Comments on: Opening act for Gibson's self-tuning guitar

The guitar strings serve as the network on the Robot Guitar, which could save professional musicians time when changing keys.
Photos: Self-tuning six string
Video: Gibson's self-tuning guitar

[nbgilles]

Thanks for the helpful info!

Hey, 'well-informed'--

Thanks for helping to keep us all in the 'know'!

Happy Holiday's!

[nbgilles]

Thanks for the helpful info!

Hey, 'well-informed'--

Thanks for helping to keep us all in the 'know'!

Happy Holiday's!

[jellydonot]

Where tech and guitars meet

Who's planning on getting one of those? On one hand, I don't like the idea of too much technology on a guitar - what was good for Hendrix and Plant, should be good for all of us. On the other hand - this self tuning will be so comfortable when playing a show. There's actually a poll about these new robot guitars, where they ask if you're going to buy it:
http://www.pollsb.com/polls/poll/4282/new-gibson-robot-guitar-tunes-itself

[Pete Bardo]

Don't know about Plant...

But I seem to recall a story that said Jimmy Page uses one of these systems when performing. At the price, it's a lot cheaper than a full-time guitar tech.

[jellydonot]

Where tech and guitars meet

Who's planning on getting one of those? On one hand, I don't like the idea of too much technology on a guitar - what was good for Hendrix and Plant, should be good for all of us. On the other hand - this self tuning will be so comfortable when playing a show. There's actually a poll about these new robot guitars, where they ask if you're going to buy it:
http://www.pollsb.com/polls/poll/4282/new-gibson-robot-guitar-tunes-itself

[Pete Bardo]

Don't know about Plant...

But I seem to recall a story that said Jimmy Page uses one of these systems when performing. At the price, it's a lot cheaper than a full-time guitar tech.

[suyts]

How is this better

than a simple capo??

[jefferyschmidt]

how it's better

A capo transposes the guitar, it doesn't change the tuning. A guitar is tuned E-A-D-G-B-E. Some guitarists prefer using alternate tuning (look up "drop D tuning" sometime). This guitar does that automatically. Trying to have the "robot guitar" take the place of a capo and tune the guitar up 3 or more steps would probably break the strings and definitely throw the action (distance between the string and the guitar neck) way off. This isn't a capo replacement.

[Pete Bardo]

Better than a capo?

From the description, I'd bet it won't even work with a capo!

[danbrown99]

What do you mean "How is this Better?"

Hmmm.. maybe because you can tune to open tunings, or DADGAD, drop tunings etc. very quickly?

In fact, the last thing this would do would be to replace a Capo, you wouldnt be able to tune up more than a semitone without overstressing strings and guitar.

[suyts]

How is this better

than a simple capo??

[jefferyschmidt]

how it's better

A capo transposes the guitar, it doesn't change the tuning. A guitar is tuned E-A-D-G-B-E. Some guitarists prefer using alternate tuning (look up "drop D tuning" sometime). This guitar does that automatically. Trying to have the "robot guitar" take the place of a capo and tune the guitar up 3 or more steps would probably break the strings and definitely throw the action (distance between the string and the guitar neck) way off. This isn't a capo replacement.

[Pete Bardo]

Better than a capo?

From the description, I'd bet it won't even work with a capo!

[danbrown99]

What do you mean "How is this Better?"

Hmmm.. maybe because you can tune to open tunings, or DADGAD, drop tunings etc. very quickly?

In fact, the last thing this would do would be to replace a Capo, you wouldnt be able to tune up more than a semitone without overstressing strings and guitar.

[jharrisofkansas]

sounds like a waste of money to me

Any guitar player worth anything only cares about how well their guitar plays and sounds....having the ability to tune your guitar relying on your ears will go a long way in improving your ability to hear what is going on with your playing and your music....All would be better served to take the extra money for this guitar and spend it on the next step up in the quality (playability and sound)of the guitar you buy.

[jharrisofkansas]

sounds like a waste of money to me

Any guitar player worth anything only cares about how well their guitar plays and sounds....having the ability to tune your guitar relying on your ears will go a long way in improving your ability to hear what is going on with your playing and your music....All would be better served to take the extra money for this guitar and spend it on the next step up in the quality (playability and sound)of the guitar you buy.

[novelator]

New Strings?

I'm curious as to what the robot does when encountering new string stretch in the middle of a song? Everyone who plays a guitar knows how new strings stretch like crazy. So, if a player breaks one in the middle of a set, what happens after it's replaced? Does this robot keep tuning or what?

For the money, it ought to play all the damn songs, no human input necessary or desired...LOL

M.L. Bushman
www.jigsawpress.com

[novelator]

New Strings?

I'm curious as to what the robot does when encountering new string stretch in the middle of a song? Everyone who plays a guitar knows how new strings stretch like crazy. So, if a player breaks one in the middle of a set, what happens after it's replaced? Does this robot keep tuning or what?

For the money, it ought to play all the damn songs, no human input necessary or desired...LOL

M.L. Bushman
www.jigsawpress.com

[cyberbian]

Boy did they miss-market!

They are completely missing the ideal market and price point. They should be selling this on every beginner guitar, and at a price point of about 50 bucks. Beginners would greatly benefit from having a well tuned guitar to learn the relationship of sound and feel. There are lots more beginners out there.

[danbrown99]

Miss Market? I don't think so

This technology is currently too expensive to incorporate in a 'budget' guitar. The price would dwarf the price of the guitar. An inexpensive ($20) clip on tuner could be bought for the beginner.

The flip side of the argument is, an experienced player/professional, who would pay the premium would benefit from being able to change tunings quickly. A beginner wouldn't.

[cyberbian]

Boy did they miss-market!

They are completely missing the ideal market and price point. They should be selling this on every beginner guitar, and at a price point of about 50 bucks. Beginners would greatly benefit from having a well tuned guitar to learn the relationship of sound and feel. There are lots more beginners out there.

[danbrown99]

Miss Market? I don't think so

This technology is currently too expensive to incorporate in a 'budget' guitar. The price would dwarf the price of the guitar. An inexpensive ($20) clip on tuner could be bought for the beginner.

The flip side of the argument is, an experienced player/professional, who would pay the premium would benefit from being able to change tunings quickly. A beginner wouldn't.

[ss_Whiplash]

Awesome

This is the coolest thing ever. Not as cool as having 5 guitars on stage.... but still way cool for use in the studio. I just wish I could afford one.

[ss_Whiplash]

Awesome

This is the coolest thing ever. Not as cool as having 5 guitars on stage.... but still way cool for use in the studio. I just wish I could afford one.