Version: 2008

Comments on: Bill Gates offers the world a physics lesson

In an interview with CNET News, Gates talks about why he spent his own money to make a series of classic physics lectures available free on the Web. He also touches on Project Natal, Google's Chrome OS and more.

Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 2 of 3 pages (171 Comments)
by sciontcya July 15, 2009 11:23 AM PDT
Free physics lessons from a drop-out?
I don't get it...
Reply to this comment
by wanorris July 15, 2009 12:05 PM PDT
Exactly! The way the world's going, next we'll all be rewriting our physics texts based on the crackpot theories of a Swiss patent clerk instead of the time-tested ideas of highly-regarded academicians. Oh, wait.
by subrajitmaity July 15, 2009 12:17 PM PDT
micheal faraday was a book store clerk.wanorris is referring to albert einstein i guess
by Vegaman_Dan July 15, 2009 1:24 PM PDT
Richard Feynman did the lectures and had both a Bachelor's Degree from MIT and won the Nobel prize in Physics.

I'd say he qualifies to be an expert, wouldn't you?
by jessiethe3rd July 15, 2009 4:38 PM PDT
It's call post monkies - monkey see - monkey do. See a Microsoft related topic post a crappy unfounded response.
Yes, Bill Gates is a drop out, however, I am quite sure he's smarter then you :) He happened to start one of the worlds most profitable companies.

Regardless - as was stated above... he's simply posting films/videos of Richard Feynman's 1962 lectures. I found them rather enlightening - a very good primer to physics - an area I have the least bit of knowledge about. I'm a bit smarter :)
by markosph July 16, 2009 1:58 AM PDT
Some people don't need to finish school to achieve "greatness". He dropped out of Harvard... its not like that is a high school or middle school. I certainly don't tell kids its ok to drop out but there are alot of people who drop out and are successful. If it was Steve Jobs (another drop out) would this comment have been made?

I watched some of the lectures... they are pretty good, I don't understand some of it but I liked them non the less.
by subrajitmaity July 15, 2009 12:13 PM PDT
so bill gates giving free lectures on proprietary tech is microsoft promotion.
you guys wanna tell me you use open source software because its "open source" not because its "free as in free beers" .
so why does google releases its software with BSD license not GNU-GPL.
is google going to dishup ads sold by yahoo on their search engines in the near future?
and not even google applies open source policy on their money making products.

i am not a google hater without it i would never discovered the web.
i just want you guys to realize each company wants to make a profit on its investments.
google is not investing time and money for charity cases. they just want more platforms to
dishup their ads
Reply to this comment
by Jimmy371 July 15, 2009 12:43 PM PDT
Gates is up to his old tricks. He's being sneaky by using the videos as a backdoor for installing Silverlight onto unsuspecting computer! My company doesn't trust Silverlight and won't let us install it. I won't install Silverlight at home either. I don't trust MS security.
Reply to this comment
by Hokulea July 16, 2009 11:55 AM PDT
Do you have Flash, QuickTime, or Java RE on your system? If you are so concerned about security then perhaps you should uninstall those plugins as well since they have numerous and constant security vulnerabilities.

Just wondering if you are a founding member of the Flat Earth Society or just lacking in objectivity in general.

So let's see here, Bill Gates spends his own money to buy limited rights to Feynman's lectures then posts them on a website that anyone with a computer and internet connection can access.

People complain that they can't watch the videos in Firefox, which is wrong since that is what I'm doing with Firefox 3.5. Of course it does require the Silverlight plugin to be installed.

People complain about having to install a free plugin. I suspect they probably have Quicktime, Flash, Java, and several other free plugins installed in their browsers. Oh wait, Silverlight is a Microsoft plugin which automatically makes it inferior and undesirable.

Argue for your limitations and you shall have them.

Thanks Mr. Gates for providing these lectures.
by twolf2919 July 17, 2009 11:03 AM PDT
@Hokulea,
Your comparison of Silverlight to Flash or Java is ridiculous. Both Flash and Java are available for many operating systems FROM THE VENDOR OF THE TECHNOLOGY whereas Microsoft only makes Silverlight available for Windows, as far as I can tell. I tried your suggestion of finding a "Silverlight" plugin for Firefox (you can simply click on the "Silverlight does not work on your machine" icon on the MS Feynman web page) and was pointed to Moonlight's download page. This is an open-source implementation (i.e. not done by Microsoft) of Silverlight. I downloaded and installed it on my Firefox (on Ubuntu)...and it doesn't work.

I think Mr. Gates did an admirable thing by making these lectures available - but he certainly can't call them "publicly available" if a growing percentage of the public can't access them. If I were of a paranoid bend, I would call it yet another way MS tries to lure you into its proprietary world.

