April 18, 2007 6:00 AM PDT

Police blotter: Open Wi-Fi blamed in child porn case

Related Stories

Police blotter: Sensual masseuse sues ex-customer

April 11, 2007

Police blotter: No privacy in home PC brought to work

April 5, 2007

Police blotter: Ex-employee sued for deleting files

March 28, 2007

Police blotter: Unbrotherly love in Craigslist sex ad

March 21, 2007

Police blotter: Computer logs as alibi in wife's death

March 14, 2007

Police blotter: FBI's 'misleading' wiretap suppressed

March 7, 2007

Police blotter: Wife e-surveilled in divorce case

March 1, 2007

Police blotter: Convicted eBay robber loses appeal

February 21, 2007

Police blotter: Wireless voyeur appeals 56-year term

February 14, 2007

Police blotter: Texas student guilty in SSN hack

February 2, 2007

Police blotter: Heirs sue over will-making software

January 24, 2007

Police blotter: Antispam activist fights lawsuit

January 19, 2007

Police blotter: Detecting computer-generated porn?

January 3, 2007

Police blotter: Web at heart of ecoterror lawsuit

December 27, 2006

Police blotter: Google searches nab wireless hacker

December 20, 2006

Police blotter: Fired over 'Wicked Weasel' photo

December 8, 2006

Police blotter: Child porn in Web cache OK

November 24, 2006

Police blotter: Florida judges target Net sex

November 17, 2006

Police blotter: Prison inmate wants personal ad replies

November 10, 2006

Police blotter: Child porn blamed on computer virus

November 3, 2006

Police blotter: Web cookies become defendant's alibi

October 27, 2006

Police blotter: Flap over nude photos of Cameron Diaz

October 20, 2006

Police blotter: Prosecutors want reporters' hard drives

October 13, 2006

Police blotter: Sex offender demands Playboy on PC

October 6, 2006

Police blotter: When can cops seize your computer?

September 29, 2006

Police blotter: Alleged al-Qaida hacker goes to court

September 22, 2006

Police blotter: Cops raid Usenet provider over porn

September 8, 2006

Police blotter: Judge OKs text message use in drug case

September 1, 2006
Police blotter is a weekly News.com report on the intersection of technology and the law.

What: A Texas man, whose home is raided in search of child porn, points to an open Wi-Fi connection that is not password-protected. He is convicted of possession of child pornography but appeals the decision, asserting an invalid search warrant.

When: 5th Circuit Court of Appeals rules on April 11.

Outcome: Conviction and prison sentence upheld.

What happened, according to court documents:
In early 2004, a woman in New York state told her local police that she had received an instant message with sexually explicit images of minors. The instant message allegedly came from the Yahoo ID "famcple."

The complaint was forwarded to the FBI's Buffalo, N.Y., field office, which then sent a subpoena to Yahoo for information about the owner of the "famcple" screen name.

Yahoo reported that the owner's name was "Mr. Rob Ram" and that he had been using the IP address 24.27.21.6, which was in turn traced back to Time Warner Cable. Through a second subpoena, the FBI learned from Time Warner that the IP address in use at that time was linked to Javier Perez, who lived on Scenic Brook Drive in Austin, Texas.

The usual steps followed: Perez's home was raided, and a special agent carted off his belongings.

What makes this case relevant to Police blotter is that Perez challenged the search warrant as unlawful. He claimed the open, unsecured wireless network in use meant that roommates or "neighbors would have been able to easily use (his) Internet access to make the transmissions."

Although the FBI didn't know it when they raided his home, one of Perez's housemates was named Robert Ramos--suspiciously similar to the Yahoo account owner's name of "Mr. Rob Ram."

Nevertheless, the FBI did say it discovered CDs with child porn in Perez's area of the house. He was arrested and charged with one count of possession of child pornography. After a federal judge denied his motion to suppress the evidence seized during the search, Perez entered a conditional guilty plea. He was sentenced to four years and 9 months in prison.

He appealed to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, which last week affirmed the lower court's ruling.

One can read an excerpt from the discussion below, but what deserves focus is the appeals court's statement that it was "likely" that the user of the IP address was inside Perez's home. That was a consideration that originally helped lead to the issuing of a search warrant.

It is possible that the user was inside Perez's home. But if there was, in fact, an open 802.11 Wi-Fi network, it's also possible that it was being used by anyone within a radius of a few hundred feet.

