Comments on: Comcast gives broadband users a speed boost

New feature allows users to get turbocharged downloads whenever excess capacity is available on the network.

[JLBer]

Big deal -- and I call BS.

Considering that Comcast is still very expensive when compared to DSL, I'd much prefer to keep my current 6Mb connection with a price cuy. Okay, when I'm downloading the latest version of Solaris or the newest "Battlefield 2" patch, I want speed. But 99% of my Internet usage is not anywhere close to even the current 6Mb limit. I've actually considered getting Verizon 3Mb/768Kb DSL for $29 because of the few times that I max out my connection every month. I'll still get 768Kb up for gaming while saving close to $25 per month.

And exactly who does Comcast think they're fooling? This speed boost is CLEARLY meant to compete with FIOS, which Verizon is starting to really push. This has absolutely NOTHING to do with "extra capacity" or the fraudulent benevolence that Comcast is purporting to be showing.

Spare me the speed boost. You can keep me at 6M/768K. Just knock off $20/month instead.

[Dachi]

That is why

You are correct to state this is becasue of FIOS.

Also, the occasional high bandwidth download (like Solaris ISO's) tend to use much less overall bandwidth than a PC infected with a virus or loaded with spyware that consistantly send many small packets.

As for the need for greater upload, while there are valid reasons for needing it, most of them tend to be stuff than would be against their TOS anyway.

Giving a few million PC's a 16 meg upload overnight could lead to trouble.

[cpresco]

Faster downloads? Who cares?!?!

I'm a Time Warner customer in Green Bay stuck at 384K up and hate it. Uploading something simple like pictures to Snapfish takes forever. Cable operators are highly lagging behind when it comes to upload speeds and this is making me start to consider DSL options which are typically 2x that of cable operators in this area.

[naterandrews]

how is this really newsworthy?

i didnt know that you could turn a simple speed increase for an isp into an entire article. so comcast increased speeds for customers, whoop de doo. you dont need to have an exaggerated analytical approach to posting that... jeeze!

[chriswaco]

FASTER UPLOADS

They are insane if they think that people don't want faster uploads.

[pcpimpster]

17.1 megabits per second

Thats the speed i just scored on my comcast 6 mbps commercial account.
http://www.bandwidthplace.com

I'm in PA, so maybe they are doing this for business customers already or maybe this is just a goofy marketing tactic.

I have 2 * 6 mbps accounts, load balanced through a Xincom dual WAN router (that score was just for one WAN, both get about the same speed).

Can't beat those speeds for 200 bucks a month, even though uploads are only @ T1 speeds.

But...

FOIS is looking real good for uploads, once it is available in my area.

[csturdivant]

SBC DSL

I used to be jealous of my Comcast friends when I was on 1500/256 DSL, but within the past year I was upgraded to 3000/512 and just recently up to 6000/768....all for $27.99 a month as well.

[WadeF]

Not seeing a difference.

I pay for the extra speed (Previously 6Mbps) and now I'm supposed to have 8Mbps with a boost up to 16mbps. I'm not seeing this on the speed tests. Internetfrog.com does show 8mbps, but when I download files I'll usually get 400-500kbps. Shouldn't I bet getting 800kbps-1600kbps? Will my Comcast cable modem support these higher speeds? I had to get a new modem to make the jump from 4mbps to 6mbps.

[kyler]

I notice slight changes

I am downloading a torrent thats about 750MB, and a month ago it
would get maxium speeds of around 25kb/s - depending on how
many uploads/seeds there are, but lately, about every 10 min, it
jumps from that 25kb/s to almost 300kb/s and stays that way for
about 5 min, then slowly goes back down to 25. its a nice upgrade
considering i download a lot of these torrents, most of which use to
take 3 days to download, now take 2 hours at most.
love it.

[Shaun8121]

NICE!! Why are ppl complaining ITS FREE!!

I live in York, Pa. and they just took over suscom.net and I am glade they did!! Comcast Tech's are great! They wont cover up anything, if they know you have a know-how on how things kinda work. Anyway! This speed boost is a Good thing! Why are you complaining?? Its FREE.. I don't give much on Uploading.. Downloading is what we knead!! Good job Comcast. The ones that are complaining, don't have any clue..