You can insult people who think this as flat-earth backwards. But maybe you're being a bit naive (and ignorant) as well.
by Hokulea July 18, 2009 11:49 AM PDT
@twolf2919
Silverlight works on both Windows and Mac. If you'd bother to read other poster's comments you would know this already. Every software developer wants to lure you into a proprietary world including Linux distros. I don't understand how you can state that the Feynman lectures aren't publicly available. They are for 98% of the public with internet access that use Win or Mac OS's. Your growing percentage still needs to grow quite a bit more before it becomes relevant.

I run Xubuntu on my laptop and don't expect everything to work. Getting the wireless card to function was a PITA. That's just the nature of LInux at this point in time. It does have it's drawbacks as you have discovered. I haven't tried it yet but Silverlight may work on Linux through the Mono implementation of .NET for Linux.

There are a lot of people that are suspicious of .NET. Back when I was ignorant and naive, I felt the same way. All .NET really is, is a JIT compiler that uses a CLR. I write code in C#.NET and I like the syntax and structure. There's really nothing mysterious or sinister about it and it's pretty efficient at what it does.

Fine, call me ignorant and naive if you want. In the meantime I'm watching Feynman's lectures and you're not.
by kineticarl July 15, 2009 12:46 PM PDT
Fantastic. I've long wanted to see these fabled lectures. Feynman was incredible. Suck it up, install Silverlight, bask in glorious physicsy enlightenment.
Reply to this comment
by oddemirci July 15, 2009 1:36 PM PDT
Wowwwww. What a nice MS propaganda page this is! By the way, he is NOT doing a favor to the world by providing these lectures for free. They must already be free. Do you understand this point? Ha???

I am not using M$ and Windows. I am proud of Linux and I am giving support to them by donations. Because they are doing a very great job. They are the heroes of the modern ages.

By the way, I am a scientist.
Reply to this comment
by Nataku4ca July 15, 2009 3:13 PM PDT
and i guess thats why i was told scientist are dumb....

SSSSossooooooo, if u hate ms so much why bother reading this or for that matter any of the news about ms?

u need to go learn to look at stuff on a neutral perspective and not on hatred, if ur really a "scientist" it would help...

do remember Bill never mentioned Silver light or how great it is, enough said
by odubtaig July 15, 2009 4:31 PM PDT
...because promoting a TV show never sold a subscription channel.
by jessiethe3rd July 15, 2009 4:54 PM PDT
Did you know there's a free silverlight player for the open source community? Give it a shot.... of course you could be so anti-Microsoft that you believe there are subliminal messages about buying Microsoft products and conforming to the borg. Bing (or Google) Moonlight 2.0.
by odubtaig July 15, 2009 7:23 PM PDT
See all my other posts regarding why patent encumberment and a limited patent covenant mean that the only 100% free Linux distribution that can realistically _legally_ have anything to do with these is Novell's OpenSUSE.

Ubuntu? Fedora? CentOS? PCLinuxOS? Mandriva? Sabayon? Debian?

No.

So, download Moonlight and get it working on Fedora. I'll see you in a year.
by Hokulea July 16, 2009 12:04 PM PDT
A scientist lacking objectivity is nothing more than an evangelist.

If you had actually watched the lectures you would have seen that they were produced by the BBC. Acquiring the film, converting it to video, and posting on a website that is freely accessible cost Mr. Gates every step of the way.

Kinda funny that you call it "MS propaganda" then turn around and disseminate your very own Linux propaganda.
by dev2k July 15, 2009 1:42 PM PDT
Great job Bill, KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!

The more I learn of him, the more I feel the better man won the OS war.

Keep innovating and supporting education and knowledge.
Reply to this comment
by itsme2003 July 15, 2009 4:37 PM PDT
The simple fact is that 95% of the computers in the world are windows based. Anyone who bashes this contribution based on that needs to step back and try to look at things outside of their persecuted minority viewpoint.

Even if he wanted it to be available to only windows users, it's not like he is expecting this thing to drive sales. Come on guys, you have a brain, why not use it. You look for the MS boogeyman behind everything.

And a comment on linux. I use both windows and linux. Each has costs and benefits. I see a lot of socially inept or social misfits drawn to linux. That allows them to help continue their view that the world is out to get them. Don't get me wrong, their are plenty of linux users who are normal, everyday people. To them linux is just another thing, like bread or shoes. They just don't worship at the church of Linus or Richard S every week like the ones who lack the social development.

What a great gift this is. I've had paper copies of these books for over 25 years.

Thanks Bill.
Reply to this comment
by JoshuaFan July 15, 2009 4:45 PM PDT
Pretty neat. Thank you, Mr. Gates. They've already been on YouTube, but making a whole website for them has generated a lot of deserved publicity.
Reply to this comment
by justinf79 July 15, 2009 9:28 PM PDT
This is nice! GJ to Mr. Gates on putting out these videos!

