Comments on: Google bets on mobile market

Mobile is the next frontier for Google, but how will it straddle the line between partnering and competing with major cell phone operators?

[i_am_still_wade]

If Google wants to succeed, they must drop Sprint

Just like Sprint drops calls, Google must drop Sprint. Even partnering with Sprint is going to set Google back. Yes, I know Google is using the data network, not voice. It doesn't matter, Sprint is by miles the worst cell carrier in the world. If Google partners with Sprint, this will Google biggest failure.

[atulkumthekar]

cell and datanetworks

Well, from your comment it seems like google is going only for the data networks part - for which Sprint is pretty good. (Believe me as I worked for Sprint - but not so much prejudiced for it!)

I do not know the full technicalities of the deal, but yet fail to understand how, going for only the datanetworks part Google is planning to leverage cell phone market.

And I guess sprint has got out of dropped call problem by now... :)

atul kumthekar

[wildchild_plasma_gyro]

propergative wave dynamics

to propergate your wave the furthest you'll need to account for the subtle energy dispersion better and also work on the hamonics better.
see what basveo can do for you google.

[casevos]

Sprint and US carriers in general

If Google can go solo they should. All US carriers are out of step
with the global cell phone industry. They have left the the US
woefully behind in mobile technology.

[joej25]

Way to go Google!

On what data do you base your opinion that Sprint is the worst carrier in the world?

I have had Sprint for years, do a lot of traveling, and have no problems with the service.

I think this is a great move for google.

[onlyauser]

GOP Chickens! Or should it be sickos?

The GOP candidates know that they are NOT on the same page of the majority of Americans. IMHO a CNN sponsored YouTube debate would be disaterous for them.

These old school gus are on the way out. The GOP needs to be re-worked to serve the people's interest not just the rich and big money.

Also, it is so ironic that the party that screams the most against big government (GOP). Is in reality all about the BIGGEST government. And it does not function worth a ****.

And let us not for get the "Moral Majority" LOL. Yeah the GOP has the most moral polititians. What a freakin' joke. This GOP party (and many of its hig-profile supporters) is the party of hypocrits and perverts.

These nuts are also spending our nations future on foreign nation building, financing war, demanding and pledging MORE defence spending. America supports 700+ military bases. Not only that but the US also out spends the other world military powers (all lumped together) by many times. JUST LOOK AT ALL THAT MONEY THAT COULD BE USED IN OUR OWN COUNTRY!

Why are my fellow Americans the most terrified country/people in the world? We does our country NEED to dominate every single world crisis.

Things are very currently going wrong in America.

One more thing to the GOP. Since it is obvious that you are all on drugs (and perverted acts). Listen to the words of Nancy Reagan and learn to "Just say no."

[onlyauser]

SORRY! I do not know how my political post ended up here.

OFF TOPIC

SORRY! I do not know how my political post ended up here.

[troy789]

Google knows what they are doing

I doubt very much that Google is planning to manufacture their own cell phone nor will they become a service provider ? can you imagine multi-colored Google cell towers covering the landscape?.(I can picture the sight? but I seriously doubt it will happen).

Google is essentially a media company generating revenue from advertisements. They provide content and applications for the benefit of mankind and make huge profits in return.

Google sees cell phones as a great place to imbed its applications but the largest players in the field aren?t playing ball. What is Google to do?

Up until recently there wasn?t much Google could do, a handful of cell phone companies own the airwaves and act like little dictators. But now that the 700 MHz spectrum is opening up Google has a chance at something??try to open up the playing field as much as possible so that they can implant their software on more cell phones.

To this effect Google is winning the battle and will probably win the war. Already the FCC has mandated that 22MHz must remain open to any and all cell phones or applications. Without spending a dime Google applications are now on 1/3 of the spectrum!

The FCC has also predicted that the auction will generate about $15 billion. Google has declared that it is prepared to bid about $4.6 billion or 1/3 of the estimated total. Since Google has already locked in 1/3 of the spectrum to its applications it can dedicate the billions of dollars to the remaining spectrum and purchase an additional 22MHz bringing the total spectrum that will support Google applications to 2/3 of the total 66MHZ.

Once Google owns the 22MHz, they can lease it out to smaller companies with the condition that access is kept open for Google applications and bandwidth for all those lucrative advertisement dollars.

With two thirds of the coveted 700MHz open, I doubt that even the big players will be able to resist the competitive pressures and will have to open up their networks. At this point, Google is declared victor and the consumer is saved from the "freedom hating" cell phone oligopoly dictators!

[exapted]

Very good points. I am curious about something though.

Is that how the math will work?

If Google gets 1/3 of airwaves, and 1/3 of the remaining 2/3 must be open, 5/9 of the airwaves must be open to Google applications/services.

However, Google's strategic alliances may allow Google applications/services to run over more than 1/3 of the 2/3 of the airwaves Google does not own. Perhaps 1/3 of the 2/3 will immediately and voluntarily allow Google applications to run. So Google might run on 1/3 + (1/3)*(2/3) + (1/3)*(2/3)*(2/3) = 3/9 + 2/9 + 4/27 = 19/27 of the wireless airwaves - more than 2/3.

Or are my assumptions incorrect?