December 12, 2009 5:30 PM PST

Legal battles rage over e-book rights to old books

The ownership of the e-book rights to older titles is a growing source of conflict in the publishing industry.
(From The New York Times)

The story "Legal battles rage over e-book rights to old books" published December 12, 2009 at 5:30 PM is no longer available on CNET News.

Content from The New York Times expires after 7 days.

13 comments

Join the conversation!
Add your comment (Log in or register)
30 years. That is where copyrights should be ratcheted back to... would solve a ton of problems.
Posted by Random_Walk (7902 comments )
Reply Link Flag
30 years? Try less than that..... 10 years, max, seeing as how most books are read and gone in that time frame.
Now, they COULD have a thing that renews the copyright if you have RELEASED the book in some form in the past 10 years, for another 10 years.... up to 4 times or until you die.
Posted by Lerianis4 (2979 comments )
Link Flag
Copyright used to last 27-30 years... up until Disney and co. decided that they haven't milked Mickey Mouse enough, 30 years used to be perfectly sufficient, and no one had any complaints. Authors whose copyrights ran out simply wrote more books. Movie makers would simply re-cast/re-interpret plots into new and better forms. Musicians would simply come up with new music.

Now, we have a whole generation of authors, movie-makers, and musicians whining about royalties as if they had some sort of right to creative works that should have died a natural death a long time ago.

Now, we see descendants of authors shouting as if they had some sort of aristocratic right to the work of their parents/uncles.aunts/etc. , and corporations acting as if someone's long-spoken idea is a thing to be monetized until Judgment Day.

...and people wonder why the latest movies, books, and songs simply suck. It's because everyone is afraid of getting dragged into court, so they're more focused on avoiding than they are on creating, and the results visibly suffer.
Posted by Random_Walk (7902 comments )
Link Flag
Books can be found on the web free of charge. It's easy to find.
Posted by redmarine (351 comments )
Reply Link Flag
So to para-phrase the article "GREED" and "OLD BUSINESS ATTEMPTS TO REMAIN RELEVANT".

I find the whole digital book industry an utter joke. Any slackjaw can buy a $20 scanner and if the scanner doesn't come with OCR software buy software for $5. At that point they can digitize as many books as they want and save it into an open office writer file.. poof they can instantly save it to PDF.

The fact that Old Publishing companies claim that processing and conversion costs $15-40k per book (or worse per 50 pages) is a total joke. The same can be said with the rest of the entertainment/media industry. Coning artists and content creators into believing that they are still relevant and required to accomplish distribution of the artist's works.

Over the next 15-20 years as new artists come into the market I am sure they will have grown up in the digital age and will inherently know how irrelevant the old guard is.
Posted by zeroplane (286 comments )
Reply Link Flag
I could make a PDF of a book in decent quality by cutting apart an older book in one day for less than 100 dollars. Actually, I have done that with hentai mangas..... cutting the books apart, scanning the pictures in very high resolutions, and then zipping up the .jpeg's and converting the .jpeg's into a PDF using ACDSee Pro 3.
Posted by Lerianis4 (2979 comments )
Link Flag
copyright=min(out of print, 10 years) not available for software

patents=min(if (used in commerce 20yrs),else(3 years). not available for software, plants, genes, ...
Posted by blevinsdavidlester (15 comments )
Reply Link Flag
I'll stick to Book 1.0

No batteries, nothing to break, works when wet and dries, doesn't kill me financially if lost or stolen, and when done, I can go to the used Book 1.0 store and trade it for other Book 1.0's
Posted by Gromit801 (384 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated.
Posted by gfsdfge (131 comments )
Link Flag
Hardcopy certainly does have those advantages. For me, though, I like the portability. I have an old PocketPC currently that fits in my pocket and when I'm on the long train commute I have to make a couple days a week, I enjoy the convenience of not having to decide what mood I'm in ahead of time. Instead I can choose from dozens of different books right at that moment, and if i get bored with one, I can flip over to another, without having to carry dozens of them in my laptop bag.

For people who enjoy reading at home (as I sometimes do as well) hardcopy is perfectly fine, but for on the road convenience, e-books are the future.
Posted by bookshire (196 comments )
Link Flag
@bookshire You are right however I don't like the whole idea of having to own digital books at all. I am willing to pay a subscription that opens me up to read any book I want, but I will never pay the same price for digital as I would hard copy. Hard copy publishers pay in resources per book, digital they only pay once and just spit out another copy in the time it takes for someone to download it. Books are one thing that should go in the cloud, makes way more sense than storing your latest documents with companies that can read it and maintain copies at any time, bad enough google, M$, and any other web email can read what I send and receive. I do applaud google on their attempt to digitize for free books that don't get read very much, they are protecting our history by doing so, anyone that tries to retain a copyright for too long, sorry we are going to copy and distribute in a fair manner whether you like it or not.
Posted by shootfirst (286 comments )
Link Flag
@shootfirst

Hmmm...an online library. Interesting idea. I wonder if brick and mortar libraries will move in this direction over time.
Posted by bookshire (196 comments )
Link Flag
The Amazon Online Reader now has over 360,000 books, newspapers, magazines, and blogs available available, including more than 101 of 112 current New York Times® Best Sellers. I know music copyright expire every 70 years., now I here an authors copyright expires every 30 years.

AMZN CEO Jeff Bezos has a button under most paper backs, newspapers and magazines subscriptions asking the viewer to click a link if the buyer want the illustration in a kindle format. Soon Publishers Clearing House and others will se that they are loosing money when they are not going accord to the Kindle era of today.
Posted by Reader_Admin (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag
 

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

Inside CNET News

1-2 of 11

Scroll Left Scroll Right

What's Hot

Discussions

Shared

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.

Markets

Market news, charts, SEC filings, and more

Related quotes

Dow Jones Industrials (-0.69%) -89.23 12,801.23
S&P 500 (-0.69%) -9.31 1,342.64
NASDAQ (-0.80%) -23.35 2,903.88
CNET TECH (-0.58%) -11.91 2,032.01
  Symbol Lookup