Works fine on OS X with Firefox.
Reply to this comment
by markosph July 16, 2009 2:00 AM PDT
Yeah, I like the comment area and the extra features of the first video, It took me a little while to finish the first video as I read and watched the extra stuff in Microsoft Telescope... very cool teaching tool. I wish this kind of stuff was around when I was younger.
by BevanMusson July 16, 2009 2:36 AM PDT
**** Bill, You Freynman...... **** OFF.!
Reply to this comment
by BevanMusson July 16, 2009 2:38 AM PDT
Fart Bill, You Freynman...... Poo OFF.!
Reply to this comment
by July 16, 2009 6:03 AM PDT
This thread where people are doing the usual Bill Gates/Microsoft bashing is pathetic. What should be brought up is that the concept that Gates speaks of is not new, nor novel. The basis of the web's creation was distribution of physics papers freely. As for educational videos related to the sciences, Gates is not bringing anything new to the table here. The Annenberg/CPB project has been around for a while and there is a wealth of educational programs available on line for free at learner.org. This is not innovation that Gates is bringing us. What it is relates to his new profession. It is philanthropy. It does not matter what Microsoft is or Gates being the modern day robber baron. He has now entered the stage of his life that the 19th century robber barons did. He is taking his loot, and he is spreading it around to do good, possibly soothe a guilty soul, and ensure his name is mentioned in a good light after he is gone.

Thank you Mr. Gates. I plan on watching Dr. Feynmans lectures in my leisure because that is the kind of geek that I am. I appreciate you making this available to me.

Folks, it's time to stop holding Bill's ass to the fire. When he gives something back to the community, just say thank you. It's called manners.
Reply to this comment
by July 16, 2009 7:40 AM PDT
I'm sure Bill Gates bothered to get "rights" to copy a few videos and lend them to his friends. I bet he never shared any music on cassette with friends either. Of course he cannot admit this as it would be hypocritical with his marriage to DRM.
Reply to this comment
by July 16, 2009 11:18 AM PDT
I have to agree with odubtaig. Where's the support for Red Hat/Fedora?

I have to say that, as a computer user, I incredibly lothe that Billie Gates got rid of the desktop competition in the 1990's and forced his f**king stupid operation down my throat, the worse operating system in history. Where are my choices if I don't like the Apple?

For the case at hand, if I choose Fedora, I am also f*cked.
Reply to this comment
by Hokulea July 16, 2009 12:06 PM PDT
It's your choice, live with it and stop whining.
by LaraineMae July 20, 2009 12:14 AM PDT
Fedora Core 9 is supported: http://mono-project.com/MoonlightSupportedPlatforms
by Zakatos July 16, 2009 1:07 PM PDT
It was fun to read all the cute troll comments.
The conspiracy theories are priceless!

I found the videos to be interesting. But after a few years of physics, I'll stick with my microbio major tyvm.
Reply to this comment
by megustansalchichas July 16, 2009 5:26 PM PDT
wow i can't believe the idiocy of the arguments here. you're all computer users arguing about whether it's 'free' or 'not free' when 5 billion people out there don't even have a computer.
Reply to this comment
by July 17, 2009 1:11 AM PDT
The title is misleading to the say the least. It should read:

Bill Gates offers IE users a physics lesson

;-)
Reply to this comment
by kool_skatkat July 17, 2009 4:19 AM PDT
for Education's sake, they should provide multiple formats, upload a copy on youTube, google video, iTunes U, create a podcast in mp4 format!
Reply to this comment
by kool_skatkat July 17, 2009 4:20 AM PDT
for Education's sake, they should provide multiple formats, upload a copy on youTube, google video, iTunes U, create a podcast in mp4 format!
Reply to this comment
by inachu1 July 17, 2009 5:55 AM PDT
The only bad thing I have learned was that at first we all smiled when
Bill Gates decided to save the entire earths supply of seed grain. Yep that is a mighty moral project that any philanthropist could ever do for humanity.

The down side to this. Bill Gates has allowed companies to raid these seed stores and copyright them all so no farmer around the world will be allowed to use their own seed grain that they have been using for hundreds of years as they are all copyrighted now.

Pretty sad dark world we live in.
Reply to this comment
by shycelticwitch July 20, 2009 12:36 PM PDT
Yeah... and now he wants control of hurricanes. Can you say "Big Brother?"
Showing 2 of 3 pages (171 Comments)
advertisement

15 sites that went kaput in 2009

Web sites launch all the time, but they also shut their doors. We highlight 15 that bit the dust this year.

Top 10 news stories of the decade

Let the debate begin: Was the iPhone more important than iTunes? Was anything bigger than Google finding a great business model? CNET offers its list of the 10 most important stories of the '00s.

About Beyond Binary

During her years at CNET News, Ina Fried has changed beats several times, changed genders once, and covered both of the Pirates of Silicon Valley. These days, most of her attention is focused on Microsoft.


Beyond Binary is a look at how technology is changing our lives and the people behind all that life-changing stuff, with an extra emphasis on that which emanates from Redmond, Wash.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Beyond Binary topics

Binary Bits

    Follow Ina on Twitter (Twitter name: InaFried)
    advertisement
    advertisement