• On TechRepublic: Why VISTA HATERS will love Windows 7
January 3, 2009 10:50 AM PST

Facebook sues social-network aggregator Power.com

by Jennifer Guevin

Facebook is suing Power.com, a Brazilian start-up that lets users access a number of social networks through one portal.

Facebook filed a lawsuit on Tuesday in U.S. District Court in San Jose, Calif., for copyright and trademark infringement; unlawful competition; and violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, CAN-SPAM Act, and the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, among other charges.

Power.com signs users into their various social networks and messaging clients and delivers the data from those sites and services to one page. For example, you can see all of your friends, their status updates, visit their profile pages, and even send a message to multiple friends on multiple social networks--all in one place. Last month, Webware editor Rafe Needleman described it as Meebo for social networks, and it's obviously a big convenience for people who have profiles and friends spread across Facebook, MySpace, Orkut, Hi5, and the AOL, Yahoo, and MSN instant messaging clients.

But Facebook would rather users go through them. It has requested that Power.com use Facebook Connect instead of asking users for their log-in information and has been in discussions with the start-up for a month, according to The New York Times. But the Times reports the two failed to come to any resolution, and so Facebook decided to file suit. Power removed access to Facebook after the claim was filed.

It's true that Power.com does its thing without consent from the sites and services it taps into. But a month ago, when the company was making its first big push into the U.S., CEO Steve Vachani told the Times that Power.com was in fine legal standing because it only accesses other sites' content when a user voluntarily logs in. He likened Power.com's actions to the way social networks import contact lists from e-mail services or the way Meebo accesses users' instant message accounts.

Facebook seems to be feeling the pressure from FriendFeed, Twitter, and other social sites du jour--doing its own compiling of third-party sites. In May, it added feeds from Google Reader, Hulu, Last.fm, Pandora, StumbleUpon, and YouTube into its Mini Feed service, which had already included Delicious, Digg, Flickr, Picasa, and Yelp. And in August it launched Live Feed, a real-time stream of everything your Facebook friends are doing on the site, giving users a more centralized way to track their contacts' activity.

A screenshot of Power.com before Facebook was removed from the site's offerings.

(Credit: Rafe Needleman/CNET Networks)

Jennifer Guevin is assistant managing editor of CNET News. She focuses on science and green tech. But she also makes the occasional contribution to CNET's kitchen gadgets blog or writes about the latest Web distraction. Once a week, she takes the mic as host of CNET's Daily News Podcast. E-mail Jennifer.
Recent posts from Webware
Sites that help you lodge complaints
Google App Engine misfires
Microsoft: Bing needs to improve when news breaks
Google finally sued by makers of Finally Fast
Google Toolbar for IE speaks your language
Bing brings out the tweets
Google Search optimized for a mess of phones
Yahoo's Delicious proves Chrome extensions real
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (29 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by Spanwite January 3, 2009 11:20 AM PST
Maybe Facebook is just jealous, they didn't come up with this good Idea.
Not all your friends are at facebook, so this is the side where all of your friends are.
Facebook get over it, someone else had a very good idea.
Reply to this comment
by WeCanDoBIZ January 5, 2009 12:29 AM PST
It's not a good idea though. Social media aggregrators have been around for ever and all what Power.com does isn't even particularly elegant. The only thing going for it is the domain name.

As services open APIs and rely on other APIs to present news feeds from other sites, the winners in an increasingly open world will be those sites providing the most relevant context for its users. This will bring more users, cause them to stay and even potentially pursuade them to pay for an enhanced service.

