Version: 2008
  • On CBS MoneyWatch: 6 things NOT to do on Twitter, Facebook

Crave

Comments on: Must-have Nintendo Wii accessories

Getting a Nintendo Wii? You'll need to pick up a few other items to fully enjoy it.

Add a Comment (Log in or register) (27 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
No online gaming at launch is a disgrace...
by PhillyBoy919 November 17, 2006 9:00 AM PST
I was initially very excited for the Wii but have become less and less so as more details were announced. I currently have an Xbox 360 which is great because I find single player modes boring most of the time and do most of my gaming online. It blows my mind that Nintendo could launch a "next-gen" console without online game play. The idiocy of that decision is simply staggering.

Equally surprising (to me anyway) is the decision to stick with low def graphics. From what I have seen the graphics are no better than what the GameCube or PS2 was capable of and less impressive than the original Xbox. If you have an HD TV, 480p (progressive scan) is supported but you have to buy additional cables to take advantage of this. They should have included an all-in-one cable with standard and progressive options included.

Not that the improved resolution matter all that much, Excite Truck is actually said to look worse with the added detail, apparently showcasing animation flaws and jagged edges all over the place. Trauma Center inexplicably doesn't support widescreen at all, even when in 480p.

Ultimately the decision to eschew high definition graphics will hurt the Wii as middle America catches up with the coasts and comprehends the benefits of HD as the sets fall more into their price range. In other words; the low def approach is very short sighted and will come around to bite Nintendo when their games all appear to be antiquated in comparison with the PS3 and X360.
Reply to this comment
Is that not subjective?
by MasterNewbie November 17, 2006 9:39 AM PST
While there are some, you included, that comprise a group that prefer online capabilities versus single-player offline action, there are those who don't, myself included. Because of modders/glitchers/exploiters, more often than not a game's single player mode gives a much better view of the game itself than its online counterpart. While Nintendo is launching a console without simultaneous online support, there will be that support in the near-future. If you are that impatient to have to wait a couple months for them to finish it, so be it. Memory recalls the DS launched without online, but when the online launched, it quickly surged, much faster than many other online services.

While the decision to put graphics aside in favor of implementing a new control scheme is regrettable, they didn't perform that decision for the gamers, rather for those who don't play. Both Xbox 360 and PS3 are console powerhouses, but look at the pricetags, $400 and $600, respectively. If the Wii wanted to compete in the graphics arena, the price could easily be Xbox 360-worthy. Now, I don't think many non-gamers would be attracted to that pricepoint for either console, the opposite of Nintendo's intentions would result. Sorry, while the PS3 supports 1080p, but you have to also buy a separate cable to use it, at least the Wii's cable to use its maximum resolution is $70 less than that of the PS3.

All that is words. Have you personally seen the graphics of either game? How can you commment on something that hasn't even been released yet? There are more than two games for the Wii.

I don't see the logic in your last paragraph. As most of America already possess SD-TVs and no HD-TVS, the decision to retain SD is one fine by me, and is already explained by the way of manufacturing costs. If Nintendo wished to support high resolutions they would have, but at a price; higher costs resulting in fewer sales (Law of Demand speaking there). I explained to you the goal of Nintendo, and obviously that action would essentially be a step backward in Nintendo's view.

To sum things up, while Wii games may seem antiquated compared to the PS3's and Xbox 360's, you have the production demands similar to that of EA and SquareEnix, graphics over gameplay. Just think about that.
View reply
Hi def is nothing without good games
by Wild Eep November 17, 2006 7:03 PM PST
Sure it doesn't have immediate online gaming, but it has FREE internet
gaming when the MMOS are realeased

