Comments on: Microsoft kicks off search effort

Firm replaces Yahoo's search technology with its own and launches widespread ad campaign, in hopes of dethroning Google.
Images: Microsoft revs its search engine

[Not Bugged]

new msn search sucks big time

Right after i found out about it i went to test it if it can help me with my problem. i entered: gateway "usb keyboard" problem. First two results were shopping offers! and I am not talking about advertisment at top of the page! Results have no relevance!!! Searched words are not even close to each other on result pages. Coplet mess. 0 out of 10 not even 1 for effort.

[Lite Rocker]

what will be the mile long url?

msn.com/search ? nope

search.msn.com ? nope

long gibberish string that has no resemblance to "MSN Search" ? CORRECT!!

http://www.imagine-msn.com/search/tour/moreprecise.aspx

when will MSFT learn that the name is half the marketing.

Google - noun and verb

Yahoo- same.

[catchall]

Please

OK, the search powers MSN... lets give it a second of thought... Just one second now... How about www.msn.com
Imagine that! There it is.

Now, having toyed with it for a few minutes, I'm rather unimpressed.

Works for me

search.msn.com works for me. Maybe you should do a search on configuring DNS.

[Christopher Hall]

Some Observations

I just got back from a test drive with the new MSN search. The first thing I notice is that the interface is still almost identical to that of Yahoo!'s. Even down to the rectangle with a triangle on the bottom that points to the "Web" search selection.

Moving along, a search in Google, Yahoo!, and MSN for "2005 Corvette" yielded some interesting results. Starting with the reigning champ, Google listed two websites (with one subsite each) before getting to www.chevrolet.com/corvette, one of which was the museum and the other of which was a forum. Prices and sales are on the side, which is nice.

By my own admission, I don't use Yahoo!, but figured I would for comparison. Yahoo! gives me the option to try other searches in the same category, such as "2005 corvette pictures, 2005 chevrolet corvette, 2005 corvette z06," which is a nice touch (especially the Z06 one - ROWR!). Sponsored results are all over the page, though, on the top - there are three - and the side - there are eight. As usual, these deal primarily with shopping, and if I were in the market, I'm sure I would find these useful. I'm not sure what the "Yahoo! Shortcut" is, but it seems to be another sponsored link. Right below that, the first true search result, is the Corvette homepage. So Yahoo! nails it in one (kinda).

Finally, there's MSN. Three sponsored links right up front, five on the side. corvetteforum.com comes up first on the results list, followed by the homepage. Although changing the language settings bumps it down to third, behind an image gallery.

So my conclusions? I don't have any compelling reason to prefer either of the three, so I'll probably just keep doing what I've been doing for the last 8 or so years: googling. As far as brand-loyalty goes, though, I don't have any. Microsoft has yet to wow me, though. How about a 3D representation of the search results in connected bubbles? That would be cool.

[shoffmueller]

MSN Search This

So, yeah, MSN wants our lexicon to change from googling to MSN Searching. That will happen.

Or, based on their URL: http://www.imagine-msn.com/search/tour/moreprecise.aspx

Instead of saying, "I googled your name, we can say:
Hey, "let me imagine msn search tour more precised your name"

[unixrules]

It gives me the creeps

First, you go to msn.com and there is Gates puss grinning at you. Then, you get totally bogus search results, all the while wondering how much info MS has gathered about what you are doing. I'll stick with google, thanks.

[Christopher Hall]

HAHAHA

Thanks for the laugh, I needed that.

Gates' puss... That's classic.

[NWLB]

Fate has a way of getting back at MS, somebody just cracked their DRM....

This guy's blog indicates people in Japan have found a way to crack Microsoft's DRM software wide open.
Chris Lanier's Blog:
http://msmvps.com/chrisl/archive/2005/01/31/34499.aspx

NWLB
****************
www.NWLBnet.blogspot.com

[dznr]

Where is the LINK, folks?

I can't believe that News.com could publish an article
about a major website and not include a clickable link to that
website.

Nice going, folks! You apparently really understand the web!

[pencoyd]

First link in story is to MSN, where search is featured

The very first link in the story goes to MSN (www.msn.com), and the new search is prominently featured on that page.

Thanks for reading.

John Roberts
CNET News.com product development

[ca5ter]

Looks Like Yahoo!

Search results aside, you would think having a product two years
in the making would give MS enough time to think of their
own design. The new home page design is a copy of Yahoo's.
Well at least we now know MS just doesn't copy Apple, but any
successful company... Look out Starbucks your next.

I'll take a Microsoft Latte Home Edition Longhorn Expresso
Grande®, hold the Desktop Search please!

Interesting examples on where MSN breaks down...a joke on AOL?

Microsoft just released its new search engine on msn.com. I was interested to see what ad deals it had (are they still working with Yahoo?). Turns out their premier ads are MSN ads but their secondary ads are still Overture (Yahoo). But there's obviously still some glitches in the search itself. Try typing in "mortgage" (my generic test word for keyword advertising) on msn.com. Maybe by the time you try, they'll have fixed it, but for now, the first non-advertiser link is titled "Checking Connection Speed" which is a pre-page spiders find on www.aol.com. The link goes to AOL's homepage. Is this a Microsoft joke on the fact that AOL has mortgaged anything it ever used to be? Link number two is appropriately www.sss-mortgage.com.

Interesting note: this only appears when I search through an American computer. My direct connection with a French IP address doesn't show AOL. It also doesn't show any ads, MSN or Overture.

[orphu]

Try it again

Take off your 'I Hate MS' hat & try it again. Yes, the first two are shopping links (which many search portals serve up), but the first two 'regular links' point to Gateway. Of the first 10 regular links, 4 point to a Gateway domain. Do the same search on Google and only the first of 10 points to Gateway.

Bash MS all you want, but at least engage your brain first.

[SmokieUK]

RE:

[i]"Now that Microsoft is launching its own technology, the software giant will be working hard to outpace rivals, using its Internet Explorer browser and its desktop dominance to make a lasting impression."[/i]

Smell an anti-trust lawsuit anyone?