Version: 2008

Comments on: Leopard early adopters suffer for the rest of us

The dust has mostly settled following the release of Apple's Mac OS X Leopard operating system, and while several problems were reported, that seems to be the price of admission to the early adopter club.

Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 2 of 3 pages (83 Comments)
HUGE apple loyalist...BUT!!!
by k4950 November 2, 2007 8:38 AM PDT
The new iChat was supposed to have all these great new
features. Like being able to use video booth effects or actually
change the backdrop on video chats?...you know, the green-
screen effects where it looks like you are standing in front of a
waterfall etc....

Well, I just spent 15 minutes trying to toy around with it and
figure it out. Well, it turns out that you need an intel processor
to use any of those new features. Are you kidding me?? It hasn't
been that long since they upgraded to the new Intel processors
so I can't imaging them leaving out full blown highlighted
leopard features for the millions of people who bought a
computer more than a year and a half ago??

So far, this upgrade has only been mildy worth it...Apple is
starting to worry me with this kind of bogus false advertising. I
mean, first it was the iMovie thing...now this...I wonder what
other features I'll find out I don't get because I don't have an
intel processor? They had all this time and not that much was
even changed other than slowing down my 1.33 GHz laptop.
The dock feature is probably the biggest improvement (which is
minor really since it's only cosmetic).

I guess it's been almost 2 1/2 years so I'm probably due for
another $3000 laptop but it sucks that I have to give this GREAT
17" mint condition laptop to someone who won't be able to be a
part of new features and upgrades. And what about the
millions of other folk and schools who can't switch all of their
networks to Intel processors? They've made it so that unless
you can switch ALL of your computers, there won't be uniformity
on computers that were purchased over 2 years ago...this is not
good.

Basically, my G4 laptop and G5 desktop have become zero
priority by Apple after only 2 years. I wish I had known
this...Thanks for the secrecy Apple! I guess you had to do
something with all those G4,G5 processors!

just ranting and raving...
Reply to this comment
I agree completely!
by M-RES November 19, 2007 10:52 AM PST
This is my biggest gripe with Apple - they're quietly dropping
PPC support.

They've done the same thing with XTools, so the newer versions
of software I use all the time are NOT fully optimised to run on
PPC. I fI had an Intel Mac there wouldn't be an issue, but this IS a
big kick in the teeth for my G4 Powerbook (not even 18 months
old).

I can understand their P.O.V. over this, but it should be a more
gradual shift as there's far too much hardware out there being
used every day by people who aren't ready to buy a new
machine for a good 2 years or more.

The thing is, this software WILL/DOES run on the PPC
architecture. Apple have set up their installers to check your
machine though. If you don't have an Intel Mac, tough luck! Not
a good approach.

There are hacks around to get iMovie '08 to run on a G4, so
there may be something for the new photobooth stuff in iChat -
have a look. ;)
It's Nice Being A Saint!
by arkangel_3 November 2, 2007 8:47 AM PDT
I switched over to an iMac last December, and I've been nothing but delighted ever since then. There's no way I'd go back to a Windows-based environment; just too many headaches and hassles. Computers are supposed to work for YOU, not the other way around. Plug a device in a Mac, it works; do the same on a Windows machine and you're hunting for drivers for hours.

I upgraded on Monday. I did the upgrade on two Intel-based iMacs we have in the house. Both went flawlessly. As suggested, I did an "Archive and Install" for the upgrade. I removed all 3rd Party non-compatible apps before the install, and did a complete backup of my Hard Drive to an External HD. In addition, I backed up documents (photos, movies) that were irreplaceable on to my Dot Mac account.

The install took about 45 minutes on each computer; each booted up with absolutely no problems. Wireless Networking was up and running immediately. User Profiles and Preferences were exactly as they should have been.

The only issue I had was with my Intego Firewall/Spam Filter/Virus suite: the upgrade had erased my Serial Numbers and put these products into "Trial Mode". This happened despite Intego's update of the previous week which was supposed to be Leopard compatible. (I guess this was due to the Golden Master not being released until 10/26...which was news to me!). I entered my Serial Numbers, and the programs were up and running.

As for the OS itself, I'm noticing a slight improvement in speed; Time Machine actually saved my life yesterday; and the Core Audio/Video is noticeably better. There's lots of eye candy here, but a lot under the hood as well; and I'm only touching the surface of what Leopard can do.