Ian Hendry
CEO, WeCanDo.BIZ
http://www.wecando.biz
by FLAMBOYZ January 9, 2009 2:59 AM PST
You have got it wrong, Facebook is trying to protect your privacy rights. You disclose all your credentials, Secret Passwords to this site and compromise your security and if something goes wrong you blame Facebook for low security measures in place. Think Smart>>
- Be Smart Technically @ www.Flamboyz.com
by basraw March 20, 2009 9:22 AM PDT
flamboyz- EVERYONE seems to have NO PROBLEM divulging their YAHOO and HOTMAIL passwords to FACEBOOK to 'get their email contacts'.
by VizionQuest January 3, 2009 11:27 AM PST
This is ridiculous. Facebook does the same thing. Using that logic, Twitter should sue Facebook for stealing their status update concept. If Facebook is going to take this stance, Twitter, FriendFeed, and all the other services that Facebook infiltrates should band together and mount hundreds of lawsuits against Facebook and give them a taste of their own medicine to stop this kind of behavior.
Reply to this comment
by humanssssss January 3, 2009 11:43 AM PST
Can Power.com, the judge, and jury get money from Facebook for filing false charges. It seems like Facebook is throwing the entire kitchen sink of charges and hope one will fit or stall long enough that power.com loses enough money to stop pursuing to defend itself.

The law needs to add a penalty for people filing false charges.

I don't see in any way Facebook can win this case.
Reply to this comment
by Penguinisto January 4, 2009 9:21 AM PST
Many states do have laws against filing frivolous lawsuits - sadly, most don't.
by Benlofton January 3, 2009 12:02 PM PST
I can see why facebook would be upset that they didn't ask permission to use their site for their profit. But looking at power.com it is pretty cool how you can access all of the sites at once. This is the first i've heard of power.com.

Nice Article Jennifer!
Really Enjoyed it.
Reply to this comment
by foreyk January 3, 2009 12:11 PM PST
what's up with all this lawsuit..soon no one will be able to crate new site as we will be in risk of something...please give me more content! and let me chose my portal
Reply to this comment
by Hunnter2k3 January 3, 2009 12:17 PM PST
Now i feel even better for deleting my Facebook account.
And i say deleted, more like set it to super hidden. Think i could sue them for not fully removing it? (never had the option to from what i saw)

This, along with the still quite horrible design and the breastfeeding thing is why i dislike it so much.
Reply to this comment
by Alphax45 January 4, 2009 10:59 AM PST
You can delete your account by doing something that will get you banned. Just perform a major violation of there TOS and they will delete your account.

Just make sure you don't do something that may come back to haunt you!

K
by hmdz105 January 3, 2009 12:26 PM PST
How can anyone ever trust these social networks and unknown websites on the Internet and give them their confidential data, such as their email and passwords? How STUPID one can be to give his E-mail log in information to Facebook and let them do a simple task of "importing their address books"?

I have left tens of these websites that dared to ask me for my Gmail password and ID.... So must anyone else, cause we don't really who is behind that friendly looking website or know how they will use our account information and to what (bad) guys they might give them....
Reply to this comment
by SeizeCTRL January 3, 2009 12:33 PM PST
From Power.com

"We have been in discussions with Facebook to get their feedback on the best ways to work with them. Facebook would like sites to use Facebook Connect and they are continually open and available for feedback and comments on how to expand Facebook connects functionality. We support mutual industry cooperation to help responsibly create a borderless web. We are working with feedback from Facebook to implement Facebook connect inside of Power. We are also offering Facebook feedback on how to enhance and improve Facebook Connect functionality and will be launching a newer version of Power using Facebook connect in late January."

Sounds like whatever lawsuit was in play has already been resolved.
Reply to this comment
by tm_anon January 3, 2009 1:02 PM PST
Or you could use Flock, already takes care of myspace and facebook along with twitter and youtube and digg along with flickr. Plus, you don't have to go to a site to check on your friends, just open up the sidebar, check the current status then close the sidebar and you never left the page you were on. They're continually working on making it better and they do listen to your ideas. The only catch. Oh wait, there isn't one, it's firefox based so you already have all the addons you'd ever want.
Reply to this comment
by loose_screw January 3, 2009 1:12 PM PST
Yeah, and what if you want to use it on a public or friend's computer that doesn't have Flock installed? FAIL.
by loose_screw January 3, 2009 1:10 PM PST
I just checked power.com, and facebook has been removed as a login option.... Looks like the lawsuit threat worked after all?
Reply to this comment
by tonenj January 3, 2009 1:13 PM PST
Access all your profiles through one portal would be great. A lot of these sites have become too overgrown and impersonal though. I found a newsite that seems pretty cool. YeahOhYeah.com
Reply to this comment
by MafiaPenguin January 3, 2009 3:53 PM PST
...wow.

