Comments on: Top 10 portable speakers

Looking for the perfect way to share the tunes on your next trip or just around the office? Check out CNET's Top 10 portable speaker systems.

[chiragmehta]

What about the Bose Sounddock?

Does it qualify as a portable speaker? Is it worth the 400$?

[MaaikeKock]

Creative TravelSound

That looks real nice!

[weidner6]

Where is the iMainGo?

How could the iMainGo not be on the list? It should be near the top. Inexpensive, good sound, and portable. Heck, it even got a 8.7 review on cnet and it wasn't on this list?

[Jasmineflower]

No editors' review

The iMainGo doesn't have an editors' review (a requirement for inclusion in this story), though the 8.7 user rating does make it look promising! :)

[moretroops]

... that have been reviewed by CNET.

That's the critical phrase here. There is one portable speaker that CNET has
NOT reviewed -- the Harmon Kardon Go+Play -- and it unfortunately happens
to be the best. I have the number one on this list (Altec Lansing) and it's quite
good. It's not close to as good as the HK though.

C'mon CNET, get it together.

[ittesi259]

Horrible writing

What I hate about CNET and every other tech review site is sentences like this it will connect to iPods, MP3 players, yadda yadda yadda. Lets stop the brand preferences....an iPod IS an MP3 player. Why does this get seperated out like its somehow different? It just helps foster the stupid kids who get an MP3 player for Christmas and say "This is an MP3 player, not an iPod." Even though they do the EXACT SAME THING.

[SlanderPanic]

Transform and ROCK OUT

Where's the Optimus Prime iPod dock? Surely, this is the coolest set of iPod speakers this year!