Comments on: Java to appear in next-gen DVD players

Sun announces that Java, a technology originally conceived for consumer electronics devices, will be built into Blu-ray Disc players.

[E B]

DVD-rewritable, not CD-rewritable

The article mentions competition "between CD-RW and CD+RW for rewritable CD-ROMs. Neither side won the CD standard struggle, meaning consumers had to grapple with incompatible drives and discs."

Surely they don't really mean CD's, which have a single rewritable standard. Sounds more like DVD (standard, not blue ray) writables and rewritables. DVD-R/DVD-RW and DVD+R/DVD+RW are the two competing formats (though DVD-RAM, a third format, could also be thrown in the mix, it's mostly dead now).

Dual-mode recorders are becoming popular for DVD burners (I have one). But I've read that's unlikely for the two competing high-definition DVD formats, since their technology is supposed to be different enough to require two separate sets of lasers and lenses, nearly doubling the cost of a dual-mode player.

[aabcdefghij987654321]

Meaningless

Until the Blu-ray and HD-DVD camps can come together and create a single format for the next-generation DVD, neither format will be adopted by consumers. These companies seem to have missed the big picture. If there is a format war, consumers will wait for a winner before buying equipment. The content recycling companies depend on people re-purchasing the movies that they already bought on DVD and VHS (and maybe Beta and CED). If people do not purchase equipment, they will not re-purchase the content.

[ahickey]

Blu-Ray

One thing that doesn't get mentioned is that Blu-Ray will be in the Playstation 3.
Now there is mass market penetration.

If Sony can get the Playstation 3 out there in big enough numbers then this debate is irrelevant.

The media will be sold for the most popular platform.

Would be Great to see Mp3 Players with Java

Convergence is near, cellphones and pdas have java, and programming on it is as easy as on web.

For more news on mp3 players and other gadgets go to www.mp3playerguide.info

www.mp3playerguide.info

Write once, Rewrite many.

Unless there is a strict certification process, I don't see how this could possibly be easy. With cell phones, you can't expect a single version of an application to work on every phone. Differences among manufacturers and even among single manufacturers require different versions to be able to deal with the various quirks each phone has. In my personal experience, getting a single application to run on the 25-30 phones Sprint supports usually requires about 5-6 different builds.

With these next-gen disc players and the eventual flood of cheap players from Korea, developing multimedia applications could prove to become a nightmare far beyond the one developing for cell phones has become.

[William Squire]

Bye Bye DVD Player

<<Java will be used for control menus, interactive features, network services and games, Nishimura said. >>

Just what the world needs, another computer. What I'm looking for is a hi-def DVD PLAYER, not another "computing experience." Automatic updates, phone-home features, and bugs that crash my DVD player?? No thank you. If I want a game machine, I'll buy an XBox or a PS.

Since the PlayStation is supposed to adopt Blu-Ray, does that mean it'll run Java too?