June 14, 2001 9:35 AM PDT
House leader concerned about Carnivore
- Related Stories
A gripe about CarnivoreMay 21, 2001
Report finds risk but supports Carnivore email surveillanceNovember 22, 2000
Critics blast FBI's first release of Carnivore documentsOctober 2, 2000
DOJ picks university to study CarnivoreSeptember 26, 2000
Armey, R-Texas, joins a chorus of politicians and privacy advocates voicing concern over DCS1000, the technology more commonly known as Carnivore. Carnivore is a system that is installed at Internet service providers to monitor e-mail from criminal suspects.
"I respectfully ask that you consider the serious constitutional questions Carnivore has raised and respond with how you intend to address them," Armey's letter read. "This is an issue of great importance to the online public."
The Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) has voiced the loudest concern over the system during the past year. EPIC claimed that Carnivore could be used to monitor the innocent and sued the FBI for not providing enough information about the system.
Leaders of the Senate and House Judiciary Committees have publicly criticized the program. Last September, the House Judiciary Committee approved a bill that would restrict Carnivore to the same protections for voice conversations under the federal wiretap law.
In response to concerns, the Department of Justice posted information about Carnivore on its Web site, and selected IIT Research Institute, an arm of the Illinois Institute of Technology, to undergo a review of Carnivore's technology.
In Armey's letter to Ashcroft, the Congressional leader cited Monday's Supreme Court's ruling that thermal-imaging devices used by police officers without a search warrant would compromise privacy. Using Carnivore to monitor correspondence could also be categorized as a search and require a warrant, Armey said.
"It is reasonable, then, to ask whether the Internet surveillance system...similarly undermines the minimum expectation that individuals have that their personal electronic communications will not be examined by law enforcement devices unless a specific court warrant has been issued," Armey wrote.
News.com's Rachel Konrad contributed to this report.