September 29, 2005 12:23 PM PDT

Motorola CEO: Apple 'to build a smart phone'

Related Stories

Motorola Q, pink Razr for the holidays

September 23, 2005

With Nano and Rokr, Apple makes itself heard

September 10, 2005
CAMBRIDGE, Mass.--Motorola CEO Ed Zander on Thursday downplayed disparaging remarks he made last week about Apple Computer's newest music player and predicted that the Mac maker will build its own cell phone.

Zander was quoted as dismissing Apple's new iPod Nano at a Silicon Valley gathering Friday, saying, " Screw the Nano. What the hell does the Nano do? Who listens to 1,000 songs?"

The comments seemed odd, given the long-standing relationship between the companies. More than 20 years ago, Apple used Motorola's 68000 processor in the Lisa. And earlier this month, the two companies shared a stage to introduce Motorola's Rokr cell phone, which runs Apple's iTunes software.

After his presentation Thursday at Technology Review's Emerging Technologies Conference at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, CNET asked Zander whether there's a rift between the companies. In particular, is he happy with the partnership that produced the Rokr? And did Apple upstage the Rokr by introducing the Nano at the same press conference?

Zander said his comments about the Nano were "taken completely out of context. We have a great relationship with Apple. I've known Steve Jobs for 15 years. Sure, there is some tension there. We have the Rokr, and they have the Nano. They are a competitor as well as a partner."

He also added fuel to persistent speculation about Apple's interest in producing its own phone. "And we know that they are going to build a smart phone--it's only a matter of time."

On other fronts, Zander, a former Sun Microsystems executive who took the helm at Motorola nearly two years ago, demonstrated the recently released Rokr phone and showed prototypes of several advanced phones that also play music and are slimmer than current models.

Zander demonstrated one unnamed prototype device that can receive and play music videos. The device flawlessly played a Gloria Estefan video but would not shut off. Zander tried to silence the wayward device by unsuccessfully attempting to remove the battery. He finally called an offstage assistant for help.

On a more serious note, Zander bemoaned the lack of engineering students in the United States. "One big issue is our investment in education. We're not pushing enough science and math. Go around the world, and see the kind of national programs to push the sciences. We ought to own biotech, high tech and other areas," he said.

While Motorola is making strides in the design of new, smaller and more powerful devices, Zander said the biggest roadblock to future systems isn't the hardware. "Our biggest challenge in mobile delivery is in software such as DRM" (digital rights management). He laid blame for some of those software challenges at the feet of proprietary software makers. Motorola, he said, has embraced open source, Java and Linux, among other software. "We're moving from proprietary platforms," he said.


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
Poor choice of comments...
Motorola needs to have its CEO recalibtrated. The ROKR is not
that much of a cell phone, and with only a 100 tune capacity, it's
no competition to any iPod model, or anyone else's MP3 player.
Sure, Motorola will sell a bunch of the things. Just think of all the
Q-Ray bracelets that have been sold, and the ROKR actually

But not for me. I have my Sony Cybershot, my iPod Mega, and
once in a while, I even carry my cell phone - if I can find it. It was
around here someplace maybe last week or so.
Posted by Earl Benser (4310 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Why focus on math and science education
in the U.S. when every company is so focused on outsourcing technical work? I think these companies are crying foul because they are tired of competing with each other for the few thousand PhDs that graduate each year.
Posted by thewill587 (2 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Hey Zander, Sun laid me off for an Indian counterpart
Ed Zander's comment about tech education is a joke. My entire
department at Sun, consisting of some of the best engineers I've
ever worked with, were laid off and replaced by a group in India
for half the cost. It isn't bad education in the US, it's the greed
and shortsightedness. Sun wants it's employees to work for dirt
wages, and when they don't, they whine about not being able to
find educated engineers, and then use that as an excuse to
outsource.... What a hypocrite.
Posted by HedgesX (4 comments )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.