September 2, 2005 4:00 AM PDT

eBay at 10: Boon and bane

(continued from previous page)

hooked. The amount of material available even in the early days was shocking, and often at prices far below those found on Usenet or at shows, he said.

Omidyar himself saw the site as a community, at least as welcoming as the offline collectors' shows and swap meets. He often e-mailed regulars to see if they were happy, and set up forums where people could discuss auctions, eBay itself, or whatever else they wanted.

That's how Jim "Griff" Griffith, an early regular on the site and now one of eBay's chief spokesmen (his official title is dean of eBay Education), ended up working for the company. Griffith was a frequent poster on eBay's forums in 1996. Omidyar eventually called him, and hired him to be an evangelist and guide for people new to auctions.

"From the very beginning, the power of community was something bordering on ownership," said Griffith, who remains one of eBay's most public faces today. "Everyone felt very strongly about it from the very beginning. Nobody's indifferent about eBay."

Over time, that early rough-and-ready feeling started to change, however. Hasbro executive Meg Whitman was brought in to head the company in early 1998, and helped take eBay public later that year.

The next few years saw quick expansion into international markets, growth of features and audience at home, and the acquisition of online payment firm PayPal and other companies. Other companies, including Yahoo and publisher CNET Networks, started their own auctions site. But none ever rivaled eBay's reach.

eBay's expansion has drawn complaints from some users, however, who say that the auction site doesn't have the same community feel it once had. Continually rising fees have ruffled feathers. Some have complained that rules such as a ban on all firearms (including antique muskets) and a lack of appeals processes for cancelled auctions are too arbitrary.

eBay executives say they try hard to stay responsive to their users, even hosting a quarterly "Voices" program where they bring in different people from the community to discuss the site's operations. But they concede that listening to more than a million people is far more difficult than appealing to the original thousands.

"In the early days, the community was self-sustaining, if you let them do things their way," Griffith said. "It's still kind of the same. But when there are several million people involved, and different languages and different locations, creating a support structure to assist and moderate is something of a challenge."

Meanwhile, the offline culture has been wholly changed.

Many of the shows that housed collectors have closed. Brogan's PMA show in the San Francisco Bay Area has dropped from three convention center buildings to just one, with its attendance halved.

Griffith, who still collects antiques, said he has sympathy for the people who miss the past. But change, he added, was inevitable.

"I talk to a lot of collectors and dealers, and there's no doubt that eBay really shook that world," he said. "But if you position yourself as a middleperson in any market and remain static, then market changes can always overwhelm you. You have to be able to adapt."

Previous page
Page 1 | 2

See more CNET content tagged:
boon, eBay Inc., culture, margin, community


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
I never use eBay
Where I live we still have an old fashioned flea market every week, which seems much more human. eBay has become nothing more than a web based Walmart for used goods.
Posted by (174 comments )
Reply Link Flag
The problem is...
eBay charges too much and they have too many people selling the same crap. The same item is listed over and over and over again often from the same seller. Seller's rip you off with shipping charges. eBay's policies suck.

There is too much new stuff and not enough different and interesting used stuff. It has become a dumping ground for anyone with crap they want to unload instead of tossing in the trash.

Posted by Heebee Jeebies (632 comments )
Reply Link Flag
People are totally misleading buyers. I have been mislead many times. They will list an item as being one thing, but what you actually receive is totally different. eBay does not do enough to protect against fraudulant transactions.
Posted by PCCRomeo (432 comments )
Link Flag
Can't imagine not finding what you're looking for on eBay
I've bought and sold a lot of used computers, laptops, and parts over the years on eBay. Each year when I get a better computer I sell the old one on eBay. It's also a great place to buy used CDs. I've found some great used books and records that I'd looked for for years before I found them on eBay. I shop eBay every day. I make a couple of hundred bucks each year buying stuff at thrift shops and reselling on eBay. It's also a great place to shop for a car. I'm still looking for that 1985 Delta 88 with 57,000 miles on it in mint condition. Trouble is, they're always in Florida!
Posted by lingsun (482 comments )
Link Flag
Good ol' John
All his stories get corrected. There is a phrase for that. LAZY & IMCOMPETENT REPORTING.

Time to find a new job John..I am getting tired of your screw ups.....

(Go look up that in the Apple dictionary)
Posted by (23 comments )
Reply Link Flag
eBay's legacy at 10
No wonder they've reached the ripe old age of 10 when they condone theft and fraud! When you ask for assistance they find any old excuse not to help. (PayPal were no help either!)

I agree with an earlier comment that sellers do rip you off with extortionate shipping charges, but that's not the fault of eBay.
Posted by micksmixxx (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.