Comments on: New study questions mobile TV and music hype

Study could throw cold water on mobile carriers' hopes that people will spend big on mobile music downloads and TV.

[unknown unknown]

I am surprised people pay what they do for ring tones

It's not like sound good on a cellphone, and often don't contain the entire song. I suppose there are those gadget crazed individuals who will continue buy ring tones and video for their cellphones because it's the latest thing.

[unknown unknown]

I am surprised people pay what they do for ring tones

It's not like sound good on a cellphone, and often don't contain the entire song. I suppose there are those gadget crazed individuals who will continue buy ring tones and video for their cellphones because it's the latest thing.

[bobby_brady]

Watch TV on a 2" screen? What idiot does that? and PAY for it?

I'm surprised of anyone PAYING to watch TV on a 2" screen. They should be paying us!

[No invasion of privacy]

It's only a few inches from your face...

watching a 2" to 3" a few inches from your face is not too
dissimilar from watching a small (15") TV from a few feet away.

Having said that, I wouldn't want to do it myself for anything
more than a few minutes and I certainly wouldn't pay for the
"privilege". I suspect that the mobile carriers are getting a hard-
on for this idea because of the "success" of the iTMS videos,
thinking that most people watch those paid-for downloads on
their video iPods... IMO, what is more likely is that the majority
of people watch them on their computer and not on their iPod.

[bobby_brady]

Watch TV on a 2" screen? What idiot does that? and PAY for it?

I'm surprised of anyone PAYING to watch TV on a 2" screen. They should be paying us!

[No invasion of privacy]

It's only a few inches from your face...

watching a 2" to 3" a few inches from your face is not too
dissimilar from watching a small (15") TV from a few feet away.

Having said that, I wouldn't want to do it myself for anything
more than a few minutes and I certainly wouldn't pay for the
"privilege". I suspect that the mobile carriers are getting a hard-
on for this idea because of the "success" of the iTMS videos,
thinking that most people watch those paid-for downloads on
their video iPods... IMO, what is more likely is that the majority
of people watch them on their computer and not on their iPod.

[Stating]

Market Research?

So did the carriers that have launched this service do market research beforehand or not? Did they discount findings that were not supportive of their plans? Is this another example of "If we build it, they will come."? What is Plan B if revenue from these services does not meet expectations, what is the next big thing? Inquiring minds want to know.

[Stating]

Market Research?

So did the carriers that have launched this service do market research beforehand or not? Did they discount findings that were not supportive of their plans? Is this another example of "If we build it, they will come."? What is Plan B if revenue from these services does not meet expectations, what is the next big thing? Inquiring minds want to know.

[tundraboy]

Mobile t.v.

Remember the Watchman?
Nobody bought it then, why would anyone buy it now?

[tundraboy]

Mobile t.v.

Remember the Watchman?
Nobody bought it then, why would anyone buy it now?

[tundraboy]

It's the battery, stupid.

I suspect most people view their cell phone as an emergency device. The last thing they want to do is to needlessly run down the battery (by listening to music or watching t.v. on the phone) then be stuck with a dead cell phone while sitting in a stalled car in the middle of nowhere.

[sanenazok]

definitely

yes, but that was true about 10 years ago. Back then cell phones were for doctors only.

[tundraboy]

It's the battery, stupid.

I suspect most people view their cell phone as an emergency device. The last thing they want to do is to needlessly run down the battery (by listening to music or watching t.v. on the phone) then be stuck with a dead cell phone while sitting in a stalled car in the middle of nowhere.

[sanenazok]

definitely

yes, but that was true about 10 years ago. Back then cell phones were for doctors only.

What I'd pay for...

How about cell phone service that was a clear and reliable as my
landline service...that'd be something to get excited about! TV and
Music are both just really fancy icing on a really bland cake.

What I'd pay for...

How about cell phone service that was a clear and reliable as my
landline service...that'd be something to get excited about! TV and
Music are both just really fancy icing on a really bland cake.

[zincmann]

Freeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee if its not I dont want it....

