February 19, 2008 1:49 PM PST
Microsoft waiting for formal rejection from Yahoo
- Related Stories
Microsoft's big bid for YahooSeptember 10, 2008
Yahoo's Jerry Yang is no Bill GatesFebruary 16, 2008
Memo to Microsoft: Yahoo's A-listFebruary 13, 2008
- Related Blogs
Microsoft eyes proxy fight for Yahoo
February 19, 2008
Yahoo and News Corp. -- the match made in hell
February 15, 2008
Yahoo faces shareholder suit, in talks with News Corp.
February 13, 2008
Having been informally rejected by Yahoo, the software maker is awaiting a formal rejection before going ahead with its next move, likely appointing its own slate of directors, a move that it has until March 14 to make.
While Microsoft could just raise its bid, one source says the company doesn't see a benefit in bidding against itself until Yahoo shows its willingness to come to the bargaining table. According to The New York Times' DealBook, Microsoft is ready to approve going forward with a proxy battle.
Such a formality may seem surprising, given Yahoo has publicly stated that Microsoft's unsolicited buyout bid first valued at $44.6 billion, or $31 a share, undervalued the company. But a formal step likely is needed to put the ball back into Microsoft's court.
"Yahoo has been radio silent since the offer was made," said a source familiar with Microsoft's thinking. "Until Yahoo is prepared to respond, I don't know why (Microsoft) would want to raise the bid. It would be like bidding against ourselves."
But one source familiar with Yahoo's thinking and the "radio silence" noted: "Sometimes in negotiations, you have to bid against yourself."
Basically, the software giant is waiting for a formal rejection letter from Yahoo, which would include typical "Dear John" merger language like: We reject your offer and think we are worth a lot more than what you are offering. Come sign a nondisclosure agreement and we will show you why we are worth a lot more.
"Yahoo needs to show a willingness to engage and have a conversation and, in less than 24 hours, we would be available to respond," the source familiar with Microsoft's thinking told CNET News.com.
However, "Yahoo may not want to engage until it's pretty certain it has explored all its other options," said one investment banker who is not involved in the transaction.
The banker surmised that Yahoo may try to argue two points on its lack of a formal response. One is that without having formally rejected Microsoft's offer, it can avoid potential shareholder lawsuits for failing to do the deal. And should Microsoft launch a hostile proxy fight or tender offer, Yahoo may try to go to the Delaware Chancery Court (where it is incorporated) with the claim such actions should be delayed, because it is still considering all its options and that is why it has not formally responded to the software giant.
An attorney who declined to be named was not aware of any similar situations in which a target company did not issue a formal response to an unsolicited bid. And the attorney could not offer any strategic advantages on why such action would be taken to forgo a formal response.
"Maybe Yahoo concluded a letter wouldn't matter and, at this point, 19 days since Microsoft made its offer, it would be hard for them to come back and say, 'by the way, your deal undervalues us,'" the attorney said.
A Yahoo spokeswoman referred questions regarding a formal rejection letter back to its public statement that it issued on February 11. A Microsoft spokesman declined to comment.
Meanwhile, a report surfaced Tuesday that Microsoft is planning to authorize a proxy fight later this week.
"We would prefer to do a friendly transaction," the source familiar with Microsoft's thinking told CNET News.com.
Microsoft realizes retaining Yahoo's employees is an important part of the deal and is well aware of key members who would be essential to an integration of the two companies, the source said.
"Efforts are being made to do just that (with respect to retention)," the source said.
Yahoo had no immediate comment in regard to any pending proxy fight with Microsoft. A spokesman for Microsoft reiterated that the company is "aware of its options."
Some Microsoft investors also support the deal, the source said. Matrix Asset Advisors, for example, said it would not only support Microsoft's existing bid but also approve of a slight increase of $33 to $35 a share. A number of Yahoo's 20 largest institutional investors also own Microsoft stock, with a majority of those shareholders having larger positions in the software giant's stock. Matrix, although it is not in the top 20, falls into the category of having dual ownership.
Microsoft's support comes amid a 13 percent drop in its share price since the bid was announced on February 1. The software giant is making the move to better compete with Google in the areas of Web search, online advertising, and Web-hosted services. Yahoo is the perennial No. 2 to Google, but would give Microsoft a huge audience.
Last week, a report published in the New York Post suggested that Yahoo's board was splintering on its assessment of the Microsoft offer.