Comments on: Zune phone rumors persist

Unsourced rumors suggest Microsoft's deep in planning a Zune phone based on Windows Mobile 7.

[robvme]

Doubtful. The Smartphone already outsells iPhone 2 to 1, even during the debut of the iPhone. Microsoft has no desire to cut out all of its mobile partners and operators. Microsoft is going to focus more on Cloud services. The acquisition of Danger has probably more to do about Microsoft Surface than developing a new piece of hardware. Microsoft, wants the software platform, not the hardware. There are already plenty of great phones out their for business, entertainment, and texting. Adding another phone to an already successful line would be negligible. Apple is great at delivering an end-to-end experience in narrow fields. Microsoft is going to stay more focused on choice and a broad audience. A Zune phone is probably not going to happen anytime soon.

[AndrewAmazed]

Fail.
Should have gave credit to Zunited's admin/founder or whatever Teccom747 who had created the photo/graphic.

Also, I'm wondering why touchscreens are a must...? Before the iPhone came out, there were barely any people interested in touchscreens.

[Teccom747]

Hi, I'm Teccom747, I designed and made that image you used. I am now on Zunited.net and NOT zunescene.

Just thought I'd let you know.

Teccom747 (Jared Marino)

[doneflop]

LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Zune phone .........

[kylebuttermore]

that photo i so old, i saw it like a year ago...

[AndrewAmazed]

yes, that photo is quite old...
but still looking quite nice.

[jes834]

no. just concentrate on windows mobile. i will not buy a zune phone. zune? yes. zune phone? no. go windows mobile

[Drezen]

I'd love for this to be true and for the Zune phone to be everything I want it to be, but realistically I doubt it will be. Currently I have four device 'needs' that I have to cover: high capacity media player, PDA, phone and GPS satellite navigation. Thanks to my Zune and a Treo 750 with an external bluetooth GPS receiver, I've been able to cram those four functions into two devices, if somewhat inelegantly (external GPS is a PITA).

Logically, the iPhone should be ideal for me but Apple's decision to lock out the GPS functions from the likes of TomTom and the device's relatively small capacity make that a no go.

I'm very happy with my Zune and fairly happy with my Treo, the device I'm dreaming of would be an 80GB Zune smartphone, running Windows Mobile 7, with internal GPS. I can see the high storage capacity being a sticking point as the market in general would rather buy a small, limited device than a bigger one that does everything. That said, if MS were to release a Zune phone that I could install TomTom on at, say, 16 or 32GB I'd find it hard to resist.

[DakkonA1]

Microsoft's mobile offering should be limited to Windows Mobile. Zune should stay a dedicated player. However, what *would* be interesting is if Microsoft offered a separate ZunePlayer/Connect software for Windows Mobile that would allow you to use your Windows Mobile device as a media player that syncs with the Zune desktop software, albeit with some functionality missing (e.g. FM radio).

[keaura]

To me, Windows Mobile is a failure. I've not seen one phone that was easier to use or had any incredible features that made the phone worth having. I use a Windows Mobile phone now, and as soon as my contract expires, I'm in line for an iPhone.

[wmyinzer]

Both Zune and Windows Mobile are excellent products. However, combining the two probably wouldn't be so great.

Number one, too many peole would perceive it as Microsoft copying off Apple (which isnt true...as much as some people claim it is)

Number two, I dont think too many consumers would be happy with an all-in-one device--despite how good that actually sounds. Most of the people I know with an iPhone have complaints, yet the biggest is that they realize that they're phone, mp3 player, and storage device are all bundled into one delicate device. I think combining so many important things into one product is the wrong way to go, and people are starting to realize that.

Lastly, why fix something that isnt broken? You could use wi-fi (or bluetooth with later Zune generations) to connect wirelessly with Windows Mobile devices. With Windows Mobile as the dominant smartphone platform (and most-liked among business users), and Zune a powerful contender to the iPod, why try the gamble of combining two products together.

Sure, its been done....with very limited success. I think the iPhone has reached its pinnacle...and its a long way down.