Comments on: TVUPlayer: Another Napster?

The video service is building an audience but legal experts wonder about copyright issues.
Image: Peer-to-peer television

[thedreaming]

Good idea, Bad Implementation

Having cable/satelite channels available on the web using a little player is actually a great idea. Think about it. You're bored at work, there's no work, but they won't send you home, so you have to wait for work to suddenly appear. What do you do? Simple, watch tv.

The problem here is copyright and since this new company doesn't have redistribution rights then their whole operation is illegal.

What's going to be interesting is that this company is in China. It's not going to be easy to shut them down. Plus, what's their business model? How are they going to make money by giving the content away for free?

[frmorrison]

$

This is from the article, "subscribe to pay channels and pay-per-view events". It seems you have to pay for certain streams of content.

However, this seems to be illegal, even with commericals rebroadcast.

[dangurtoo]

Illegal but not in China

So what if it is legal or illegal in the USA or elsewhere?....China obviously doesnt recognize the copyright laws of the USA. As you said shutting them down would be hard in China....and if they are paying for their own subscriptions to some cable provider to provide those channels...then the cable company is still making their moneys. The advertisers are benefitting even more by having their messages played to an even wider audience.
What exactly is illegal here anyway?...if the cable TV provider that is supplying the content to whoever is the paying customer (TVU)...and they choose to retransmit their cable selection...what is the loss (other than people not subscribing to cable providers)?

[powerclam]

XP only, so who cares.

The player is XP only, so who friggin' cares?
As for illegality - it is based in China, where 99.9% of windows installs are illegal anyway, so...

[pararealist]

One thing that really sickens me is when a crook complains about someone stealing from them.
After raping the rest of the world to be able to live the life the western world wants to, now it complains when the rest of the world starts "stealing" from them. You cant have it both ways.

Anyway the whole world now seems to be based on a crooked viewpoint, this viewpoint having been set by the western world, steal until you get caught, if you dare, else go under. This will go on until the whole mentality of the world changes, or some alien forces attack earth and we have to pull everything together, so let us enjoy while we can and stop ********.
So much money is made and still they want more. Greed, it sadly is a human trait by now.