A voyage inside the iPod Shuffle

A look under the hood of Apple Computer's iPod Shuffle shows the company is making music with two chips.

IDC analyst IdaRose Sylvester recently dissected a 512MB iPod Shuffle, purchased at retail, to determine what the tiny music player is made of. Her report, published earlier this month, reveals that Apple used two main chips spread over two separate circuit boards to foster the compact design of the music player, which was introduced in January.

The Shuffle Sylvester dismantled was based around an MP3 decoder chip from SigmaTel and a flash memory chip from Samsung--which means the device uses many fewer chips than hard-drive-based iPods, she wrote.

The MP3 decoder, mounted to one board, takes charge of a multitude of functions. Its handles music, including the playing of MP3, AAC and Audible format files. It harbors a USB 2.0 converter, SDRAM for buffering data and a headphone driver.

The chip is capable of handling Windows Media music file decoding and voice recording, and could send images to an LCD screen and work with an FM tuner, she wrote. Those features go unused in the Shuffle, though.

The Shuffle's Samsung flash memory chip is mated to a separate circuit board. The two boards are sandwiched together at the top of the Shuffle, leaving room for its battery below.

The Shuffle's lithium-ion battery takes up the bottom half of the device; it sits between the boards and the player's USB (Universal Serial Bus) connector. Sylvester surmises that because of the Shuffle's design, it may not be possible for the battery to be replaced by a consumer, if at all.

As with any electronic device, Apple had to make some trade-offs. The Shuffle's twin-board setup, integrated MP3 chip, built-in USB connector and the circuitry required to support recharging its battery via USB amount to a fairly complex design.

However, she concluded that Apple seems to be making a decent profit on the Shuffle.

Sylvester believes it costs Apple about $59 for the materials to build the 512MB device. The most expensive component in the Shuffle is its flash memory chip, which right now costs about $31, Sylvester wrote.

Thus Apple appears to have a "margin" of about 40 percent on the 512MB player, she wrote. Sylvester estimated that Apple's margin on the 1GB Shuffle is slightly smaller, about 35 percent. However, the report did not mention costs beyond the components, such as marketing, packaging, labor and other overhead. Also, while Apple sells iPods directly, it would not receive the full retail price of those sold through other stores.

Over time, the memory chip's price should decline, giving Apple even higher margins.

Apple could not immediately be reached for comment.

More from News.com on this story's topics

Processors

Create an email alert | RSS feed

Memory

Create an email alert | RSS feed

Music

Create an email alert | RSS feed

Music devices

Create an email alert | RSS feed

Apple

Create an email alert | RSS feed

See more CNET content tagged:
memory chip, Apple iPod Shuffle, circuit board, Apple Computer, flash memory

Add a Comment (Log in or register) 12 comments (Page 1 of 1)
Apple Profit on iPod Shuffle
by February 25, 2005 9:55 AM PST
The parts may cost X and the product may cost Y, but that
doesn't mean that the difference = profit. There's R&D,
production, distribution, marketing & advertising in there too.
After all that is taken out, what remains is profit. Kinda basic,
but it apparently bears repeating.

gmcv
Reply to this comment View all 2 replies
No anatomy pictures?
by shoffmueller February 25, 2005 12:08 PM PST
Love to see pictures of the inside of this thing. Dang.
Reply to this comment
what no wma/mp3 playback bad idea
by heystoopid February 25, 2005 1:32 PM PST
The report shows a number of very serious short comings of this unit,including the lack of ability to play wma files(not Napster compatable). The current competitors in this field offer better value for money, Apple will have to do a lot of work to address this units shortcomings as currently released. Undoubtedly, Apple's battery replacement policy charges, for this unit will follow it's bigger brothers, empty your wallet policy.
Reply to this comment View all 3 replies
My shuffle is empty, I don't how it's working!
by technewsjunkie February 25, 2005 2:37 PM PST
I opened it up and it's empty. Go figure.
Reply to this comment
Margins According to Apple
by jmmejzz February 25, 2005 7:36 PM PST
"Oppenheimer (Apple CFO) was asked about lower iPod margins.
In 2004, the
company saw its margins on the popular music player drop from
27 to about 20 percent. Oppenheimer explained that this was
due to increased production of the iPod mini, its own price cuts,
and an increase in its production of iPods sold to Hewlett-
Packard. Oppenheimer noted that margins on the iPod shuffle
are "below the aggregate" of the margin for Apple's hard drive-
based players."

I would imagine this is not as much as a guess as is the authors
opinion in the article.
Reply to this comment
Very poor analysis
by February 27, 2005 1:33 PM PST
Shame for such a poor analysis. Very much an amateur job from a respected organization. Makes you wonder about their other reports, doesn't it?
Missing costs to produce the product include: the manufactuer's direct labor (the people building it), indirect labor (others needed to support the assembly operation such as qc engineers and testers, buyers, managers, etc.), the manufactuer's profit and overhead (not Apple's, but their supplier), packaging instructions, shipping, and Apple's own support to the manufacturer and their R&D. If these are factored in, along with the distribution channel's margin at non-Apple stores, the conclusion is quite different. This story has been picked up by many papers and just perpetuates erroneous information. As I journalist I find this regrettable. How about a retraction from IDC?
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software
advertisement
RSS Feeds
Add headlines from CNET News.com to your homepage or feedreader.
Google
Yahoo
MSN
More feeds available in our RSS feed index.

Latest tech news headlines

Most Popular Stories
FCC approval suggests November Android debut
Apple willing to replace any smoking first-gen iPod Nanos
Debate rages over free wireless spectrum
Palm leaks Treo Pro photos and videos
Judge lifts MIT students' card-hacking gag order
Markets

Market news, charts, SEC filings, and more

Related quotes

Apple (-1.06%) -1.86 173.53
Dow Jones Industrials (-1.14%) -130.84 11,348.55
S&P 500 (-0.93%) -11.91 1,266.69
NASDAQ (0.00%) 0.00 1,816.15
CNET TECH (-1.39%) -22.86 1,626.36
  Symbol Lookup
advertisement
On MovieTome: SEX AND THE CITY clips are here!
Advanced
search
Advanced
search
Visit other CBS Interactive sites