Hi-def games are nothing when the games suck.
"yah, i got this great new hi-def system with a terraflop of processor"
"what does it do?"
"It kicks a ball back and forth, a HI-DEF BALL"

see what i mean, when the company making the system gives it great specs,
but doesn' t put good games on it, the system sucks

no one wants to make games for the ps3, because it's so hard to program for,
and even harder in hd, with teh wii, producers can crank out as many games
as they want, even if theyre total garbage, the wii will have more games, and
therefore a higher chance of having an amazingly good one.
View reply
Regarding Online play and graphix quality...
by sportsdc November 22, 2006 5:29 PM PST
Let's speak for ourselves rather than pretending to know every gamers out there. I can only speak for myself when I was turned off by online games in that the hassle of finding and joining groups, getting ass-kicked by already accomplished gamers, not to mention rude 12 year olds and the whole navigating hassle...you just can't play a quicky whenever you want contrary to single player games..

I don't look forward to online play whether it's xbox360, ps3 or wii. I'd like to see some very well designed single player games...and wii was designed for people who care more about game play rather than flash graphix and braggin rights to someone they've never met...

I'm an old timer and don't like interacting with overgrown 12 year olds and would like to keep things that way. Let's not pretend that online play is a make or break deal for everyone as I tend to think there are more people like me out there...especially the new gamers who've never owned predecessor machines which wii seems to be attracting...

As for graphix quality...who the hell cares about the specs..480p is plenty good enough for most gamers...I don't need to look for facial wrinkles of a character in the middle of drop kicking them...from 10 ft away, unless you plan to play with a humongous screen which most of Americans do not own (and i don't consider 42inch pdp's large), you will not notice the jaggies and 1080p and 480p will look pretty much the same..

1080p HD TV's just started selling this year...buiding an overpriced machine to take advantage of non-existing market or paying premium for features one cannot take advantage of is both idiotic to me.

Unless you are one of very small number of people who own 1080p hdtv(yes small..i don't care if 1million people buy 1080p tv this year..that's 299million without one), all you get to do with paying 2-400 extra is bragging rights that your machine could do better only if you could afford the right hardward to support it..stupid stupid stupid...

What this translates to is that those who buy PS3 or xbox 360 need to make additional purchases that'd set them back couple of thousands more to take advantage of overblown specs of those 2..it's either you spent 200-400 extra for nothing or need to spend thousands to get that 1080p games..yikes..

yes most americans are stupid enough to shell out that kind of money for just in case they own an 1080p monitor..somebody in education department needs to remember to include economic 101 for teem america..or their parents for that matter...

savvy consumers like me will stay away until I actually have a need for 1080p hdtv before considering purchase of xbox360 or ps3..

another angle with wii is that I'm looking for a machine to play with my 5 year old son. i don't care if it costs only $1...most xbox and ps3 games are just too grusome and are not designed for kids..

wii is the machine for me for some time to come. i'm not even sure if I'd want my son to own xbox or ps3 even when he's in his teen years..or even college years for that matter...

xbox360 and ps3 was designed for single males with no life..I have family and am busy for work..no time for hours of online play or patience for gorry graphix...those 2 over equipped machines just don't have a place in my home..

If I really wanted that kind of game, I already have a $6000 pc with nvidia 8800 sli card hooked up to 30 inch dell monitor with 2560x1600 native resoluution..let's not pretend that you have the best of the world with puny 1080p..

my graphix workstation will kick ass of any play machines discussed here..lol..

wii should have enough spec for any casual or serious gamers for years to come...

as far as game machines go, wii have my vote..
as for xbox360 and ps3..i really don't know what that's about...99% of those who purchase those machines are just IQ deficient...
Reply to this comment
In Total agreement
by T-Shot75 November 24, 2006 5:49 PM PST
Thanks for speaking up, because I don't know how many times that I've been to EB or the local video store just to find a game (for my PS2) that is both age appropriate and easy enough for my 6 year old. I will most likely be getting a Wii. I think it will definitely help put the "game" back into video gaming!!
View reply
Regarding $5000 PC's and the ridiculous remote...
by Ryo Hazuki November 25, 2006 8:33 AM PST
1st sentence: "Let's speak for ourselves rather than pretending to know every gamers out there."

