Comments on: Panasonic to deliver the Blu-ray living room

Attention cinephiles: Nearly every big consumer electronics company is going to be hunting you down this year.

[mystereojones]

Blu ray or HD DVD?

Blu ray, HD DVD, etc, etc. Just offer all formats in one device.
http://www.techknowcafe.com/content/view/75/42/

[mystereojones]

Blu ray or HD DVD?

Blu ray, HD DVD, etc, etc. Just offer all formats in one device.
http://www.techknowcafe.com/content/view/75/42/

[Earl Benser]

No problem.....

..... Both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD are far too expensive, have
duplicate capabilities, and don't match a regular DVD with MPEG-4
compression. So two alternative over-priced under-performing
junk designs. Almost sounds like Microsoft.

Where are any design brains in this area? Is everyone fog-bound
and stupid?

[Andrew J Glina]

over-priced under-performing junk designs

Sounds more like Apple. After all, they only recently caught up with Microsoft and the PC world, yet they still charge more. Aside from my usual reasons, how about "Safe Sleep"? Windows has had hibernation for years, yet Apple added that feature in Tiger, and even then you need to do a un-supported mod to get it to work on most machines.

[Earl Benser]

No problem.....

..... Both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD are far too expensive, have
duplicate capabilities, and don't match a regular DVD with MPEG-4
compression. So two alternative over-priced under-performing
junk designs. Almost sounds like Microsoft.

Where are any design brains in this area? Is everyone fog-bound
and stupid?

[Andrew J Glina]

over-priced under-performing junk designs

Sounds more like Apple. After all, they only recently caught up with Microsoft and the PC world, yet they still charge more. Aside from my usual reasons, how about "Safe Sleep"? Windows has had hibernation for years, yet Apple added that feature in Tiger, and even then you need to do a un-supported mod to get it to work on most machines.

[Broward Horne]

Go Blu-Ray

I think Blu-Ray is the odds-on bet over HD-DVD.

http://www.realmeme.com/roller/page/realmeme?entry=blu_ray_vs_hd_dvd

[luvmysubaru]

FANBOY alert!

Stop with posting this chart... it means nothing. What does mean
something is how poor the Blu-ray movies are looking on the first
round. The HD-DVD titles look stunning and use H.264 rather
than Blu-ray which using traditional MPEG2 - I've seen both in
action and I'm not impressed with Blu-ray. HD-DVD however looks
great.

[Heebee Jeebies]

We have a...

Consumer lemming! He/she or in the case of Bush - it is headed for a cliff!

R

[Broward Horne]

Go Blu-Ray

I think Blu-Ray is the odds-on bet over HD-DVD.

http://www.realmeme.com/roller/page/realmeme?entry=blu_ray_vs_hd_dvd

[luvmysubaru]

FANBOY alert!

Stop with posting this chart... it means nothing. What does mean
something is how poor the Blu-ray movies are looking on the first
round. The HD-DVD titles look stunning and use H.264 rather
than Blu-ray which using traditional MPEG2 - I've seen both in
action and I'm not impressed with Blu-ray. HD-DVD however looks
great.

[Heebee Jeebies]

We have a...

Consumer lemming! He/she or in the case of Bush - it is headed for a cliff!

R

[Jackson Cracker]

Intel is irrelevant here

When was the last time you bought a movie DVD from
Intel Studios or a music CD from Intel Records?

[Jackson Cracker]

Intel is irrelevant here

When was the last time you bought a movie DVD from
Intel Studios or a music CD from Intel Records?

[Jackson Cracker]

Intel's "support" is irrelevant here

When was the last time you bought a movie DVD from
Intel Studios or a music CD from Intel Records?

[Jackson Cracker]

Intel's "support" is irrelevant here

When was the last time you bought a movie DVD from
Intel Studios or a music CD from Intel Records?

[baisa]

Watershed: format supported by all studios

There is a watershed event that must occur before anyone who isn't rich or crazy can sensibly purchase a HD DVD or BluRay player: *all* studios must support the format. How useless would it be to have a player for which you couldn't get all your favorite movies? Remember when you still had to keep your VHS dusted off to play the movies that hadn't been released in DVD format? <shudder> Who would buy 2 hidef players??? Sheesh this is annoying!

[luvmysubaru]

annoying is right

this format war is about Sony not wanting to loose to Toshiba
like they did with VHS in the 80's and DVD - both were Toshiba
vs. Sony format wars and Toshiba ended up winning both
despite Sony bringing out techincally superior formats each
time. Sony and Toshiba were at one time coming together on a
single HD format, but it all fell apart and now we the consumers
are stuck in the middle of yet another pointless battle. I own a
Toshiba HD-A1 and I will buy a Blu-ray player as well, but I am
not impressed with Blu-ray's quality as compared to HD-DVD -
the picture quality is much better in the HD-DVD masters than
the first round of Blu-ray titles which show significant
artifacting.

[markdoiron]

Yes, But . . .

Yes, a format supported by all studios would be nice (if either of these formats is to beat DVD, something which I'm not totally convinced of yet!). However, I don't think that consumers choosing a particular hardware solution feel limited just because there is a lack of complete content selection. Just look to the online music services for a current example. So, Blu-Ray may have the edge (if it doesn't garner a reputation for poor transfers): More content, and the consumer can buy the other studio's movies in plain-old DVD.

mark d.

[baisa]

Watershed: format supported by all studios

There is a watershed event that must occur before anyone who isn't rich or crazy can sensibly purchase a HD DVD or BluRay player: *all* studios must support the format. How useless would it be to have a player for which you couldn't get all your favorite movies? Remember when you still had to keep your VHS dusted off to play the movies that hadn't been released in DVD format? <shudder> Who would buy 2 hidef players??? Sheesh this is annoying!

[luvmysubaru]

annoying is right

this format war is about Sony not wanting to loose to Toshiba
like they did with VHS in the 80's and DVD - both were Toshiba
vs. Sony format wars and Toshiba ended up winning both
despite Sony bringing out techincally superior formats each
time. Sony and Toshiba were at one time coming together on a
single HD format, but it all fell apart and now we the consumers
are stuck in the middle of yet another pointless battle. I own a
Toshiba HD-A1 and I will buy a Blu-ray player as well, but I am
not impressed with Blu-ray's quality as compared to HD-DVD -
the picture quality is much better in the HD-DVD masters than
the first round of Blu-ray titles which show significant
artifacting.

[markdoiron]

Yes, But . . .

Yes, a format supported by all studios would be nice (if either of these formats is to beat DVD, something which I'm not totally convinced of yet!). However, I don't think that consumers choosing a particular hardware solution feel limited just because there is a lack of complete content selection. Just look to the online music services for a current example. So, Blu-Ray may have the edge (if it doesn't garner a reputation for poor transfers): More content, and the consumer can buy the other studio's movies in plain-old DVD.

mark d.