I've read all of the negatives and issues this past week, and all I can say is I've had none of them. I can't help but wonder if a lot of the problems were as a result of a straight Upgrade as opposed to an Erase or Archive and Install, or an inordinate amount of 3rd party apps on people's Macs.

In any event, I'm extremely pleased so far. I'm looking forward to any improvements that come along in the future.
Reply to this comment
Only problem was Logitech APE issue
by OlsonBW November 2, 2007 9:12 AM PDT
Leopard has been great for me. Other than the Logitech APE issue I've
had ZERO problems with Leopard. In fact, most of the time I keep
forgetting that I've upgraded at all.

This isn't to say that there aren't quite a few reasons to do so. I will
also say that I'm really glad I did.

For once in my life I'm actually backing up my computer all the time
and not having to worry about. I've even purposely deleted something
and had the fun, what? FUN of restoring the file. When have you ever
hard the word "fun" and "restoring a file" in the same sentence.

Everything else has just worked for me. I'm ok with the 3D dock. I'm
not bothered by the reflections. Note that I loved the Dock from Tiger
and I love it now. Windows Taskbar is one of the worst things about
any OS. The Dock is great!
Reply to this comment
Light on upgrade problems
by mijothemijo November 2, 2007 9:15 AM PDT
Most of the problems that users are having with Leopard are typical of any OS update (Mac or Windows), even the small free ones that come out by the week. You can't
maintain an OS while taking into account all of the third party software that's out there. Make a choice between between first release bugs and upgrade bugs. Wait for
10.5.1, and if you're heavy on low-quality 3rd party system modifications you might have a problem with 10.5.2.

The majority of these cases are caused by incompatible third party software, namely a long-standing system modification call "Application Enhancer." Application Enhancer
has been a problem for many years, from a security and stability standpoint it takes the Mac OS a notch towards Windows.

As far as update problems, this is a lightweight, especially considering the number of changes and additions.

The following article describes the issue, and more importantly provides a non-invasive solution:
http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=306857

I lost interest in the article rest of the article, I assume it's more typical cnet sneaky jabs and lefty compliments posing as objective journalism.

For news and reviews outside of the Microsoft Editorial and fan club, use google and add -cnet to your search.
Reply to this comment
be smart
by aznfish November 2, 2007 9:21 AM PDT
Before upgrading to Leopard clone your boot drive with SuperDuper or your favorite cloning utility, then run a utility like Cocktail's Pilot, delete the caches from the main library and the user library, and to be safe uninstall third party preference panels. It is also a good idea to run Disk Warrior or other directory repair utility to assure directory integrity (you can boot the Leopard and repair directories using Disk Utility under the Utility menu at the second screen).

Now you have two choices: when installing Leopard do an Archive & install or erase & install. If you erase & install use the Migration utility to migrate your user accounts to your "golden system".

If all fails you still have a clone of your old system to clone back to your boot drive and nothing should be lost.

I cloned, then performed erase & install, migrated my users and everything works great!

Archive & Install should work for most but I prefer the erase/install/migrate method.
Reply to this comment
This isn't news...
by thedreaming November 2, 2007 10:44 AM PDT
Must be a slow news day, CNET is once again reporting the obvious. When vista came out, early adopters suffered. When XP came out, the same, when Tiger came out, exactly the same. Who cares, they'll fix it, they always fix it.
Reply to this comment
You are right
by csturdivant November 2, 2007 12:48 PM PDT
You are right smart guy, this is not news. Look at the category....News Blogs....an opinion/editorial/one man's view of the situation.
If this is suffering, bring it on...
by Kevin Boggs November 2, 2007 11:20 AM PDT
Every non-techie who reads it is going to assume that Leopard is a nightmare. You know this article is a classic example of the kind of power journalists have.
And I'm not just talking about tech journalists. Where is the responsibility? Now,
I'm assuming that many of the stories deriding Vista are the same kind of
opinionated "truths". (As a Mac guy I kind of like VIsta. ) I suppose you need to
leave room for interpretation but it's obvious from the headline that this story
attempts to paint a dire scene. Does anyone know where I can go to read real tech
journalism, without the hidden agendas?
Reply to this comment
What do you think is my hidden agenda?
by Tom Krazit November 2, 2007 12:25 PM PDT
Honestly, I'm curious.
View reply
Those poor suffering people
by Nodack November 2, 2007 11:46 AM PDT
Gee, I don't know if I want to install it now. It sounds like
Leopard has been a total nightmare from this article, but most
people don't seem to have a problem in the comments field.

