Comments on: A minicar for future urbanites

Three-wheeled vehicles, to many, are motorcycles with sidecars or jog strollers--but that may change.
Photos: Three-wheeling in the city

[Xiibo]

Hmm...

Well, it's a unique idea. But I do have a few concerns.

1. 1 meter wide - Doesn't exactly thrill me at the chance of a soccer mom SUV slamming into the side of me.

2. 1 passenger - at 1 meter wide, the passenger will have to ride behind you, a-la bobsled.

3. Compressed Natural Gas - can't be very safe if you're in an accident.

I guess we all could strap a propane tank to our butts, slap on some roller skates, and pull our friend (also on rollerskates) with a short rope to get the same effect. And better fuel mileage too!

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for innovation and increased fuel mileage, but I don't think we're ready for something this different yet. Europe does indeed have narrow roads and smaller cars that would make this design ideal. But with major highways I have to take to work, driving next to large SUV's and even larger Semi's, I'll look for something that will make me feel better when those big guys don't see me.

[TV James]

Yeah, not in America

This would only work inside planned communities where cars were relegated to garages lining the perimeter.

Oh, wait... there already is a solution for that... golf carts (battery powered = no emissions), segways, bicycle or walking.

Yeah, it's gonna need extendable wings so that when you get broadsided by an SUV you can glide to your destination.

[justdaven]

That's why it is not for you

This car is designed for use in cities only. Not for competing with a Semi or full sized cars.

[heystoopid]

But then again

But then again, how far will you be able to drive your gas guzzling overweight boulevarde soft riding one directional vehicle like a Chevy Suburban when gas prices hit between $5 and $10 a gallon?

[Xiibo]

Hmm...

Well, it's a unique idea. But I do have a few concerns.

1. 1 meter wide - Doesn't exactly thrill me at the chance of a soccer mom SUV slamming into the side of me.

2. 1 passenger - at 1 meter wide, the passenger will have to ride behind you, a-la bobsled.

3. Compressed Natural Gas - can't be very safe if you're in an accident.

I guess we all could strap a propane tank to our butts, slap on some roller skates, and pull our friend (also on rollerskates) with a short rope to get the same effect. And better fuel mileage too!

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for innovation and increased fuel mileage, but I don't think we're ready for something this different yet. Europe does indeed have narrow roads and smaller cars that would make this design ideal. But with major highways I have to take to work, driving next to large SUV's and even larger Semi's, I'll look for something that will make me feel better when those big guys don't see me.

[TV James]

Yeah, not in America

This would only work inside planned communities where cars were relegated to garages lining the perimeter.

Oh, wait... there already is a solution for that... golf carts (battery powered = no emissions), segways, bicycle or walking.

Yeah, it's gonna need extendable wings so that when you get broadsided by an SUV you can glide to your destination.

[justdaven]

That's why it is not for you

This car is designed for use in cities only. Not for competing with a Semi or full sized cars.

[heystoopid]

But then again

But then again, how far will you be able to drive your gas guzzling overweight boulevarde soft riding one directional vehicle like a Chevy Suburban when gas prices hit between $5 and $10 a gallon?

[CB Reader]

Hogwash

A car like this is just what the typical North American driver needs to see moving down the highway beside them. The Smart car, introduced to Canada with musch fanfare two years ago, disproved the misconception that small cars are unsafe: it received higher crash test ratings than many full-sized sedans and minivans. The hazard of using natural gas is negligible. Millions of people are already moving compressed gas safely on highways. Just think of the vehicles already fuelled with natural gas (a sizable fleet), the trucks hauling propane in their conspicuous semi-cylindrical tanks and the millions that find it necessary to refill the tanks for their barbecue. A production model would be higly beneficial

[aabcdefghij987654321]

Propane is not = Natural Gas

They are two different products.

What's needed is an electric motor on this car, it's too small for long travel but with an electric motor and a 60-100 mile operating radius it would provide the ideal commuter vehicle.

As for those Suburbans, has anyone noticted that countries already using large numbers of these kind of small cars are talking about banning the SUV behemoths from their downtown areas? It could happen here too.

[CB Reader]

Hogwash

A car like this is just what the typical North American driver needs to see moving down the highway beside them. The Smart car, introduced to Canada with musch fanfare two years ago, disproved the misconception that small cars are unsafe: it received higher crash test ratings than many full-sized sedans and minivans. The hazard of using natural gas is negligible. Millions of people are already moving compressed gas safely on highways. Just think of the vehicles already fuelled with natural gas (a sizable fleet), the trucks hauling propane in their conspicuous semi-cylindrical tanks and the millions that find it necessary to refill the tanks for their barbecue. A production model would be higly beneficial

[aabcdefghij987654321]

Propane is not = Natural Gas

They are two different products.

What's needed is an electric motor on this car, it's too small for long travel but with an electric motor and a 60-100 mile operating radius it would provide the ideal commuter vehicle.

As for those Suburbans, has anyone noticted that countries already using large numbers of these kind of small cars are talking about banning the SUV behemoths from their downtown areas? It could happen here too.

[FusedAndCondazed]

Reviving the dead?

That car looks surprisiingly like the Carver One.
http://www.carver-europe.com/

The Carver One idea has been around for a while (dig around, you will find pics of this thing dated as far back as 2003, even their own FAQ states its been available since then commercially).

I'ts interesting though to see it took all the hub-bub with high oil/gas prices to get it to actually move, but it would be nicer still to see C|net actually report on something new for a change.

[FusedAndCondazed]

Reviving the dead?

That car looks surprisiingly like the Carver One.
http://www.carver-europe.com/

The Carver One idea has been around for a while (dig around, you will find pics of this thing dated as far back as 2003, even their own FAQ states its been available since then commercially).

I'ts interesting though to see it took all the hub-bub with high oil/gas prices to get it to actually move, but it would be nicer still to see C|net actually report on something new for a change.

[mstick99]

even better

http://www.commutercars.com/

[tetsuyo]

The future is now!

Yea there are a lot of competing ideas out there but this one with the advanced cornering technology looks easy to drive and a winner! I think that this is the future of transportation and we should immediately began to change our mindsets(and lifestyles) to welcome these vehicles on the road.

Forget about your gas guzzling SUV. They will become dinosaurs once people realize that they are being gouged to death by oil companies and greedy poiticians with every purchase. I am seeing once great American auto companies slowly dying because of a lack of vision. So I hope that Americans began to wake up and smell the coffee here. We need to start thinking about our future and not only developing these types of cars, but getting people into them on our streets.

[mstick99]

even better

http://www.commutercars.com/

[tetsuyo]

The future is now!

Yea there are a lot of competing ideas out there but this one with the advanced cornering technology looks easy to drive and a winner! I think that this is the future of transportation and we should immediately began to change our mindsets(and lifestyles) to welcome these vehicles on the road.

Forget about your gas guzzling SUV. They will become dinosaurs once people realize that they are being gouged to death by oil companies and greedy poiticians with every purchase. I am seeing once great American auto companies slowly dying because of a lack of vision. So I hope that Americans began to wake up and smell the coffee here. We need to start thinking about our future and not only developing these types of cars, but getting people into them on our streets.