Comments on: Google Video goes live

Content, interface and prices fail to impress as Google launches its video-on-demand Web site.

[df561]

Horrendous interface

Google needs to hire some UI gurus asap. the minimalist stuff is great for search, but not for browsing a store! ewwwww!

still great that independents can sell content, but frankly as a consumer I would much prefer to buy from iTunes. If Google can spruce up the UI maybe I'll have the confidence to return.

I agree. I really dislike the experience.

I can only speak for myself, but I really dislike the Google Video Store. Your discription is perfect: "ewwwww!"

I don't like the layout. If I go to Star Trek Voyager from the drop down menu, there are only five episodes. I don't know which season they are from unless I click on each one.

If I go to the 'movies' section from the drop down menu, I just get a bunch of random movies with no organization whatsoever.

The one thing I do like is the preview window which is nice and big.

I hope they make some improvements or I don;t see myself shopping there. I'll stick with Apple iTunes which has a very slick and very organized UI.

[df561]

Horrendous interface

Google needs to hire some UI gurus asap. the minimalist stuff is great for search, but not for browsing a store! ewwwww!

still great that independents can sell content, but frankly as a consumer I would much prefer to buy from iTunes. If Google can spruce up the UI maybe I'll have the confidence to return.

I agree. I really dislike the experience.

I can only speak for myself, but I really dislike the Google Video Store. Your discription is perfect: "ewwwww!"

I don't like the layout. If I go to Star Trek Voyager from the drop down menu, there are only five episodes. I don't know which season they are from unless I click on each one.

If I go to the 'movies' section from the drop down menu, I just get a bunch of random movies with no organization whatsoever.

The one thing I do like is the preview window which is nice and big.

I hope they make some improvements or I don;t see myself shopping there. I'll stick with Apple iTunes which has a very slick and very organized UI.

[timb2006]

Didn't mind it but...

Here's what I get when I clicked the buy link:
"We're sorry, but this video is not available in your country". Content providers don't get it, won't get it and never will get it - that's why this will fail. It's comforting to know that anytime someone fires up a P2P client to get the same content, they are actively taking money out of the pockets of those idiots who put stupid restrictions like this on content.

[timb2006]

Didn't mind it but...

Here's what I get when I clicked the buy link:
"We're sorry, but this video is not available in your country". Content providers don't get it, won't get it and never will get it - that's why this will fail. It's comforting to know that anytime someone fires up a P2P client to get the same content, they are actively taking money out of the pockets of those idiots who put stupid restrictions like this on content.

[ronwinship]

Google is better than you think!

We have uploaded 15 ready for primetime shows to Google which include some real insight with Fess Parker, Bob Dornan and even one with Minuteman Founder Chris Simcox.....Try our Sydney Pollack or Caspar Weinberger for fun or find out everything you ever wanted to know about DNA at
50....during a one hour show......all for free..
thank you very much!

Ron & Anna Winship
Cutting Edge - a talk show

[ronwinship]

Google is better than you think!

We have uploaded 15 ready for primetime shows to Google which include some real insight with Fess Parker, Bob Dornan and even one with Minuteman Founder Chris Simcox.....Try our Sydney Pollack or Caspar Weinberger for fun or find out everything you ever wanted to know about DNA at
50....during a one hour show......all for free..
thank you very much!

Ron & Anna Winship
Cutting Edge - a talk show

[jedbroadbent]

Not Mac compatible

The ugly interface aside, it also does not seem to work on Mac,
When you click on a video it says:

"Sorry, purchasing this video requires Windows 2000 or Windows
XP."

[jedbroadbent]

Not Mac compatible

The ugly interface aside, it also does not seem to work on Mac,
When you click on a video it says:

"Sorry, purchasing this video requires Windows 2000 or Windows
XP."

[Blito]

The Linux Test

Allot seemed to work for Linux and some needed Windows.

For me the interface didnt look too bad I will post a screenshot.

http://www.supload.com/thumbs/default/snapshot6.png
http://www.supload.com/thumbs/default/snapshot7.png

Not bad as I dont have cable or tv and it's nice to see Charle Rose although I just wish they would give it out for freee on their websites but...

Probably a FLAT FEE rate would be nice like the musicnow.com service I use.
I might pay 5 dollars a month right now because of weak content.
I dont feel comfortable with that many credit card purchases.