(Also..
who is credited for taking the pic?)
Reply to this comment
by jenguevin January 3, 2009 5:17 PM PST
This is a screenshot Rafe Needleman took when he wrote up Power.com a month ago for Webware.
by nixermac January 3, 2009 5:19 PM PST
I am not a big fan of social sites. I would rather say that I'm asocial. I am in touch with people I want to be with without these darn social sites. Why would I need to publish my info to the world. I am no Obama that I need to get my message across to the people for votes. I am perfectly fine without these sites.

Frankly like these sites will die sooner or later. They really do not serve any real purpose other than for narcissistic people harping away.
Reply to this comment
by codynews January 4, 2009 6:14 AM PST
How did some small company in brazil snag the domain power.com? That's what I want to know..
Reply to this comment
by go514 January 4, 2009 2:37 PM PST
I wonder if they would add richrebellion.com ? it's a new pretty cool social site for extreme stuff.
Reply to this comment
by Ian-Ellis January 4, 2009 6:34 PM PST
These guys aren't the first to do this - I have been using Gruvie.com for months. Gruvie does the same thing as power.com, but with an even better interface. They don't have as many sites yet, but I like the site better myself.

www.gruvie.com
Reply to this comment
by rythie January 5, 2009 6:49 AM PST
I think they will have the same problem power.com has since they use the username/password for facebook too instead of using the API.
by kutiY January 5, 2009 2:32 AM PST
I believe this is a dangerous precedent, our (Users of the web) profile and content will become property of different sites and social networks. This is a ridicules situation in a web that claims to put the user in the center....

So who's really in the center the user or the money making sites?

Have a good week,
Kuti.
Reply to this comment
by kutiY January 5, 2009 2:40 AM PST
I forgot to mention you -
http://www.voxox.com/

This is a software to aggregate almost everything.... :-)

SMS, mail, social network, file share, almost everything as I said....
by rythie January 5, 2009 6:53 AM PST
http://friendbinder.com also does this, but it uses the facebook's API and therefore doesn't require the user's username and password.
Reply to this comment
by RichardThomas January 5, 2009 10:52 PM PST
All these social network sites are going to blend together or disappear and will no longer be required as such with the implementation of the new Universal Information System Architecture it will be a world of Web Services, Gateways, Data Repositories and a web service integration tool. It allows anonymity with authenticated credentials. There is going to be an announcement about it I plan on getting a few select namspaces when they become available. http://informationsystem.me
Reply to this comment
by FLAMBOYZ January 9, 2009 2:53 AM PST
Facebook's market penetration globally is huge, you might be right in saying beware of the local guyz (Clones) who operate domestic (home country). But when comparing Globally, Facebook beats them all Hands Down
- WWW.FLAMBOYZ.COM
Reply to this comment
(29 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

About Webware

Say No to boxed software! The future of applications is online delivery and access. Software is passé. Webware is the new way to get things done.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Webware topics

Making sense of Windows 7 upgrades

faq The basics and the fine print on Microsoft's options for those eyeing the next operating system from Redmond.
• Full Windows 7 coverage

Road Trip 2009: Big Sky Country

CNET News reporter Daniel Terdiman takes his car full of gadgets to the Rockies and the Great Plains in search of tech, science, nature, and more.
• America's Fortress: Cheyenne Mountain

advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right