I have to say I enjoy seeing these greedy telecom carriers suffer at the hands of their own stupidity. We already pay for mortgages and a car payment and assorted household bills, not about to PAY for something else I dont need!

[zincmann]

Freeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee if its not I dont want it....

I have to say I enjoy seeing these greedy telecom carriers suffer at the hands of their own stupidity. We already pay for mortgages and a car payment and assorted household bills, not about to PAY for something else I dont need!

[bobbutts]

network upgrade

The network upgrades are also useful for mobile internet connectivity which is used by business with a growing market for a long time. This article misses the point by focusing only on services handsets

[bobbutts]

network upgrade

The network upgrades are also useful for mobile internet connectivity which is used by business with a growing market for a long time. This article misses the point by focusing only on services handsets

[ZooVision]

Real World Example

While it might not show that the masses want mobile video
entertainment (We don't look at it as mobile TV, it's a much
different experience and the types of videos need to be different
as well) our company streams videos to mobile phones all over
the world. Our traffic for daily visitors is climbing everyday, in-
fact it's going through the roof!

So for us there is a market for mobile phone entertainment how
big the market will get is still very much up in the air. One thing
that is for sure, in the future these video entertainment services
are going to be free or bundled with data plans. Consumers
already pay too much for access tolls.

Sean
ZooVision
www.zoovision.com

[Earl Benser]

IMHO- the only thing dumber....

than some company honchos trying to provide video on a 2" or less
cellphone screen are the myriad of dumb ***** that believe they
can should pay to get video on on a 2" or less cellphone screen.

Zoovision will make much money while winning a a major award for
sponsoring idiocy among its customer. That is a very unfortunate
fact of modern life. It's like watching the vultures spread out the
poisoned grain for all the little mice and rats.

[ZooVision]

Real World Example

While it might not show that the masses want mobile video
entertainment (We don't look at it as mobile TV, it's a much
different experience and the types of videos need to be different
as well) our company streams videos to mobile phones all over
the world. Our traffic for daily visitors is climbing everyday, in-
fact it's going through the roof!

So for us there is a market for mobile phone entertainment how
big the market will get is still very much up in the air. One thing
that is for sure, in the future these video entertainment services
are going to be free or bundled with data plans. Consumers
already pay too much for access tolls.

Sean
ZooVision
www.zoovision.com

[Earl Benser]

IMHO- the only thing dumber....

than some company honchos trying to provide video on a 2" or less
cellphone screen are the myriad of dumb ***** that believe they
can should pay to get video on on a 2" or less cellphone screen.

Zoovision will make much money while winning a a major award for
sponsoring idiocy among its customer. That is a very unfortunate
fact of modern life. It's like watching the vultures spread out the
poisoned grain for all the little mice and rats.

[gfxdesign]

It's the cost....

I see new and interesting offerings on a daily basis. Problem is,
nearly all of them require hefty or even unlimited internet access
packages. And the providers are too dad-gummed proud of
those packages. To get unlimited internet access from my cell
provider, I'd have to pay double+ what my isp asks for unlimited
desktop/laptop access.

Uh, no. Don't think so.

The day I'll be actively interested in this stuff is the day the cell
carriers come down to earth and offer practical pricing. And they
need to understand that I will NOT pay as much for services on a
2.5 inch screen as I do for those on my desktop or laptop. Ain't
gonna happen. Period.

[gfxdesign]

It's the cost....

I see new and interesting offerings on a daily basis. Problem is,
nearly all of them require hefty or even unlimited internet access
packages. And the providers are too dad-gummed proud of
those packages. To get unlimited internet access from my cell
provider, I'd have to pay double+ what my isp asks for unlimited
desktop/laptop access.

Uh, no. Don't think so.

The day I'll be actively interested in this stuff is the day the cell
carriers come down to earth and offer practical pricing. And they
need to understand that I will NOT pay as much for services on a
2.5 inch screen as I do for those on my desktop or laptop. Ain't
gonna happen. Period.