the whole time, it wasn't one of those "turn light changed and he got confused" issues, he was just a moron who was far to absorbed with himself.)
Twitter is just the natural conclusion of the self absorbed "me" generation.
- by vhase March 10, 2009 4:44 PM PDT
- "Applications must not contain any obscene, pornographic, offensive, or defamatory content or materials of any kind (text, graphics, images, photographs, etc.), or other content or materials that in Apple's reasonable judgement may be found objectionable by iPhone or iPod Touch users."
- Reply to this comment
-
Showing 1 of 2 pages (63 Comments)Guess this means the new Kindle App will have to go - after all, those authors love to use foul language. I better grab my copy of Hannibal before they shut it down...