Comments on: An RFID solution to rush hour headaches?

IBM says system of windshield transponders has helped Stockholm, Sweden, reduce traffic congestion by 25 percent.
Photos: RFID traffic reducer

[marsun]

Errors

You wrote that this would be political suicide in other parts of
the world. Well, it isn't exactly popular here in Sweden either...
Annika Billström has talked to the press several times,
complaining about her hatemail.

The scheme with the RFID tags didn't work. Well, the tags
themselves worked, but somehow someone messed up and
didn't draw money from the participants' bank accounts.
Unfortunately, the bad planning didn't consider this possibility,
and the system blamed the participants, who now has to pay via
the 'net or 7-elven. Oh, plus late fees. (Guess how popular this
is...)

And the license plates are surely not checked against the
national driver's license database, as the car owners are listed in
the national car register.

I might also add that a few people have had their license plates
stolen, and now have growing debts as the license plates every
day visits Stockholm during rush hours. (The politicians want
them to pay and then appeal.) Oh yes, this thing is wonderfully
set up. The people loooove it.

[Seaspray0]

But wait, there's more

What surprises me is you haven't gotten an email stating that your account for your RFID tag needs validating at www.this_is_a_scam.com where it will ask you to double check your info by entering your bank account and PIN information.

We have a similar setup in our city where the toll roads use these in some of the lanes. The traffic in those lanes is much faster and the toll costs less if you use the tag (the toll authority still makes their money by saving on equipment maintenance costs and less employees). It seems to work well.

[mantod]

London Congestion Charging

Such a scheme already exists in London, England. Rather than relying on drivers installing RFID tags it works through license plate recognition.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/london/congestion/technology.shtml

[schubb]

Pollution?

They say this is also a pollution control measure, yeah right. How about dumping the money into research on green vehicles, or in the places that can support it, better mass/rapid transit systems. I can't speak for swedish politicos, but in the US this would all go to pay higher salaries for the politicians. The ususal, "look what we did, we need more money".

When I had to, I hated waiting for the bus, getting on early so that I could get to where I needed to be late.

[ragjunk]

Where is technology helping?

Could the 25% reduction in traffic be from people flocking to public transportation to avoid paying traffic fees? The title of the article seemed to mean that the IBM technology helped manage rush hour traffic, which, clearly is not the case. Not sure if this will work in US, where people love to drive.

[aaroberts]

This is nothing new

Mass already has an RFID system. It's called easypass. Most of the eastern seaboard has the implemented at the toll gates. What we don't have is an integrated Mass Transit system not to mention that Corps. are spreadout all over the place.

[Mostrotux]

Here in Chile...

the technology has been around July 2005. I agree with you that the technology it self doesn't reduce pollution (except from the part that the system charge an extra fee in rush hours, which is not a big deal), but in Santiago (one of the most polluted capitals of the world) this system has:
help the government reduce their investment in highways making contracts with private capitals to invest.
Lower the number of traffic stops (wich accounts for almost 60% of gas).
Gather data of traffic movements (in order to plan a better public transport system)
Minning data to desing the future urbanizations.

The funny thing is that this system (at least in Chile) is not an IBM Technology.
http://www.roadtraffic-technology.com/projects/constanera/

Greetings

[taphilo]

Driving for the Rich or Write-off Eligable

Stockholm is doing what London has done for quite a while: extort money from people who work in the city and drive to work in order to save time.
It is a known fact if driving takes 30 minutes taking public transport takes 60 minutes.
For someone who earns $30 an hour public transport means losing that $30 a day. Thus, paying $5 to drive to work is worth it - you could still earn $25. To hourly wage earners it means nothing to get to work faster you earn the same amount, however you lose income to pay to drive to work.
So if you are a salaried or clock hour person your choice is to waste your time on public transport or lose income. After 120 days of work a year you have now wasted 120 hours of your life - three weeks - (in the best case) going to and from work.
And then cities wonder why people do not want to work downtown?

Tom Philo
http://taphilo.blogspot.com/

[chefgene1]

Isn't this just EZPass?

Sounds just like the EZ Pass we in New England have been using for eons. Even looks like the same windshield box.

[Sakamura]

Not going to work to well in Chicago

With the rising cost in gas and the rising cost of public transportation. You are just going to make the public angry if this was ever to be implemented in Chicago. We already have iPass which benefits drivers more than hinder.

[dianaagilesense]

RFID Solution: a better alternative for Asset Tracking

Static or in-motion assets tracking or locating, like a healthcare facility, wheelchairs or IV pumps in, laptops in a corporation and servers in a data center, was not so easy task.

User can instantly determine the general location of tagged assets anywhere within the facility with the help of active RFID technology. ?Control point? detection zones at strategic locations throughout the facility allow the user to define logical zones and monitor high traffic areas. Tagged assets moving through these control points provide instant location data.

Asset tracking applications will see an almost vertical growth curve in the coming years and the growth rate in this area will be much higher than the growth rate of general RFID market.

www.Agilesense.com provides you best RFID asste tracking services.