Comments on: Spying an intelligent search engine

Innovation in Web search using artificial intelligence may lead to the day when you could expect the Web to do the tedious tasks for you.

[Drewky]

AI

Artifical Intelligence is a meaningless buzz word. A rule based system would be accurate but no where near the emotional context of artifical intelligence. Inference Engine would be just as buzzy but much more accurate. I am sure others could come up with other terms. Maybe you should hold a contest to see who comes up with the best descriptive term. I submit Inference Engine.I hear AI and I instantly think Vapor.

[WesFlash]

Face recognition has great potential

Forget finding a girl that looks like my last girlfriend and will remind me of that pain. Law enforcement searches will benefit from facial recognition. From matching a missing kid to a kiddie porn image to finding a fellon that changed his/ her identity. For law enforcement it will be an new and invaluable tool, trolling the mug shots and internet in search of possible matches to all kinds of case files.

[Sea of Cortez]

AI is just code word for vapor/hoax ware.

I agree with other poster, AI is just code word for vapor/hoax ware.

If I had gotten a dollar for each time I heard of AI and then nothing of sort was ever delivered I would be a rich man.
There is no such a thing as AI (Artificial Intelligence) software and there wont be any, because we have no idea of how to emulate complex intelligent thinking in software, there is only good software engineering.

So it is not AI that is going to make a better search engine to Google & Yahoo, it is innovative new search engine ideas which are implemented based on good software engineering work that it is going to do it. And I will tell you about a search engine that is better than Google or Yahoo,
it is called Anoox, and it is better based on these points:
1- It is powered by the Knowledge of the people
2- It is operated in an Open fashion, so NO one company owns/controls it but 100's of different company's from around the world will
It is here in case:
www.anoox.com
Ah, another reason it is better, it is also not-for-profit.

[darmik]

Goolge has pushed the limit of html search

google has pushed the limit of html search. as long as pages and sites continued to be created in a way and format that does not allow for descprtive classification any real AI will be impssoble

[Rob at Collarity]

True Natural Relevance not AI

I think AI as a search descriptor is a little oxymoronic as well. The comments here demonstrate how each person has their own contextual relationship to the keyword "AI".

I do however agree that search as a science is in its infancy and that current cpu/storage efficiencies now make it possible to deliver an events-based (usage) search architecture connected to individual users, instead of the current link-topology-connected-to-no-one system we?ve all learned to love and hate.

We?re also not ready to throw the ?keywordese? out the door. We believe there is a lot of natural intelligence in keyword associations (i.e, John Battelle?s ?data base of intentions?) that can provide an order-of-magnitude better relevance if they can be properly distilled ? whether it?s applied to search, feeds, or media. We think the key is making it implicit (no explicit tagging or rating) and to make sure you have 100% participation ? every user is both an information consumer and an information provider for every other user in the system.

[guyfrom2006]

Its time to roll on the next generation Search Engine

The popularity of the internet is that it offers a variety of content not available in any other medium. A search engine assists users to locate the information.

The Internet is supposed to be for fun not serious business.

And that is why most people use research tools and offline content to achieve their results. Internet search is the last place a true researcher would go to find top rated content. Only after all other options are closed.

What if the internet offered this as the very first option and people could be sure that all the information that the internet and internet search throws up is Top rated quality stuff and it is available free/subscribed/paid. I am myself a researcher and would love to have such a tool in my hands instead of having to spend a huge amount on buying proprietary research content.

Once I finished using the content, I need not pay for it. There are many websites such as Janes.com which provide this sort of quality info.

Present Internet Search is neither intelligent nor smart. Cluster search engines such as Vivisimo and clusty.com help to some extent but stull trash out the same stuff.

In this respect, I admire the efforts of NetAlter which is bringing a radical new search engine that would offer quality content and meta information. According to NetAlter, their search engine would offer a variety of pre-search and post search tools that enable sorting, comparing and analyzing of search results and also offer a single click ecommerce connection.

Check out the NetAlter search whitepaper and presentation.

http://www.netalter.com/Solutions/search.pdf

http://www.netalter.com/Solutions/Search.pps

[Himanshu_Joshi]

new search required

3D search idea by Micosoft is the one i find quite useful and it invloves user interaction as well... currently many search engine do give anonymous links to increase the number of pages but only some r useful.
thanx
Himanshu joshi
http://montoojoshi.googlepages.com/onlinecompiler

[readyforthefuture]

AI is already being added to search engines

People need to start following the AI bouncing ball at Google and other search innovators. The integration of the CYC taxonomy, for example, appears to be well under way with available frameworks that allow natural language and human logic to prevail over "keywordism" in the very near future.

http://www.cyc.com/cyc/cycrandd/areasofrandd_dir/distributedai