Comments on: PowerBooks speed up, do new tricks

Apple's latest laptops feature a new scrolling TrackPad and a Sudden Motion Sensor. But what about the G5 processor?
Photos: Juiced-up PowerBooks

[Llib Setag]

People have the POWER

17 inch PB with 8xSuperDrive, OSX with iLife 2005 including
iMovieHD that will drive a THIRTY inch HD flat panel Apple
Monitor! Upgarde to FinalCut HD & you can produce HD video on
the raod & edit on HUGE monitor when you're back in the studio.
THAT'S POWER TO THE PEOPLE.

G5 PowerBook? Hold on, it's coming very very soon...

If, not you can always get a WintelDell Laptop with an Intel Xeon
Chip & 64 bit MS Longhorn OS... Oh, wait, that's right, that's not
possible today.

[rpms]

Great new specs, but let's not go overboard

The new PowerBook specs are great, but when people rave about using a laptop for heavy video editing, it's time for a reality check. Video editing is a disk-intensive task. It's no fun on a single 5,400 RPM (P)ATA hard drive. It's silly to call a PowerBook -- or any other present-day laptop -- a video editing powerhouse.

Better disk technology exists for laptops, but it isn't yet common. For example, Apple doesn't offer the fastest 2.5-inch hard drive, Hitachi's Travelstar (E)K70, as a build-to-order option for the PowerBook. There's also no mention of PATA.

Someone who wants to do professional video editing is better off with a desktop system and several 3.5-inch hard drives. Ultra320 SCSI would be the first choice of interface and PATA, the second choice.

To return to the new PowerBook specs, one of the drawbacks to Apple's proprietary hardware is lack of choice. At 1.18 x 10.9 x 8.6 inches, the smallest PowerBook is as big as my local phonebook (Santa Cruz, California). It's also pretty heavy at 4.6 pounds.

As someone who often finds himself on buses, trains, and planes, I would never give up the range of choices available in the PC laptop marketplace. My 2.2-pound Sony PictureBook is just right for me. I'm not saying it's right for everyone -- just that I'm glad to have the choice.

Miniaturization is an area where Apple could once again be a leader. In the early 1990's, for example, the PowerBook Duo was ahead of the game.

[rpms]

Sorry, I keep clicking "Reply to story" instead of "Reply to comment"

My post was meant as a response to the "People have the POWER" comment, not so much as a response to the original CNet news.com story.

[Llib Setag]

Thanks for the reminder...

You are absolutely correct, thank you.

The PowerBook line is a Pro-Mobile line of computers & the
current lineup would been great for he "in the field Pro
photographer / videographer on the go".

On the go / under a deadline, this creative Pro could edit on the
fly &/or view on a larger monitor as I suggested.

Yes, it would absolutely be faster & more productive to use the
PowerMac G5 Tower for large file editing & rendering for final
production quality end product. I would highly recommend that
solution for that task.

This is a great "on-the-go" portable Pro solution, but is by no
means a SUBSTITUTION for the dual chip G5 PowerMac Tower,
just a portable COMPLEMENT to that...

[Dibbs]

nothing wrong here

i don't have any trouble working with DV material on my 15in.
PB, even running lots of effects and junk in FCP. HD is a little
harder, but still possible.

[rpms]

Good heavens, another typo: PATA vs SATA

I think SATA but for some reason keep typing PATA.

The last two references in my post should be to SATA.

The PowerBooks support PATA.

[Jonathan]

Sad....or more accurate pathetic.

I'm sorry but the state the Power/iBooks are in is pathetic. Reminiscent of where the PowerMac was pre G5. I'm sorry but Intel has been kicking the living snot out of the PowerBook over the last two years with its first, then second generation Pentium M. With the newly release chipset that supports a faster FSB, DDR2 RAM, and PCI Express graphics its making the PowerBook line look even more pathetic. At least the iBook line can be said that its core purpose is price and accessibility to the masses with a solid spec $999 computer. But the PowerBook line is listed as the Pro consumer. Designed to get the job done. Well. Yah. It'll get the job done?slowly. Once again Apple has backed themselves into a corner because of their chip choice. I have to ask why weren't they working with IBM on a mobile solution while they were working on the G5 for the PwerMac? Its been suggested before and will be suggested again here: Apple seems to be incapable of working on multiple projects at the same time. What is there a brain drain while they are working on the Mac Mini? Or iPod Mini? Or iPod Photo?
Something has to happen. I want a PowerBook badly but I'm sure has heck not stupid enough to spend that kind of money on last years, at best, tech. Wake me when Apple has something to get excited over.

[Dibbs]

::sigh:: you have a point there

it really is sad that apple doesn't do more to juice up their
notebooks, but to be honest, they still work very quickly. intel
just makes it look more interesting. that said, i think apple could
do better if they'd work on a better chip design. the G5 is
freaking fast (beats out intel chips running double the clock
speed), but sucks power. i expect more from people who pride
themselves on intelligent, efficient design.

[CitizenX]

what a sad, sad little man

Apple will never build your "ideal" machine. They will
continue to build affordable tools for those who choose to
use them.

You don't want to buy a Mac, you want to complain about
why your perfect machine doesn't exist.

[toddouzts--2008]

New features, but same ol' defective case?

Apple makes no mention of whether they have fixed the
infamous corrosion/pitting problem in the G4 PowerBook's inner
case. Many users report that the painted plastic reacts to the oils
and sweat in human skin, especially near the palm rest area
around the trackpad. In my case, 18 months of normal use has
left the case eaten away, nearly exposing the SuperDrive bay
below. I was really hoping Apple would addressed this defect by
now.

[S R]

That was Titanium, now it's Aluminium.

I think what you are referring to is the Titanium serires. The
latest ones are anodized alumnium that doesn't have any paint
coating on them.