In a worst-case scenario, it isn't hard to imagine someone using another person's unsecured wireless connection to send child porn to the FBI, and then watch the agents show up and seize the target's computers and perhaps arrest the person in the process. Such a scenario will become even more of a possibility when future wireless networking technologies offer longer ranges.

This is not a new issue. A Washington Post article in February described the case of an elderly woman whose open wireless connection had apparently been used to distribute child porn.

Excerpts from the 5th Circuit's opinion:
Probable cause does not require proof beyond a reasonable doubt; a magistrate need only have a substantial basis for concluding that a search would uncover evidence of wrongdoing. A magistrate's determination is entitled to deference by reviewing courts.

In this case it is clear that there was a substantial basis to conclude that evidence of criminal activity would be found at 7608 Scenic Brook Drive. The affidavit presented to the magistrate included the information that the child pornography viewed by the witness in New York had been transmitted over the IP address 24.27.21.6, and that this IP address was assigned to Javier Perez, residing at 7608 Scenic Brook Drive, Austin, Texas, 78736.

Perez argues that the association of an IP address with a physical address does not give rise to probable cause to search that address. He argues that if he "used an unsecure wireless connection, then neighbors would have been able to easily use (Perez's) Internet access to make the transmissions." But though it was possible that the transmissions originated outside of the residence to which the IP address was assigned, it remained likely that the source of the transmissions was inside that residence.

Perez also argues that evidence that illicit transmissions were made does not give rise to probable cause that physical evidence would be located at the residence. However, the New York witness stated that the images she observed appeared to be videos played on a television screen transmitted via a Webcam. There was therefore a basis to believe that the suspect would have such videos in his residence.

Moreover, Britt stated in his affidavit that, in his experience, persons interested in child pornography typically retain numerous images of child pornography as well as "material documenting the arrangements, the introduction, and tasks to consummate the acquisition of child pornography." Based on this information, there was probable cause to believe that physical evidence of violations of the child pornography laws would be located at 7608 Scenic Brook Drive.

See more CNET content tagged:
Police Blotter, warrant, wireless connection, Texas, IP address

Add a Comment (Log in or register) 19 comments
A rule of thumb
by SleeStaK911 April 18, 2007 7:08 AM PDT
Just don't keep kiddie porn around, and this sort of thing won't be an issue...
Was the KP they found this Rob guys'?
Reply to this comment
And the lesson is...
by icccm08 April 18, 2007 7:09 AM PDT
And the lesson is... secure your wi-fi network.
Reply to this comment View reply
Stupid of the FBI not check these scenerios in the first place
by knowles2 April 18, 2007 8:48 AM PDT
It is in fact more than possible, I have done it my self as a test to see if it was possible, and for fun on my next door neighbours computer, once you have access to computer from a remote source you can pretty much do anything, I have even manage to turn on a friend camera which was already plug into his computer and turn it on, over wifi.

The real issue hear is did FBI explore these issues, scenerios before the case came to court and did they ask these questions and run a proper investigation to explore these options, and if they did not why did not they. Say checking computer to see out side access and who been using the wi-fi pretty sure that if they run these check they would of got a witness up on the stand dis crediting the defendent version of events.

But from the story on this page it seem they did not do that which naive of the FBI, and could lead in to future, a lot of waste court time, , it they do not do these kind of investgations, it see people getting of on reasonable doubt, doing crime this way becomes more common and more known, which it will become.
Reply to this comment
The EU is essentially...
by OneWithTech April 18, 2007 8:51 AM PDT
...responsible for his/her wireless connection and the security
that goes along with it.

If we let people like this hide behind the excuse that there
wireless network was open and unsecure; then I might as well
hack the **** out of people that anger me and then when I get
get caught I will just blame it on one of the 50 neighbors that
are within range of my wireless signal because I "left it un-
secure".

You and only you, are responsible for the wireless networks that
you set up.

Justin
Tech01
www.tech01.net
Reply to this comment
Don't be a idiot
by d9930380 April 18, 2007 9:07 AM PDT
I'm all for personal responsibility but we have to keep in mind that someone is innocent till proven guilty.

In the general sense I don't think you can say for certain that someone did anything based on an IP address. They can be spoofed, hi-jacked or in this case come from a Wi-Fi network that can be accessed from anywhere.

However in this case where it was simply a means to obtain a search warrant then I don't see what the problem was. Offcourse this is enough to warrant a search warrant, it's the kiddie porn they found in his area that got him convicted.