Final sentence: "as for xbox360 and ps3..i really don't know what that's about...99% of those who purchase those machines are just IQ deficient..."


Your coherence says everything about your own IQ.
Good luck playing Gears of War and Halo 3 on your super-workstation.
As far as the Wii goes, 100% of those who purchase it are just ignorant childish little kids...
Re: Onine play and gx QA
by Nemosity December 4, 2006 8:13 AM PST
Amen to that. I am also a casual gamer with a family. I don't know where the 12yr olds of today got their ego's and attitudes, must of been w/ the PS2 and the release of Jolt cola.

I am looking forward to a system that we can all play together @ home. The Online play part of the equation is null as I am actually looking forward to getting the kids OFF the computer and into the living room. I am sure that the online part will come, but honestyly I will probably disable it.

Only thing I would like to get a straight answer on is the dvd ability. Does it in fact play DvD's? Whether its 1080i or 480p or 720p w/e, really makes no difference. Does it play DvD's or not? That's all I want to know as I am already sold on the rest of the system. Amen to the designers of a system that gets the children off their behinds!
by sandnstars2000 June 15, 2008 10:06 PM PDT
I must say yours is one of the most intersting post I've read in sometime. I came across this site while researching facts and opinions on the wii system and regarding its appropriateness in my home as a primary birthday gift for our soon to be 10 year old daughter. I think Nintendo would be very wise to realize they have a totally unseen market in families like yours and mine. Where we're not more concerned with the violance in games and gore or the 480p especially since we finally after 15 years of marriage agreed to purchase a new tv (42" LCD Phillips, 29,000:1 ratio, 1080p) now none of that means diddly squat to me, however what did (3 days after purchase) was the fact that this particular wholesale club went up over $300 on the sticker price of this particular model 2 days after we bought this model and the TV dept. person informed us we'd just bought the best set they have short of two Sony models that are 3-5 times the price of the one we purchased. In addition, when I did research online, I can't find it anywhere for less than 5-800 more than what we paid and none of those include the shipping & handling charge that add to that price.
Now, back to the revelance all that has had with your comment and my reply on the wii system, is bottom line. Primarily from all that I've read wii is the least expensive system on the market today, which also is a plus for yes those of us whom aren't living on celebrity brains & bank accounts. We take time to see and experiance what takes the time and attention of our kids and their minds. I too have never quite been crazy about our 9 year old daughter playing on earlier systems that instantly connected her to the whole entire world, while playing a 'game' She's 9 !! I don't need her connecting with complete strangers.
Last and least, I also enjoyed reading your posts, because it ensured me that I wasn't alone in my feelings, thoughts and fears.
Ciao'
My Turkey Day with the Wii.
by cmachouse November 26, 2006 5:20 PM PST
I had a chance to play the Wii over the holidays and the game play was great. I realy was impressed with interactive game play on the Wii sports game. If that is what the game play will be like for the sports games of there likeness then I think it will be the best system for sports game. Just think of an interactive Madden "08". Makes me drule just thinking about it.
Now comes to the Heart Breaker. It can't play DVD!! What is up with that!! Really its about time that you at lease make a DVD playing game system. I mean come on allready.
Reply to this comment
Need a Yea or Nea for Playing DvD's on the Wii Plz
by Nemosity December 4, 2006 7:58 AM PST
Seriously Considering buying this game system for my kids, (and myself ;P) for Christmas. However, one of the sticking points is that I would like it to play all of their DvD movies. I had heard that the Wii does play DvD's just fine and have also heard that it does not. I am confused and just need a straight answer either from a technical engineer or just someone that already purchased one of these systems and can tell me first hand. Thank you,

Nemo
Reply to this comment
Swing and a miss...
by PhillyBoy919 December 21, 2006 7:32 PM PST
So you are speaking only for yourself when declaring that 99% of the people buying an Xbox 360 or a PS3 are "IQ deficient". Nice.

