Comments on: Office Depot to offer $99 PC with $99 shipping

Even with hefty shipping cost, post-rebate price is relatively low. And deal doesn't require subscription to Internet service.

[David Arbogast]

So long Negroponte

HP just kicked Negroponte's posterior... imagine... a commercial company offering better price/performance than a non-profit. heh, heh... Any chance HP will move in on N's market??

[AMPerez]

Hold up a sec...

Hold off on that kick...

Going to the Office Depot site states:

$99.99*
After 100.00 Instant Savings and (4) Mail-In Savings
( In Store Price $429.99)

You still have to shell out the $430 and pray your rebates don't get "lost" in the sea of rejected processing...

[chill633]

Not even close

The sub-$100 computer that Negroponte is delivering is:

1. Portable
2. Has built in mesh networking
3. Uses bare minimum power

The idea is to use it wehere there isn't reliable power or communications -- which the HP PC would survive powering up.

Two totally different animals. You need to look past the $$.

[qwerty75]

Does your corporate butt kissing never end?

This is a total rip-off. The cheap laptop project is designed to help people and countries, something you oddly find wrong.

[vizfx]

Do not buy it

I bought two items from office depot a while ago with mail in rebates and it was not a good experience. If for "some" reason, they cannot process your rebate, you will wasting a lot of time trying to get it. I gave up on my last one when they gave the same excuse that I did not mail in a copy of the product's UPC. Unless you have a lot of time and patience, go for it but the article says that there are four rebates so there's more than enough chance that your rebate process will not go smoothly.

[qzgwnxl]

Do it right and don't give up

I can tell you as a manager at an Office Depot two things.

1. I have never let a customer be refused a rebate they were due.
2. You no longer have to send in UPC's to Office Depot.

We stopped making customers send in UPC's because a high percentage (70+%) were sending in the wrong barcodes. THAT is why rebates get denied, not because it's a scam. HP still requires barcodes, but there's nothing ANY retailer can do about that.

Also, customers who don't wait 6 months or more, and can prove they actually bought the product (see: has a receipt) I take care of. If your rebate got refused I'll have it overriden, but you have to have SOMETHING to prove we owe you money.

[qwerty75]

It is still a scam

Unless you are saving that much at the counter, posting the post-rebate price is completely unethical.

Rebates are for suckers. You can do far better online, then outmoded shops like Office Depot.

[annanemas]

Obsolete On Arrival

This machine is bare minnimum for everyday use already and really needs the 256MB memory upgrade right now. In just six months you'll be looking at the cost of a possible Windows Vista upgrade, which would also require a new video card if this system is even upgradeable and another 512MB memory upgrade. This $100 PC could easily wind up costing you $300-$500 more in upgrades within a year. Most people are better off waiting six months to take advantage of special offers during and after the Windows Vista release.

[maxwis]

Not Necessarily

Yes, you probably want to add another 256 meg of ram, so let's say this computer now costs you $250 (with shipping, excl tax). It is a perfectly good computer for the kids or grandma. They will happily use XP for the next 18 months or so, it will take that long for MS to work out the kinks in Vista anyway. Or you can do as I plan to and load Linux on it as a test/dev computer. My printer just broke, so not only do I get a useable Linux computer for $198, I get a printer/scanner to boot. All-in-all not a bad deal. My only concerns are how many orders Office Depot will take before they say, "Sorry, no more", and how long shipping takes.

[zaznet]

Don't buy now for Vista...

Those consumers who will benefit from this system are not going to need Vista the day it hits store shelves or ever for that matter. $200 for a working PC with Windows XP is a good deal. Sure it could benefit greatly from double the RAM but if it meets their needs out of the box why would you want them to upgrade for Vista spending more money needlessly? That does not make any sense.

[Des Alba]

Get a better deal at Wal-Mart

I bought both of my kids a new laptop each for their schoolwork, at Wal-Mart. For less than $1300 total for both, they got everything they needed and more, including wireless and Dual Layer DVD+/-R/RW drive. If NEXT year they need better laptops, we can do that too. You get what you pay for, you know. Plan accordingly.

[omaryak]

Get a better deal elsewhere

You can get the same or lower price from Dell direct. But you're right that you get what you pay for. Get a higher quality laptop from Apple and you don't have to worry about it breaking every time it's dropped.

[aSiriusTHoTH]

and you are the luckiet person in the world

Please contact me with this weeks lottery numbers, because you are either the luckiet person in the world, or a flat out liar. I read a recent study that said over 70% have had rebate problems. Its such a big problem places like Staples and Office Depot will start to slowly get ride of rebates.

I, like lot of other people, have been ripped off so many times on this "rebate scam".

[AMPerez]

Refunds blow.

As far as rebates go - I may have put in let's say - 30 rebates in my lifetime and have only gotten 3 (three) of them processed.

Before anyone starts asking me "did you send in everything they wanted", questions - Yes. I even photocopied everything, just to have a record of them and zip- still nothing.

I've mailed the copy and was STILL asked - well if you sent this in, then you're okay. But okay or not, there was no refund in my mailbox.

If big box stores (or any other store for that matter) really wanted to move their items, they should just do the rebate at the register.

That would make me go back to that store time and time again. This through-the-mail processing is the pits.

[aSiriusTHoTH]

and you are the luckiet person in the world

Please contact me with this weeks lottery numbers, because you are either the luckiet person in the world, or a flat out liar. I read a recent study that said over 70% have had rebate problems. Its such a big problem places like Staples and Office Depot will start to slowly get ride of rebates.

I, like lot of other people, have been ripped off so many times on this "rebate scam".

[Penguinisto]

Great way to clear old crap...

With Core Duo coming out, and Pentium-M becoming the defacto low-end, it's a nice way of clearing out the Celeron crap.

OTOH, why didn't they just donate the things en-masse? the PR and tax write-off would be worth more than they'd get by selling 'em at a (probable) loss?

/P

[Maccess]

I'm offering a $1 PC

Yes sir! That's right only $1 for an Intel Core 2 Duo PC with 200 GB Hard Drive, 128 GB Video Card, 512 MB of RAM. Not a cheap PC, but a real Vista ready machine.

Mechanics are simple to get your $1 PC:

Buy the PC for $500, pay the $200 packing charge, the $200 service charge, and pay the $100 shipping charge (whether or not you pick it up from the store), and we'll give you rebates worth $499 and a zero coupon treasury bill worth $500 in 2099.

[aabcdefghij987654321]

rebates galore!

Well if your gonna charge such a high price in the first place then how do you expect to sell? You may wanna try this one for instant rebates http://www.white.in/result.php?Keywords=Instant+Rebates