November 3, 2004 11:26 AM PST

Apple blocks music sales to older iTunes

As it had said it would, Apple Computer is forcing customers using older versions of iTunes to upgrade to recent versions if they want to purchase music online.

Later on Wednesday, Apple will stop allowing people running version 4.2 to purchase songs from the iTunes Music Store.

"As of today, customers will need to use one of the three most recent versions of iTunes--4.7, 4.6 or 4.5--to continue purchasing and downloading songs," Apple said in a statement provided to CNET

The company, which had warned users the move was coming, downplayed the impact of the move.

"Less than 5 percent of all iTunes customers are using the old iTunes 4.2 version, so asking them to upgrade to the free iTunes 4.7 is no big deal," Apple said.

When Apple released version 4.5 in April, the company disabled support for a number of programs that tried to expand iTunes music sharing beyond the streaming of music files. And with the new version 4.7 that Apple introduced last week, the company quietly disabled support for iPodDownload, a program that let customers copy music from an iPod into their iTunes library.

Apple touted the benefits of later versions, including features such as iMix, Party Shuffle and CD Insert Printing. The version also is required to support the features of the iPod Photo.


Join the conversation!
Add your comment
Apple cored
From several discussions on other forums, the reason Apple did this was to protect itself. Seems the ipoddownload plugin that was forbidden (Apple legal went after the author and had it pulled) was somehow disabled in the latest 4.7 release.
So no copying back and forth of files from iPod to other macs (that is what Apple fears and thus Rip.Mix.Burned).
Personally, folks that have Windows can do this with other software. And 4.7 has its fair share of issues.
Apple is protecting itself. Not its customers.
Posted by Below Meigh (249 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Trivial fix
Anyone who cares to continue using iPod Download with the
new version of iTunes can patch it with trivial effort. There are
two steps. Get the program HexEdit through
or google to find it (it is a free program). In the open menu of
HexEdit navigate to Applications -> iTunes -> Contents ->
MacOS -> iTunes. With that file open search for the string "iPod
Download". Notice that iTunes depends on matching a string in
order to block the functionality so change the string to any other
string that has exactly the same length and save the result.

It would be possible to write a program to do this patch but I
don't know if people would be inclined to use such a solution. It
really isn't hard to do it yourself (using HexEdit) and see exactly
what is being changed.

So you have the choice of using 5 minutes to make this change
or rise up with torches and pitchforks and storm the castle. I
think applying the patch makes more sense.
Posted by Steve Bryan (92 comments )
Link Flag
Apple blocks sales to older Itunes
What happens to those folks for whatever reason are stuck using OS9. Despite what apple thinks there are many folks still using Machines that can't use OSX. Remeber unlike PC's that have to been thrown away every 8-12 months and have gotten price down to a deluxe TV or VCR. Mac oftem last for 10 years or more. Often older people that can't afford new Apple equipment are left holding the bag.
Posted by pjonesCET (42 comments )
Reply Link Flag
Apple drains it's rich user base once again.
I don't think older people fit the apple bill today. Those are for people who want to simply look good (in their own eyes) and have lots of money.

I still run really old software on my XP box. Its a good thing. Forcing people to upgrade isnt the best plan Id say. Apple has been doing this for years. Its nice being able to run any software on any version of Windows (just about anyway).

---Remeber unlike PC's that have to been thrown away every 8-12 months and have gotten price down to a deluxe TV or VCR. Mac often last for 10 years or more. ----

What a foolish comment. Not only is most of the hardware the same, I have boxes very old that run just fine  AND run all the newest software. Those run slow but hey most are 7-10 years old!

More trolling Cupertino zealots 
Posted by (35 comments )
Link Flag
iTMS never was an OS 9 option.
The iTunes Music Store was only ever an option for users of
iTunes 4, which was released the same day as the Music Store,
or higher. The most current version of iTunes that even ran on
OS 9 is 2.0.4.
Posted by ScifiterX (69 comments )
Link Flag
Boycott Apple
Whose Got The Power? Apple or You?

I say we just boycott Apple! The only reason Apple iTunes is as successful as they are is because they were the first, and people have a hard time switching.

Why don't we all just take a leap of faith and just switch already. There are other music sites out there that are far better and I am sure more options are still to come. I have heard good things about Rhapsody... maybe if Apple users switch to Rhapsody, Apple will have second thoughts about how they treat their customers and stop being such a selfish bully.

<a class="jive-link-external" href="" target="_newWindow"></a>
Posted by (59 comments )
Reply Link Flag
A pretty idea starting to get ugly.
One of the nice things about MP3 files and the iPod is the freedom the provide. Freedom to transport your music, carry your files, timeshift, etc.

Since the iPod supports more-or-less standard open formats, that was a good thing too.

Recent moves to make the iPod more restrictive, more closed and less flexibile really make the platform a lot less appealing for me. I should note I own 2 iPods and do not bootleg songs (I use it mostly for timeshifting or somtimes listening to my own CD's).
Posted by (1 comment )
Reply Link Flag

Join the conversation

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

What's Hot



RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.