My favorite part of your rant was where you knock online gaming basically because of the complexity of getting into a game and also the skill of your opponents. I'm not what I'd consider to be a heavy gamer. I'll get in maybe 7 or 8 hours a week between work, grad school, and hockey. I can see where you have some issues at first with some online matchmaking and lobby systems (especially on the PC), but honestly, after very little research I understood how everything worked. Once you get one game's matchmaking system figured out, you pretty much understand most of them from that point. With Xbox Live all aspects of online gaming are easy to the point that you can't mess it up.

As for the skill of the opponents online, of course you're going to get smoked at first. That has been true with just about every game I've played. It doesn't take very long to get up to speed though to the point where you're at least having fun. My 57 year-old father decided to get a 360 and plays Madden 2007 and Call of Duty 3 online. It took him a little while to get it but he's a smart guy and got it all squared away.

Unfortunately, I don't think your problem is with online gaming, I think its being able to learn and adapt to something new. The Wii is a fine idea, and the control scheme does have its advantages in all types of game, but it is designed so that a fairly young child can pick it up and use it. It's easy and friendly. Nothing wrong with that, I can tell its perfect for you. Me, I'll take 55" of 1080i online any time.
Reply to this comment
Component cable price is $30
by LiK February 9, 2007 8:42 AM PST
hey Crave, please fix that error. Nintendo.com is selling the component cable for $30, not $20.
Reply to this comment
@mr"savvy buyer"
by shadow6364 May 21, 2007 4:26 PM PDT
that comment about 12 year olds was pretty retarded, im sorry 99% of us don't know how to press the mute button, and seeing as you have considerable experience with xbox360 its safe to say you have one, and seeing as not pressing a mute button could be defined as retarded which is the normal way of saying IQ Deficiency, its safe to say you suffer from IQ deficiency.

(pwned)
Reply to this comment
by sandnstars2000 June 15, 2008 10:12 PM PDT
No, that persons' comment about the rude 12 year olds, is so right on. Hitting the nail right on the head. I see that many of you dang sure can't see where this person is coming from, only because it seems quite evident that all of those with something negative to say about that persons post I assure you are all young enough or (HA!) old enough to be that persons or my kids, either one. So, you all walk in our shoes then choose to be so negative.
by ezbuyworld June 29, 2008 8:32 AM PDT
check out www.ezbuyworld.com for a dozen fancy wii accessories.
Reply to this comment
by send4mechy July 15, 2009 10:54 PM PDT
For best wii accessories deals, shop at digitalXpo.com. DigitalXpo offers free shipping on orders over $199. Enter coupon code xpodeal for 10% off your entire order of two or more items. Easy one page checkout and unbeatable prices make this site a must to see.
Reply to this comment
by send4mechy July 16, 2009 11:38 AM PDT
www.DigitalXpo.com
Reply to this comment
by Hamletpri October 1, 2009 4:31 AM PDT
Ryo hazuki
"As far as the Wii goes, 100% of those who purchase it are just ignorant childish little kids..."
you guys are all adults and you give that much of a ****? I'm sorry if I'm one of those twelve year olds you hate but am I the first to say that you should grow up and get a life? (am not saying this to parents as they have a point with little kids etc) sheesh sorry gaming nerds but games were originally designed for kids
Reply to this comment
by Jazzi9y October 27, 2009 1:57 PM PDT
amen.
(27 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
advertisement

About Crave

The name says it all. Crave is our blog about gorgeous gadgets and other crushworthy stuff. If you would like to contact Crave with a tip or comment, please write to: crave@cnet.com

Add this feed to your online news reader

Crave topics

Google's mobile hopes go beyond Nexus One

The world may have thrilled to the potential for a Google Phone, but what Google actually unveiled is its plan for a new smartphone world order.
• Photos: Unboxing Nexus One

Using your smartphone safely

faq Worms, Trojans, and SMS attacks are risks for mobile phones, but the biggest practical threat to users is losing the device.