Comments on: Microsoft sees Zune effort as a long haul

To catch up with Apple in the music business will cost hundreds of millions of dollars and take years, company says.

[grey_eminence]

How about an Optical Card instead of Hard Drive ?

http://www.colossalstorage.net/home_optical_card.htm

[Hep Cat]

Optical card?

You do know that these things have to exist before they can be
deployed, right?

[kylegas]

Longer!

It'll take longer than that, and more money - what Microsoft doesn't seem to get is that their UI and engineering processes result in a terrible end user experience - they just don't get design. It's all done by committee, and it lacks coherence as well as style. The software usually works, but not intuitively. It's a fundamental part of Microsoft, and I've never understood why people still just swallow all the mediocre stuff they put out.

[catch23]

Even Palm is using Windows mobile

the only thing shallow and mediocre is the BS your peddling. It seems most people, however, seem to see things differently then you.

[Llib Setag]

MS Strategy = EEE

EEE = Extend, Embrace, Extinguish.

They have used this strategy time & time again to expand their monopoly.

XBOX: MS spent millions to develop it,losing money hand over fist without any profits, for one sole purpose...EEE
They do not care if they make any money on the game box, as long as they put all the other gamer out of business. THEN, the monopoly expands & profits roll in.

XPod-Argonauts is attempting the very same thing.
Plays-Fur-Sure Partners are in the cross hairs & Citizen Gates will lose billions until they are all extinct. Then there will only be the Apple iPod/iTunes Store/iTunes software for Win/MAc AND the Argo-nogo-iWannaBePod.
THEN the profits will roll into the monoplist robber barron's coffers.

Can you here that? "Cah-ching!, Cah-Ching!"
MonopolyLandPark is expanding & rolling in mulah.

Microsoft: Where do you want to go today?
EEE

[rmiecznik]

2016, what I think....

This EEE I understand, but this EEE could also back fire.

MS just comitted it's self into buying back like $40 billion worth of it's own stock. Meanwhile they are loosing millions on the Xbox 1, and Xbox 2 (or 360), now ZUNE. And if they make a mistake with Vista and Office 2007, and the revenues don't come in as expected, and they still are loosing millions/billions, making less.

Redmond Real Estate expansion will end, layoffs and the stock will be beaten up with people fed up.

Sure MS stock made a lot of people rich, but it also made MS rich, and Wall Street doesn't forget or allow for stupidity for too long.

You make these mistakes, and what Wall Street gave you, it will take it back even faster.

That's what I think.

**** off the masses, and you'll see what will happen.

[rcrusoe]

I wonder how many $Billion MS will lose on Zune?

Forbes says MS has lost over $4 BILLION on the XBox through the
end of 2005 - and isn't the XBox Microsoft's most successful
hardware project to date?

Must be nice to be able to p*ss away billions and not get fired.

[JulesLt]

But it worked

It drove Sega over the edge, and Nintendo are on the last role of
the dice with producing consoles (rather than handhelds).

If that's what it takes, that's what it will take. As computing moves
away from the desktop MS can't afford to miss a market. It's worth
counting how many non-Microsoft operating systems you have in
your home compared to 10 years ago. (Embedded Linux is fast
becoming popular

[john55440]

Question for 2016

What's an iPod? :-)

I "dunno". I'm just paying tunes on my Zune.

[rcrusoe]

Another question for 2016

Do you think Vista will ship before Christmas?

[Dalkorian]

Sorry John ...

I fear you have that backwards. Conversation in 2016 will go more
like this:

"What's a Zune?"

"Who knows. Let's look it up on my iPod. Hey what do you know, it
was yet another misearable failure by those people who brought us
viruses and insecure operating systems. I'm so glad they finally fell
by the wayside ..."

[Peter Bonte]

Cracking open a Zune soon

If MS is losing $$ on the player it may be cheaper to crack the Zune
for its internals, if the SD card inside is a usable one that is.

Zune = The Next BIG Failure

Next to CNET, Zune will be the second biggest
http://www.techknowcafe.com/content/view/603/43/
failure in the technology industry.

[grandmasterdibbler]

Dude!

Stop peddling random links at the end of your posts! They're not relevant in any way shape or form. The link in your last post took me to a page about and external DVD writer! What is the point?

Ok most of your posts consist of Cnet bashing and links to 'techknowcafe'.

