November 8, 2004 4:00 AM PST

Music sharing that's free and legal

A new twist on file sharing is holding out the promise of allowing millions of people to share their song collections online, at no cost--and without legal risk.

The trick involves marrying peer-to-peer technology with Internet radio. Using that combination, some companies are creating powerful tools that automatically broadcast people's private playlists onto the Web. The output is then pulled together into a searchable database that lets listeners find the music they want, when they want it.

Safeguards are in place to prevent unauthorized downloads, ensuring copyrights are honored. But if the technology behind the networks keeps improving and the number of people using them keeps growing, the services could one day turn into something akin to free, on-demand request radio.

Few companies have staked out this territory yet. A handful of pioneers--including Apple Computer, Virgin Digital and upstarts Mercora and Live 365--are just beginning to see demand.

Apple lets users of its iTunes music jukebox software share playlists that are streamed them over a local area network. By contrast, Mercora runs a Web-based network of roughly 8,000 broadcasters worldwide. Those broadcasters devise their own playlists, which are served up to 175,000 to 200,000 listeners connected over the Internet.

Mercora's software also automatically streams music from an individual's hard drive, making each member of the network a broadcaster.

"We're doing for music what Google did for the Web," Mercora CEO Srivats Sampath said.

Peer-to-peer radio is the latest step in a long line of efforts to turn the Web into an on-demand jukebox without running afoul of copyright law. In the past, such projects have caused tension with record industry executives, who turned to the courts to shut down Napster and are now bringing lawsuits against individual file swappers.

Those legal worries have been less evident in the Net radio sphere. Still, the music industry has taken steps to rein in interactive services that might sap CD and digital download sales.

During the dot-com boom, companies such as Launch Media and Musicmatch (both now owned by Yahoo) and MTVi all vied to create interactive radio services. These provided substantial listener control, which ultimately lead to legal fights with the record industry.

New copyright fight?
Most interactive Net radio services are now subscription-based, which allows a different set of legal rules to be observed. Leading examples of these services include RealNetworks-owned Rhapsody and Napster's all-you-can-eat streaming service.

Newer software lets people listen to what others are broadcasting from their hard drives, locally or internationally, thereby increasing variety.

The most widely used is Apple's iTunes, which originally let people browse and listen to each others' music collections over the open Internet. Later, it limited this feature to local networks.

Initially, Mercora said it expected to sell music via a download service resembling that of Apple's iTunes Music Store. The switch to an Internet broadcast network allowed the company to take advantage of the distinct manner in which the law treats music streamed on the Internet.

Broadcasting fees are set by the U.S. Copyright Office rather than by the record labels and are relatively cheap--they come to about 1/7th of a penny per listener, or about $1,429 per million people. As a result, Mercora says it can afford to pay the fee on behalf of the broadcasters on its network, with the cost offset through advertising sales.

"The big nut we had to crack is how to do this legally," Sampath said. "The law says you can broadcast as long as you pay. Fine, we will pay you."

In the end, this creates a beneficial symbiotic relationship between all the parties. Home broadcasters get a creative outlet, but they don't personally incur any broadcasting fees. For its part, Mercora can function like a broadcaster or cable network, with future revenue coming from selling ad space and subscription services. But it doesn't have to buy or maintain a content library, unlike a regular media network. It does, however, have to spend money on maintaining a bank of servers.

The benefit for listeners is access to music at no cost. Right now, users only have to download the software to join the network and can

Page 1 | 2


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
Mercora is Amazing!
I am a long time & loyal member of Mercora. Not only is Mercora about sharing music but it's about community and it has one of the best if not THE BEST online community on anywhere. The staff are involved with the community and make an amazing effort to listen to everyones oppinions and act on them for the betterment of Mercora. The program itself though still in Beta testing is simply amazing, easy to use, free but most of all FUN!

This article was a great read and did a great job of explaing the options and what is around the corner and Mercora is it!

Posted by (3 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Will not be free forever... What about Sat radio etc?
They have to pay license fees, so I imagine once they are past the "startup" phase they will start to charge users. But what will the market bear? We already have 2 Audio Sat companies so eager for revenue that they are slasing price everythwere. For $12.95 <a class="jive-link-external" href="" target="_newWindow"></a> you can get sat radio and steaming udio to your desktop for free (XM charges more) Or You can pay $499 lifetime fee for it. I dont own equipment or stock in the company... Just wondering how far it will go when it comes down to business.
Posted by kieranmullen (1070 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Some services may not be free
There may be certian thigns that are not free. For instance Mercora currently provides you not only with streaming audio, but video, Among a host of other features... The music will always be free. But i dont mind charging extra for the streaming video content... or maybe adding in a download service much akin to itunes.
Posted by dfxshadow (2 comments )
Link Flag
Get up to speed!
And another thing!

Get up to speed guys! Start offering G2, G1, and Edonkey Hash links to download and hash codes to compare final files besides just the http links.
Posted by kieranmullen (1070 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Mercora is awesome! Indeed.
I must agree with Stec, I have been around mercora for quite some time.. Stec, Method, Sauce, Atri, Hell just about all of the developers, have always stayed in touch and listened to our feedback, Stec and myself have contributed alot to the overal outlook of mercora, How many programs listen to the users like this. While were not officially part of the team. We are part of the family.. Long Live MERCORA!!!
Posted by dfxshadow (2 comments )
Reply Link Flag
outlook of mercora
<a class="jive-link-external" href="" target="_newWindow"></a>
Posted by Ubber geek (325 comments )
Link Flag
Replay Music does this for Streaming Music
You can do this with "traditional" internet radio stations like Yahoo Launch, using Replay Music, and it's 100% legal, too.

Check out to see how it works.
Posted by applian (13 comments )
Reply Link Flag
The Paradise for the Music Lovers
I think that it will be the paradise to all the music lovers, and i'm one of their. I can't work without music, specially hip-hop, r&#38;b and rock music. When this project be real, we'll see a new age for the digital music, because it will be the solution to all the music lovers that want to listen your favorite songs for free, without braking the laws. Congratulations to this experts, because they're ready to write a new pharagraph in the digital music history, and for us, the music lovers, they'll be our heroes...
Sorry about my english, but i'm latin, i'm from Guatemala City, my name is Roberto Mejía, Webmaster and Multimedia Designer. See you in the future CNet readers!
Posted by robertomejia (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag
Tunefeed free music sharing is a free music sharing system. It?s similar to Mercora, but without the download. is focussed on friend recommendations and are also licensed by the recording industry. Custom playlists and search facilities enable you to find all sorts of new stuff. is fully legal free music sharing.
Posted by Tunefeed (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.