Comments on: Flaming LAX laptop was a ThinkPad

Lenovo confirms that one of its laptops caught fire, but it doesn't yet know if Sony batteries were inside.

[thedreaming]

Not a good year for Sony

Sony first loaded their music cds with drm that used a rootkit, then they made that horrible racists white psp ad, then their batteries start exploding on people, forcing Dell and Apple to recall batteries by the millions. Did I miss anything? Maybe a Sony van ran over a little old lady and her girl scout troop as they were collecting money for blind lesbian albino ducks?

Maybe the last one didn't happen but right now, I think anything can happen.

[Mycroft_514]

Yup, you forgot one.

Toshiba just issued a battery recall for batteries that would not charge properly. No fire issue, but they have to be replaced as well. And the batteries were made by .... SONY.

[tlasater]

The problem is Software, not batteries

It really surprises me that people haven't talked about the fact that the real reason behind these fires is that the software to put the computer on stand-by fails frequently and if you put your laptop into your briefcase when it is still humming away, of course it is going to cause a fire !! This isn't a problem with Sonys batteries. It is any laptop which does not go on Standby when you request it to. This happens so much with my IBM that it is maddening !!!

[superman9956]

its not the software

the problem is the batteries not the software. software cant make a laptop get on fire

[lobsterman]

Faulty Logic

Your IBM catches fire a lot?

There's a flaw somewhere in your argument...

[make_or_break]

CONFIRMED: the battery was indeed from Sony

And the PROBLEM is definitely with the Sony batteries themselves. It's been identified as being a manufacturing flaw that, given enough voltage from the battery charger, will cause the internal materials of battery to ignite and subsequently explode.

Whatever issues you have with standby mode on your ThinkPad is not related to the identified problem that causes the cascade failure of these Sony batteries.

[Heebee Jeebies]

So what they are saying is...

That laptop is hot! hot! hot!

Good thing it was on a plane at 30,000 feet! Maybe until the battery problem is corrected (software or battery issue) notebooks shouldn't be allowed on the plane as carry on or cargo.

Robert

[rmjb]

Contradiction in story

The first paragraph says:

"was a ThinkPad, Lenovo confirmed Wednesday, and that notebook ships with Sony's battery technology."

Yet the 3rd paragraph says:

"That model does ship with Sony's batteries"

Which is it??

- rmjb

[Boinng]

No contradiction

Read the lines you quoted again - they both say the same thing. I think you must be imagining a "not" in the second line (it does sound almost as if there should be one, but there's... not).