Could it be that people that don't have problems makes for
boring news. Only report the few people having trouble and
everybody will think that everybody is having problems.

Could you take a poll and ask how many of the early adopters
are suffering? Oh, the humanity of it all! Those poor people.
Reply to this comment
They are all going to have problems
by Renegade Knight November 2, 2007 12:05 PM PDT
Operating Systems are all going to have kinks to work out when they hit the real world. Some will just be kinks. Some are problems built into the OS.

For now I trust Apple to only have kinks. Vista on the other hand has to remove some "features" that don't benefit users so that Drivers and other issues can be easier to fix.
Reply to this comment
Tom is uninformed
by J.G. November 2, 2007 1:11 PM PDT
Apple's own developers complete coding for Java on the OS.
There were apparently more pressing aspects for them to work
on. Java 6 will be completed for Leopard when it becomes a
higher priority.

Apple is not responsible for installation to caused by APE. Its
guidelines specifically say not to place third party code in the
system area of the kernel. Unsanity, Logitech and a few small
developers violate the guidelines.

MacFixit continually cries wolf to attract traffic to its ad dependent
site. Tidbits recently called MacFixit's behavior "despicable."
Seems appropriate.
Reply to this comment
Repair Disk Permission
by GSRich78 November 2, 2007 3:16 PM PDT
It doesnt work...Dammit!
Reply to this comment
One more thing...
by GSRich78 November 2, 2007 3:20 PM PDT
How do I fix it?
No Asprin Needed
by tdsluss November 2, 2007 3:31 PM PDT
I upgraded G5 iMac and an Intel iMac with no issues but a lack of patients on my part regarding Time Machine. I was convinced that the initial backup should be running faster and wasted half a day playing with it. Once I let it run on its own over night it has been quick handy. Maybe it was the picture of Claris the Dog/Cow I laid on the hard drive that did it. All jokes aside I?ve found the OS to be snappy even Parallels seems to run faster. I have not seen the issues that others have experience so I?ll count myself lucky and yes I trust Apple to be a first time user.
Reply to this comment
Vista what a speed champ!!!
by scweezil November 2, 2007 5:57 PM PDT
http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/01/29/xp-vs-vista/
page11.html
Reply to this comment
Using Leopard is NOT a problem
by Marcia Boone November 2, 2007 7:40 PM PDT
As a classroom teacher to students with disabilities; as well as a
few staff that need a little extra technology, Leopard is super.

My copy shipped to me at school Fri Oct 26 at 9:30am by Fed
Ex, and I installed it rather quickly. I did a ProCare just 2 days
later to see all the new features and some that will make life
easier for me. I am eager to try out translations--did it with
my G3 iBook too. I have a student whose parents do not speak
English; this will be great, no more waiting for someone to send
it to me and by the time I get it --it is too late.

I have not found any quirks. I updated to Panther-back in the
days of dial up. Tiger was DSL.

So if this is suffering, come join me~~~~
Reply to this comment
NO issues.
by gbreed07 November 3, 2007 8:22 AM PDT
I have 10.5 installed on 4 systems only 1 intel and no issues. I love
it.
Reply to this comment
It's slow
by rtolido November 4, 2007 11:42 AM PST
I have an iMac G5 with the old Power PC processor. And I am sad to say that Leopard is far from an improvement in terms of performance. Haven't seen that spinning circle as much as I have seen it in the past few days. DVD player particularly is tediously slow, so is iTunes. EyeTV software needed an update (it was available within a few days) because FrontRow seems to work differently in Leopard. I'm still wondering why I should want this Leopard: it's slower, the dock looks worse and I don't need the time machine. For the first time ever with an Apple, I am considering to downgrade to the earlier version.
Reply to this comment
Link to MacFixit requires subscription?!
by chadmarkley November 4, 2007 12:13 PM PST
You like to an article at macfixit.com which requries a subscription to read. That is fine, but the MFI is a CNET site!! Couldn't they pony up the content for your article at not charge???

