June 7, 2001 2:25 PM PDT

Microsoft, Red Hat set open-source debate

After claiming last month that the open-source model is flawed and "responsible for releasing unhealthy code," Microsoft Senior Vice President Craig Mundie is set to debate the issue at an open-source conference in July.

Mundie is expected to explain why Microsoft's vision of "shared source" software, where the software giant makes the source code of some of its products available to customers and partners while still maintaining the intellectual property rights, is better than open source. An open-source application is one where people have the right to see and change its code and are bound to freely distribute any changes they make.

Michael Tiemann, chief technical officer of Red Hat, will present the case for open source. Red Hat sells a popular version of Linux, the open-source operating system and rival to Microsoft's Windows. The debate will take place at the O'Reilly Open Source Convention in San Diego, Calif., July 26.

Mundie attracted a storm of criticism after making his original comments at New York University's School of Business. In a speech, he argued that open-source code can be a security risk. He also said developers writing and releasing open-source software such as the Linux operating system would not be able to create powerful, easy-to-use programs that are broadly accessible to consumers.

In a report issued around the time of his speech, Mundie also claimed that the companies who offer open-source software to consumers don't have a valid business model.

"A common trait of many of the companies that failed is that they gave away for free or at a loss the very thing they produced that was of greatest value--in the hope that somehow they'd make money selling something else," wrote Mundie.

Linus Torvalds, open-source advocate and creator of Linux, was unimpressed by Mundie's comments and accused him of disregarding the basic principles of intellectual property that have driven science for hundreds of years.

"Mundie throws all that away because he wants Microsoft to own it all and to make tons of money from it," Torvalds said in an interview last month.

Staff writer Graeme Wearden reported from London.

 

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot

Discussions

Shared

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.