If you don't like Cnet don't post!
AND unless you have a relevant link don't post one at all

[ServedUp]

Thats only obvious..

but it will never takeoff like the IPOD did three years ago.. the
success of the IPod was combined with good engineering, stellar
marketing, alot of luck and being at the right place at the right
time. Given Microsoft's track record.. there timing leaves alot to
be desired, and I highly doubt they will be able to pull this off..

They want a device that promotes community?? The IPOD already
has that. Actually all of Apple's products have that and they ain't
going to stop at the IPod. Their are alot more devices,
computers and software in store from Apple. Apple ain't going
to simply role over and die, their on to much of a role.

They also want a service that will tie in Media Center and Xbox??
Again that will never fly, they've just made it complicated
already. Their attempts to flood the market with Xbox and Media
Center is absurd. I think Microsoft is forgetting their core
audience - blue collar workers -. Microsoft and whatever brand
they come up with is just not seen as being techno-cool. No
matter how much they dilute the brand. Why? I keep picturing
Ballmer and Gates celebrating their victory with Windows 95. So
much hoopla and fake fan fare, that made me sick. Gates
especially what a total geek. No insult intended but Ballmer and
Gates quite posisbly could do a sequel to Revenge of the Nerds.
Don't you think??

Either way you cut it.. they've run out of good ideas. They
haven't a clue on how to bring in more revenue so they take an
obvious strategy and copy their competitors. They've never lead
by example. I just hope they don't call this innovation. What a
joke..

Its going to be a flop just like Origami. I just hope they'll go
through with it and decide not to back out last minute for
entertainment value. I just want to see Ballmer weasel his way
out of this one..hehe

[cmcmanis]

As only a monopoly can

Microsoft will enter yet another market, and if their service which has fewer artists and more egregious terms doesn't kill Apple then they just release an OS update to generate a few billion dollers so that they can effectively remove Apple's ability to compete by using their huge cash horde and temporarily eliminate the "market" entirely. Why off course your microsoft OS powered phone works just like an iPod now, of course your desktops get the music for "free" noew, of course your set top box will only play Zune tunes. And on the ashes of iPod/Apple Microsoft will get one step closer to becoming a data monopoly.

Force Zune to be a separate business with its own P&L? Never happen.

I've seen the future, and it is this: "all your data are belong to Microsoft." The non-technical community doesn't realize how irrelevant governments become when that happens.

[Broward Horne]

Zune Meme Has No Public Awareness

There's virtually no public awareness of Zune -

http://www.realmeme.com/roller/page/realmeme?entry=apple_ipod_vs_microsoft_zune

Run Your Own Meme -

http://www.realmeme.com/Main/miner.jsp

[m.meister]

MS has lost any focus

All they seem to be doing is looking at the current trend and
trying to copy that. This is a major RED flag that a company has
lost all its focus.

They need to focus. Their two main cash-cow products are dying
on the vine. Vista and Office continue to suffer from delay after
delay. As Balmer might say: "FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS,
FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS... FOCUS, FOCUS,
FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS, FOCUS"

But perhaps they believe they can get this out before Vista ships
-- then again, what CAN'T YOU GET OUT BEFORE VISTA SHIPS.

[Sumatra-Bosch]

Zune - One of a Thousand Cuts!

How will MS die? A thousand small cuts tossing billions at markets they don't understand and can't bully into submission while the Vistapocalypse ends in a hurricane of cracks that will completely destroys the OS, turns MS into a global laughing stock, inspires law suits from its own customers and make the company the most shorted stock in the history of US equities. Already analysts and traders are publicly asking why MS is selling at any multiple at all given the company's slackjawed incompetence. This is really the beginning of the end. MS's only move left is to end support of XP or send out an update that will turn off the OS and force the user to buy and download the Vista upgrade which they can't attempt without getting sued by their own customers. No one ever wanted anything made by Microsoft and more than ever before users will find excuses to avoid Vista and being swept up in the Vistapocalypse. Ballmer can run around throwing chairs, head-butting buses and making good sport of avoiding the animal control officers trying to catch him but in the end he will go down in history as the grunting pinhead that dismantled the biggest software company in the world. He will go down with blinking idiots like Fred Wang, Dr An Wang's kid, the guy who rode Wang Laboratories into its grave.

[maxwis]

It Will Take "Years" To Make It Insecure

What Microsoft meant to say is that it will take several hundred million dollars and several years to make Zune just as insecure as the rest of Microsoft's platforms. A truly insecure product is a work of art, and cannot be hurried.

[microsoft slayer]

I'm jamming to iTunes

why the hell would I want to use Zune? iTunes and my iPod are awesome together!