Geez
Reply to this comment
Misleading!
by jmphilpott November 4, 2007 2:03 PM PST
The title implies a massive problem with Leopard. You can
backpedal all you want about the content of the piece, but the
message of the title is crystal clear--and utterly misleading. The
vast majority of us who have upgraded have had experienced
nothing but a very smooth transition into a new OS that so far
has performed flawlessly.

If this was not your intent then change the title or submit a
retraction.
Reply to this comment
keystrokes swapped on appswitch ... is it just me?
by xurizaemon November 4, 2007 2:41 PM PST
I've noticed one wierd behaviour: sometimes when I've just switched to an app, the first two keystrokes are transposed on insertion. I've seen this in Mail.app (when searching), Aquamacs and Firefox.

"hte quick brown fox, etc."

Either this is a new typing disorder I've recently developed, or perhaps it's related to 10.5 (but what evil magick is this?)

Anyway ... anyone else noticed themselves making the same typo repeatedly, and wondered?

It totally could just be me making the same typo :)
Reply to this comment
What hardware?
by M-RES November 19, 2007 11:10 AM PST
I've heard of this problem on the new (super slim... and nasty)
Apple bluetooth keyboards. There's some kind of latency issue
there, which results in the keystrokes sometimes arriving out of
sequence (!?!?!?). It's mental I know, but I think I read something
in a review about it.

That is, if you ARE using a BT keyboard. Not heard of the
problem in any other instance, so if you're using BT try
switching to a wired keyboard (or radio-based wireless kbd) and
seeing if you can replicate.
living in Leopard hell
by hal Summers November 4, 2007 2:52 PM PST
I got Leopard in the mail on the day of it's release. Over one
week later I still don't have a working computer.

First, i called Apple and explained my issues and they made
some suggestions none which helped. I then called later and
the tech said my machine was not because it might be due to a
defective logic board and power module. I got an appointment
at the nearest apple store (100 miles away) and dropped off my
imac. When i picked it up yesterday i still wouldnt boot up. The
tech tried an archive and install. No luck. Then we tries to put it
in Target disk mode and transfer the info. No luck there. Then
we did an Erase and install. I did not want to do this because
had some info I didn't back up (stupid me) but none was critical.
So we did that. Finally, after driving home I fired it up and now
the screen says I need to attach a keyboard before proceeding.
I have a wireless keyboard! I cannot attach it. I called Apple
again. No help there (after holding 40 minutes). They said I
could buy a new keyboard. Thanks!!
i am waiting for a friend of mine to get back from work to go
over to his house and use his keyboard. Hopefully I will finally
have a working OS.

I think I'll like Leopard. I can't wait to use it.

Hal
Reply to this comment
Any keyboard will do...
by M-RES November 19, 2007 11:18 AM PST
...any USB kbd will work. it doesn't have to be an Apple
keyboard. By default if you plug in a WinPC kbd the Windows
key becomes the Command (Apple) key

[That's why in the kbd control panel there's the option to
transpose the input from Win/Alt keys to put them the right way
round for the Mac's normal kbd layout]

So if you have an old USB PC kbd/mouse lying about, just use
those.

Did you try to repair permissions on the hard disk first before
going through the installs? When you boot off the install CD,
switch to Disk Utility (under one of the menus) instead of
running through the install. That way you can quickly fix any
hardware issues (or find out if your HD's actually knackered!).
and repair file permissions before installation.

You didn't actually mention any of the issues. There's a big Mac
community out there and many of them know a lot more than
Apple's 'Gurus' at their stores! ;)
Showing 2 of 3 pages (83 Comments)
advertisement

15 sites that went kaput in 2009

Web sites launch all the time, but they also shut their doors. We highlight 15 that bit the dust this year.

Top 10 news stories of the decade

Let the debate begin: Was the iPhone more important than iTunes? Was anything bigger than Google finding a great business model? CNET offers its list of the 10 most important stories of the '00s.

About Apple

At the start of the 21st century, there's no tech outfit more influential than Apple. CNET News' Erica Ogg and other reporters will attempt to make sense of the rumors, hype, products, and people that will shape the future of the company. But Apple's not the only game in town, as the established cell phone companies and others strike back against the iPhone. E-mail Erica at erica.ogg@cnet.com.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Apple topics

advertisement
advertisement