October 24, 2005 4:00 AM PDT
Separating myth from reality in ID theft
- Related Stories
Survey: ID theft hard to shake offJuly 26, 2005
Banks to share ID theft data with FTCJuly 6, 2005
Data leaks denting Web shoppers' confidenceJune 23, 2005
Credit card breach exposes 40 million accountsJune 17, 2005
Laptop theft puts data of 98,000 at riskMarch 29, 2005
Firms seek to reassure e-shoppers over securityFebruary 18, 2005
Study: Security fears daunt online shoppersFebruary 14, 2005
(continued from previous page)
nation's fastest-growing crime," he said. "The bad news is that it is not going away. Instead, it is holding steady."
The wide reports of ID theft have made people more vigilant, which all sides agree is a good thing. For one thing, "we need to do a better job of not keeping our paper available," said Charles, who recommends canceling paper statements from a bank, credit card issuer or a utility company.
Hayes monitors her credit card and bank account daily via the Internet and requests a credit report twice a year. Though she has not fallen victim to fraud from the U.C. Berkeley incident, she has had other experiences with identity theft.
Five years ago, someone bought a cell phone in her name, unbeknownst to her, until a collection agency came looking for money. It took some effort, but the mess was cleaned up, and her credit score restored.
"I think we need a whole better system," said Hayes. "Identifying people by their Social Security number simply isn't working."
Like many other careful consumers, Hayes now shreds all documents that contain sensitive information before she discards them. About 10 million shredders are sold every year worldwide, according to shredder manufacturer Fellowes of Itasca, Ill.
"We have seen significant sales growth," said John Fellowes, director for shredders at the company that bears his name. "The industry is up about 10 to 15 percent over the previous year."
But experts point out that, while shredding is smart, only 2.5 percent of ID theft cases last year was linked to dumpster diving. By contrast, 8 percent was traced back to the mailbox, a much cleaner way to find identifying information. Almost one-third of all fraud occurred because of a lost or stolen wallet.
As a result, though some fear of ID theft is justified, experts in the field stress that it should not dominate anyone's life.
"There are certain things that are just silly to do in today's world, like throwing out your tax documents and credit card statements in a plastic bag on your curb without first shredding them," said Monique Einhorn, an attorney at the FTC. Nevertheless, she added: "People have to balance their own paranoia and security issues against convenience."