Version: 2008
  • On TechRepublic: Five super-secret features in Windows 7

Should Google be forced to hand over data?

Google's refusal to comply with a request by federal prosecutors for some of its search data has embroiled the company in a heated debate over online privacy. As part of an investigation into the Child Online Protection Act, the government requested search terms and URLs from four major search engines. Google was the only one to refuse, and a federal judge today said he would likely support the Justice Department in its demands. The DOJ has drastically reduced the amount of information it's asking for and has agreed to compensate Google for the time its developers spend on the project. But the company says the government has other options for obtaining search data and that asking for search keywords infringes on user privacy. Should Google be compelled to give up its search-term data?

Add a Comment (Log in or register) (18 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
The answer--> NO
by Aquilonious March 14, 2006 5:38 PM PST
While I absolutely detest child pornography, giving up our human rights in the "attempt" to research it is TOTALLY WRONG. Why don't these researchers just go on the Internet themselves and do their own research?

More and more there is is subtle blending of church % state and America seems to be asleep to it. We are having our rights taken away almost on a daily basis (Patriot Act, wiretapping, presidential archives being permanently closed, etc).

As Robert Redford has said, "Wake up, folks, because you could end up in a totalitarian nightmare, wondering what happened to your country."
Reply to this comment
The answer--> NO
by Aquilonious March 14, 2006 5:38 PM PST
While I absolutely detest child pornography, giving up our human rights in the "attempt" to research it is TOTALLY WRONG. Why don't these researchers just go on the Internet themselves and do their own research?

More and more there is is subtle blending of church % state and America seems to be asleep to it. We are having our rights taken away almost on a daily basis (Patriot Act, wiretapping, presidential archives being permanently closed, etc).

As Robert Redford has said, "Wake up, folks, because you could end up in a totalitarian nightmare, wondering what happened to your country."
Reply to this comment
Heck no.
by jackharvest March 14, 2006 7:24 PM PST
Why don't they go and collect their own data? Are they too lazy to even do that? Sheesh - they're probably being paid by Microsoft to go collect information. Can't we just accept how big Google is getting and get over it? There are so many BABIES out there thinking they're all going to kill us.

You get ads and spyware from visiting msn.com for heaven's sake, not google.
Reply to this comment
Heck no.
by jackharvest March 14, 2006 7:24 PM PST
Why don't they go and collect their own data? Are they too lazy to even do that? Sheesh - they're probably being paid by Microsoft to go collect information. Can't we just accept how big Google is getting and get over it? There are so many BABIES out there thinking they're all going to kill us.

You get ads and spyware from visiting msn.com for heaven's sake, not google.
Reply to this comment
Google Data
by webwilly1 March 14, 2006 7:53 PM PST
Of course not - we are being stripped of our privacy in the name of "Homeland Secuity".
Reply to this comment
Google Data
by webwilly1 March 14, 2006 7:53 PM PST
Of course not - we are being stripped of our privacy in the name of "Homeland Secuity".
Reply to this comment
Well, well
by 04Outlander March 14, 2006 8:55 PM PST
I'm actually surprised that this doesn't have a longer discussion thread than it does. Perhaps people don't care anymore? A local talk station was on this very subject today and a lot of people called in saying they didn't mind because terrorists may be out there searching for websites. People seem to rationalize something like this by immediately invoking 9/11. People who give up freedom for security deserve neither - well, that's the way we're headed at this point. The radio host warned that this is a slippery slope. If they find a popular search for something they don't like, then they are definitely going to be interested in who is searching that... back to courts, starting surveillance, etc... I agreed with the host that any concession on this is putting a wedge in the doorway to erosion of privacy and rights.
Reply to this comment
Well, well
by 04Outlander March 14, 2006 8:55 PM PST
I'm actually surprised that this doesn't have a longer discussion thread than it does. Perhaps people don't care anymore? A local talk station was on this very subject today and a lot of people called in saying they didn't mind because terrorists may be out there searching for websites. People seem to rationalize something like this by immediately invoking 9/11. People who give up freedom for security deserve neither - well, that's the way we're headed at this point. The radio host warned that this is a slippery slope. If they find a popular search for something they don't like, then they are definitely going to be interested in who is searching that... back to courts, starting surveillance, etc... I agreed with the host that any concession on this is putting a wedge in the doorway to erosion of privacy and rights.
Reply to this comment
Coincidence?
by tverhaar March 16, 2006 8:26 AM PST
It is an interesting coincidence that the news headlines are all
about a child pornography ring. It seems all to clear the Bush
administration is creating a lot od "noise" around this , like they
used 9/11, anthrax and every other scare-tactic, to get the
American people to do their bidding. If we allow ourselves to fall
prey to this scheme like we have so willing fallen into line on the
falacious 911 / Iraq connection - we are heade toward the
totalitarian regime the right wing is seeking. Three cheers for
Google for resisting. Shame on Yahoo for capitulating so easily.
Reply to this comment
Coincidence?
by tverhaar March 16, 2006 8:26 AM PST
It is an interesting coincidence that the news headlines are all
about a child pornography ring. It seems all to clear the Bush
administration is creating a lot od "noise" around this , like they
used 9/11, anthrax and every other scare-tactic, to get the
American people to do their bidding. If we allow ourselves to fall
prey to this scheme like we have so willing fallen into line on the
falacious 911 / Iraq connection - we are heade toward the
totalitarian regime the right wing is seeking. Three cheers for
Google for resisting. Shame on Yahoo for capitulating so easily.
Reply to this comment
GOOLE HANDING OVER GMAIL
by watfulscott March 17, 2006 6:16 AM PST
NO THEY SHOULD NOT
Reply to this comment
GOOLE HANDING OVER GMAIL
by watfulscott March 17, 2006 6:16 AM PST
NO THEY SHOULD NOT
Reply to this comment
GOOGLE HANDING OVER GMAIL
by watfulscott March 17, 2006 6:18 AM PST
NO THEY SHOULD NOT HAND OVER ANY PERSONL MAIL
Reply to this comment
GOOGLE HANDING OVER GMAIL
by watfulscott March 17, 2006 6:18 AM PST
NO THEY SHOULD NOT HAND OVER ANY PERSONL MAIL
Reply to this comment
(18 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement
News
News site map
Latest headlines
Contact News
News staff
Corrections
CNET blogs
Popular topics
Apple iPhone
Apple iPod
Cell phones
Dell
GPS
LCD TV
CNET sites
CNET Site map
CNET TV
Downloads
News
Reviews
Shopper.com
More information
Newsletters
CNET Mobile
Customer Help Center
RSS
CNET Widgets
About CNET