Comments on: New Google desktop tool offers customization

Free software seems to move the search giant further into Microsoft and Yahoo territory.
Images: Google moves onto the desktop

Any Better Than 1.0

I wasn't all that impressed with Google Desktop Search 1.0. I wonder if this version is really any better. I've been using Copernic for several months without much complaint.

[TanNg]

Nothing innovative

GDS 2.0 borrowed ideas from
-- Yahoo Widget/My sidebar
-- Blinkx
-- DesktopSearch
but everything is not as good as competitor's appications.

Google OS

Another step toward the Google OS

not quite OS

to be realistic, i don't see why google would actually bother creating an OS in the traditional sense, dealing with hardware issues, file input/output, etc...

rather, what they are building are the capabilities to have a platform-independent interface, which you can use from any operating system. windows of course bundles the interface with the operating system, so does mac, and unix/linux distributors have joined that game, but if you leave the interface platform-independent (i.e. web/standards based) then the OS becomes irrelevant really.

everyone can still enjoy their fully integrated OS packages from Microsoft and Apple, but those have-nots, those on the other side of the digital divide, can pick up any free OS they can get their hands on, and as long as it has a standards-compliant web browser, they have, in essence, a "Google desktop", accessible through the browser.

brilliant really... hopefully this represents an end to corporate domination of OS interface. now if only someone could come up with an online Office package.

[joepwro]

Innovation on Tap

Google continues to impress me with their constant
innovation. The sidebar is quite useful and only
in its infancy.

Is there any other company out there that is even close to Googles level of innovation? If you think so, I would really like to hear about them.

[Andrew J Glina]

Easy

Sun -> Java
Apple -> GUI Pioneer
Microsoft -> Makes software that the common joe uses
Palm -> Made keyboardless organizers practical
ARM -> Made RISC CPUs for desktops
Intel -> CPUs
AMD -> Conviced the world to buy 64-bit chips without software for them....

What had Google done that no-one had done before? In most cases they just do what has been done before, just better. If that is innovation then Microsoft probably the most innovative company in the world...

[TanNg]

Innovative?

They copied it from others

Um, Innovation?

This isn't the first 3rd-party sidebar app, dude. There are others that you can download and install today, and Google's version is pretty much a direct rip-off of Longhorn's sidebar.

Kinda funny how when Google copies someone else, they're "innovative", but when Microsoft does it they're vilified for it.

[Christopher Hall]

Sidebar?

Can it be that I'm the only person out there who hates the idea of a sidebar? Keep the desktop area clean, don't clutter it up with useless "extras."

[BR-549]

You are not alone

I already know where I want to go and what I want to do, so do not need anything extra to clutter my desktop. I certainly do not need anything to search the hideous monstrosity of Microsoft’s Outlook inbox, when Eudora will immediately search all of several mail boxes (both in, out and otherwise) that have been configured for it. Add to that Google’s "Quick Find" and Sidebar panel designed to automatically update itself, and there will probably be extra garbage running in the background.

So I appreciate News.Com’s article on Google’s desktop tool because it gave me enough information to let me know that I do not want to even try such a thing. However, I imagine that the tool will be downloaded by the masses, simply because it is FREE!!!.

lots of extra space

but what is the point of having a clean desktop with one or two icons on it? anyway apple had the right idea with their "widgets" which appear only when mouse is on 1st or last pixel column. so both sides win.. clean desktop, and instant access to many functions instead of navigating multiple layers of folders/menus.

[Sikander]

Its Cool

It's pretty cool, no need to discourage every new good thing that comes up on the market, Innovation is one thing, even if Google is IMPROVING previously attmepted stuff, that's a goooooood thing. Be positive. I like it, I like my desktop clean too, I wasn't going to keep it if it just sat there on the right side of my desktop, but it's got an autohide feature, which makes it all very simple. All my news, Cnet, Wired, Gamespot, Slashdot, Cnn in one place plus a notepad, plus everything else, plus extra plugins u can download, that's just.....nice. Kudos Google.

Didn't work

Am I the only person in the world who had trouble with this product? I installed it and it completely slowed my PC down even when it wasn't indexing. Had to take it off.

[shzshi]

Integration with Other Application

Hi,

Iam Developing a application, within which i want google search should be integrated, same as it work with outlook express.
Is there any possiblity to do so ? Please help

Regards,
Shashi
http://www.hitechend.com

[MorganLighter]

New Google Desktop Tool...

Awesome. Thanks for the article - In my opinion, Google is making life easier.