The thing I wonder is how do they stop hackers that break into banks from a public Wi-Fi hotspot?
Reply to this comment View all 2 replies
Housemate what?
by slaw05 April 18, 2007 9:34 AM PDT
"Although the FBI didn't know it when they raided his home, one of Perez's housemates was named Robert Ramos--suspiciously similar to the Yahoo account owner's name of "Mr. Rob Ram."

"Nevertheless, the FBI did say it discovered CDs with child porn in Perez's area of the house."

Lets see.. the CDs they found could have belonged to the housemate Robert Ramos whose name was linked to the Yahoo account.

I guess the queston is what does "Perez's area of the house" mean. The roomy could have stashed the CDs in there.

I think the wireless is a non-issue because they can trace the Yahoo account to a specific computer in the household.
Reply to this comment View reply
Once again The Law is 10 steps behind
by Michael00360 April 18, 2007 1:50 PM PDT
It appears that the officers did not investigate the possibility of there being a user outside of the home using the open wi-fi network. Of course it does go without saying that it could be partially the defendant's fault for not securing his network. However, you would think that the police would have double checked before executing a raid based on the evidence they had.
Reply to this comment View reply
Zune, could be the Porn Tool of choice
by Sniche April 18, 2007 11:50 PM PDT
This has already happened not long after it launch. the way the
Zune works it would be hard to trace to the origin
Reply to this comment
access provisioning is the answer
by forgethis April 20, 2007 3:15 AM PDT
Hopefully, such incidents will drive the adoption of access and service provisioning solutions like Amazingports (http://www.amazingports.com) and fon (http://www.fon.com), which, while securing networks also go a step further and provide viable business models for hotspot owners.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.

More feeds available in our RSS feed index.

advertisement
Rackspace

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • News - Business Tech

    Chrome's JavaScript challenge to Silverlight

    The advent of Google's Chrome browser, software pros say, should spur a big speedup for JavaScript, which would raise its standing against Microsoft's Silverlight technology.

  • Gallery

    Photos: Top 10 reviews of the week

    Here are CNET Reviews' 10 favorite items from the past week, including the TiVo HD XL, Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H50, and the Dish Network's newest digital TV converter box.

  • News - Apple

    Apple watchers spot 'iPod Nano' pix, iTunes hints

    The rumor mill has long been predicting a longer, leaner new version of the iPod Nano, and now it's conjuring up some pictures.

  • Coop's Corner

    Chris Shipley 1, Internet lynch mob 0

    Demo's impresario goes public with a tart and smartly written riposte to the shoot-from-the-lip crowd.

  • Video

    Katie Couric reflects on first Webcast

    The political conventions are over and so are CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric's first series of Webcasts. CNET's Kara Tsuboi sat down with Couric on the final night of the Republican National Convention to discuss what she liked about Webcasting, some of her most memorable guests, and whether TV news will still be around by the next round of conventions.

  • News - Digital Media

    Creating a 'Facebook for spies'

    The CIA, FBI, and National Security Agency are reportedly testing a social-networking site designed for use by analysts within the 16 U.S. intelligence agencies.

  • Video

    YouTube plays party politics

    During the presidential campaigning four years ago, YouTube didn't even exist. Now it's a tool candidates must master to get their message across. CNET's Kara Tsuboi stops by the YouTube upload booths at the Democratic and Republican conventions to find out why Google's video site has such a big presence in Denver and St. Paul, Minn.

  • News - Gaming and Culture

    Are Demo and TechCrunch50 fragmenting their audiences?

    With both events scheduled to start Monday, many press, as well as venture capitalists and others are having to choose which one to attend.

  • News - Cutting Edge

    Execs predict next Google-like tech

    On eve of company's 10-year anniversary, researchers and business pundits speculate about what technologies might someday have as much impact as Google.

  • Gallery

    Images: The art of 'Spore' prototypes

    Will Wright and his Maxis team worked on dozens of prototypes to test the elements of their soon-to-be-released evolution game. Here's a sampling.

  • Crossfade

    The Standard, 'A Different Skin': Free MP3 of the Day

    Eschewing the danceable beats favored by many of its post-punk brethren, while opting instead for more ominous and insistent rhythms, is what makes the Standard visceral and engaging. Download a free MP3 of "A Different Skin" courtesy of CNET Download Mus

  • Green Tech

    Duke Energy to invest in mini solar power plants

    Can hundreds of rooftop solar panels collectively operate like a central power plant? Duke Energy launches $100 million distributed solar program to find out.