[open-mind]

Unstoppable Zune Business Model

Just force all large Windows PC makers to "bundle" a free Zune with
each Windows PC they sell.

Sure it's illegal, but they can just claim it's a hardware extension to
Windows. "Yeah, Windows Zune Edition. We're innovating again.
That's the ticket!"

Worked before! LOL ;-)

[microsoft slayer]

Glad I have a Mac

I'm happily locked into Apple and iTunes. :) Who cares about Winbloze!

[isodork]

zune and xbox

Microsoft has a real chance with the zune, because it shares the same target audience as the xbox

http://www.zunescene.com

[lesfilip]

Directs you to Zune promotional site

One of the few even remotely positive postings about the Zune
article directs you to a site that is clearly associated with the Zune
promotional machine. It reads like someone's parents trying to talk
like and be cool like their teenage kids. Age-inappropriate behavior
and the Zune are equally repugnant.

Have a nice day!

[regulator1956]

Right Down The Tubes

Yeah M$ is really hurting. I'm sure they're just a bad decision or two from going down the tubes.

Get real. M$ makes so much money each quarter, they have no use for it. They have many solid products and millions of loyal followers.

Could they start to lose momentum slowly and have profits drop? Sure. That's why they invested billions in XBox and now in Zune.

Don't just milk the cow, because the world might get tired of milk. Make butter, cheese, whip creme, yogurt, and lots more money.

[grandmasterdibbler]

Where is the evidence?

COuld someone point me to something 'rock soild' that indicates that the Zune will have anything to do with games. The early portable xbox stuff was speculation and everyone seems to be clinging to it, there was nothing I could see in the press release about games.

They've lined themselves up for difficulty already by announcing some vague ideas about what it will do and people will take these hints and go wild, and then be very disappointed when it doesn't match up.
It looks like Apple have the right idea by not releasing any information until the product is ready to go on sale, that means when it comes out people will be wowed by the features. That happens mainly because they have no idea what's coming. Whenever there is an announcement Apple gives no hints about what they're releasing. That results in no disappointment as usually rumours are just educated guesses and the wow factor.

It's like if you go the cinema and have read all the plot spoilers for the movie as opposed to knowing very little, there's no surprise, no excitement. That is the problem with releasing sketchy details.

[Tanjore]

This goes back to couple of months ago article

This goes back couple of months article that microsoft was trying to provide a bridge to IPOD through usb 2.0 interface specs are something and it did not provide user the experience they wanted.

Xbox live is getting popular with xbox users. Xbox live has been a successful delivery channel for microsoft.

Imagine zune docked to xbox and is able to communicate with xbox live site to download songs or even videos!!! who knows.

I am sure microsoft that there is money to be made eventually!! and that why they are in.

[Tanjore]

Check this link for IPOD and XBOX

Check this link for IPOD and XBOX link. This has not worked great so far.

http://www.betanews.com/article/iPod_to_Connect_with_Xbox_360/1116012979

[imguessing]

Insecurity & Jealousy

Just another example of Microsoft?s insecurity & jealousy of all things tech related. Any tech company who experiences success, makes Microsoft feel threatened. They are constantly entering markets they have no business entering, just because they have the money to do it.

If they would spend those resources on improving their OS, browser, Productivity software, we would be using them because we want to, not because we have no other choice.

I?m Guessing

http://imguessingblog.blogspot.com

[Björn Lundahl]

Markets are not static!

They change all the time and no one ?owns? them.
It has nothing to do about jealously.
It is only about making money. Microsoft believes that it will be able to make money in this way. It does not believe that it will make money in investing those resources on improving their OS, browser, productivity software and so on. That is the message I get. Actually, they are increasing competition by entering this market.
Björn Lundahl,
Göteborg,
Sweden

[Thrudheim]

Microsoft's modus operandi

I saw this post on the Mini-Microsoft blog and thought it was
insightful and relevant to this discussion:

"Here's the problem- the only way to grow the business this
company knows is to be an 800 pound gorilla (who gets to sit
wherever he wants). That's why you have Zune muscling in on
PlaysForSure partners. That's why Microsoft is horning in on
Adobe (with the expressions stuff), IBM, Oracle, anyone else.
Basically, unless you're seliing Microsoft's stuff for them in the
channel, beware the talk of 'partner', if you develop on their
platforms- because the fact is Microsoft will eventually want the
money YOUR company is getting to fund THEIR growth."

Here's the link:

http://minimsft.blogspot.com/2006/07/we-are-fam-ily-
links.html#c115402433908523810