Facebook sues social-network aggregator Power.com
Facebook is suing Power.com, a Brazilian start-up that lets users access a number of social networks through one portal.
Facebook filed a lawsuit on Tuesday in U.S. District Court in San Jose, Calif., for copyright and trademark infringement; unlawful competition; and violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, CAN-SPAM Act, and the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, among other charges.
Power.com signs users into their various social networks and messaging clients and delivers the data from those sites and services to one page. For example, you can see all of your friends, their status updates, visit their profile pages, and even send a message to multiple friends on multiple social networks--all in one place. Last month, Webware editor Rafe Needleman described it as Meebo for social networks, and it's obviously a big convenience for people who have profiles and friends spread across Facebook, MySpace, Orkut, Hi5, and the AOL, Yahoo, and MSN instant messaging clients.
But Facebook would rather users go through them. It has requested that Power.com use Facebook Connect instead of asking users for their log-in information and has been in discussions with the start-up for a month, according to The New York Times. But the Times reports the two failed to come to any resolution, and so Facebook decided to file suit. Power removed access to Facebook after the claim was filed.
It's true that Power.com does its thing without consent from the sites and services it taps into. But a month ago, when the company was making its first big push into the U.S., CEO Steve Vachani told the Times that Power.com was in fine legal standing because it only accesses other sites' content when a user voluntarily logs in. He likened Power.com's actions to the way social networks import contact lists from e-mail services or the way Meebo accesses users' instant message accounts.
Facebook seems to be feeling the pressure from FriendFeed, Twitter, and other social sites du jour--doing its own compiling of third-party sites. In May, it added feeds from Google Reader, Hulu, Last.fm, Pandora, StumbleUpon, and YouTube into its Mini Feed service, which had already included Delicious, Digg, Flickr, Picasa, and Yelp. And in August it launched Live Feed, a real-time stream of everything your Facebook friends are doing on the site, giving users a more centralized way to track their contacts' activity.
A screenshot of Power.com before Facebook was removed from the site's offerings.
(Credit: Rafe Needleman/CNET Networks)
Jennifer Guevin is assistant managing editor of CNET News. She focuses on science and green tech. But she also makes the occasional contribution to CNET's kitchen gadgets blog or writes about the latest Web distraction. Once a week, she takes the mic as host of CNET's Daily News Podcast. E-mail Jennifer. 



Not all your friends are at facebook, so this is the side where all of your friends are.
Facebook get over it, someone else had a very good idea.
As services open APIs and rely on other APIs to present news feeds from other sites, the winners in an increasingly open world will be those sites providing the most relevant context for its users. This will bring more users, cause them to stay and even potentially pursuade them to pay for an enhanced service.
Ian Hendry
CEO, WeCanDo.BIZ
http://www.wecando.biz
- Be Smart Technically @ www.Flamboyz.com
The law needs to add a penalty for people filing false charges.
I don't see in any way Facebook can win this case.
Nice Article Jennifer!
Really Enjoyed it.
And i say deleted, more like set it to super hidden. Think i could sue them for not fully removing it? (never had the option to from what i saw)
This, along with the still quite horrible design and the breastfeeding thing is why i dislike it so much.
Just make sure you don't do something that may come back to haunt you!
K
I have left tens of these websites that dared to ask me for my Gmail password and ID.... So must anyone else, cause we don't really who is behind that friendly looking website or know how they will use our account information and to what (bad) guys they might give them....
"We have been in discussions with Facebook to get their feedback on the best ways to work with them. Facebook would like sites to use Facebook Connect and they are continually open and available for feedback and comments on how to expand Facebook connects functionality. We support mutual industry cooperation to help responsibly create a borderless web. We are working with feedback from Facebook to implement Facebook connect inside of Power. We are also offering Facebook feedback on how to enhance and improve Facebook Connect functionality and will be launching a newer version of Power using Facebook connect in late January."
Sounds like whatever lawsuit was in play has already been resolved.
(Also..
who is credited for taking the pic?)
Frankly like these sites will die sooner or later. They really do not serve any real purpose other than for narcissistic people harping away.
www.gruvie.com
So who's really in the center the user or the money making sites?
Have a good week,
Kuti.
http://www.voxox.com/
This is a software to aggregate almost everything.... :-)
SMS, mail, social network, file share, almost everything as I said....
- by FLAMBOYZ January 9, 2009 2:53 AM PST
- Facebook's market penetration globally is huge, you might be right in saying beware of the local guyz (Clones) who operate domestic (home country). But when comparing Globally, Facebook beats them all Hands Down
- Reply to this comment
-
(29 Comments)- WWW.FLAMBOYZ.COM