[Blito]

Larger pictures

http://www.supload.com/free/snapshot6.png/view/
http://www.supload.com/free/snapshot7.png/view/

[Blito]

The Linux Test

Allot seemed to work for Linux and some needed Windows.

For me the interface didnt look too bad I will post a screenshot.

http://www.supload.com/thumbs/default/snapshot6.png
http://www.supload.com/thumbs/default/snapshot7.png

Not bad as I dont have cable or tv and it's nice to see Charle Rose although I just wish they would give it out for freee on their websites but...

Probably a FLAT FEE rate would be nice like the musicnow.com service I use.
I might pay 5 dollars a month right now because of weak content.
I dont feel comfortable with that many credit card purchases.

[Blito]

Larger pictures

http://www.supload.com/free/snapshot6.png/view/
http://www.supload.com/free/snapshot7.png/view/

[207495111267145837975635436522]

What else will Google Big Media machine try to control next!!!

The more I see from Google, the more I become
certain that it truly is the Big brother, right
along with Microsoft & other Big US media ources.
After all they keep passing Billions of dollars
to each other and hyping each other.

That is why I have been looking for a search
engine that is both pure play on search and that
it is people driven rather than wanting to ontrol
the peoples (eye balls) minds world wide. I have
found it, you should know about it too. It is AnooX:
www.anoox.com

But problem with AnooX is that again it is a US
based search engine - again! However they offer
their search engine for free under Open Source
license to those whom want to provide it in
under languages. So I hope top quality ISPs in
various countries in Europe and elsewhere will
grab their code and start offering AnooX french, German, Italian, etc, outside of US, that would
be only way to ensure the highest freedom of
information.

[207495111267145837975635436522]

What else will Google Big Media machine try to control next!!!

The more I see from Google, the more I become
certain that it truly is the Big brother, right
along with Microsoft & other Big US media ources.
After all they keep passing Billions of dollars
to each other and hyping each other.

That is why I have been looking for a search
engine that is both pure play on search and that
it is people driven rather than wanting to ontrol
the peoples (eye balls) minds world wide. I have
found it, you should know about it too. It is AnooX:
www.anoox.com

But problem with AnooX is that again it is a US
based search engine - again! However they offer
their search engine for free under Open Source
license to those whom want to provide it in
under languages. So I hope top quality ISPs in
various countries in Europe and elsewhere will
grab their code and start offering AnooX french, German, Italian, etc, outside of US, that would
be only way to ensure the highest freedom of
information.

[enowtom]

Google's only good at text search

I don't think this is Google's first bad product, I think ALL of their products except text and image search are inferior to the competition. Gmail changed webmail not because the UI or functionality is better (e.g., feelings about its folderless model are mixed at best) but simply because of the 1 gig storage; Froogle is OK, but not a category winner by any means; Google News finds some good stories, but often has very odd or fringe sources in its lead stories; Orkut never took off; their Google Pack is a joke (wow, Adobe Reader!); the list goes on. I love Google's text search, but I think these guys are a one trick pony. It's a company run by engineers, and it shows - take a look at the video on CNET of Larry Page at CES and tell me it doesn't make you want to sell your Google shares.

[Johnny Mnemonic]

No Steve Jobs...

He's definitely no Steve Jobs. Ofcourse he is a
great geek ;)

When you put it that way

When you put it that way, I think you're right. I would also call their AdSense advertising system very innovative, and the best of the bunch (far better than overture). But thats not really a consumer product, nor is it new.

The only really cool product of late was Google Earth, and that was bought from Keyhole.

[df561]

you nailed it!

100% agreed, unfortunately

[enowtom]

Google's only good at text search

I don't think this is Google's first bad product, I think ALL of their products except text and image search are inferior to the competition. Gmail changed webmail not because the UI or functionality is better (e.g., feelings about its folderless model are mixed at best) but simply because of the 1 gig storage; Froogle is OK, but not a category winner by any means; Google News finds some good stories, but often has very odd or fringe sources in its lead stories; Orkut never took off; their Google Pack is a joke (wow, Adobe Reader!); the list goes on. I love Google's text search, but I think these guys are a one trick pony. It's a company run by engineers, and it shows - take a look at the video on CNET of Larry Page at CES and tell me it doesn't make you want to sell your Google shares.

[Johnny Mnemonic]

No Steve Jobs...

He's definitely no Steve Jobs. Ofcourse he is a
great geek ;)

When you put it that way

When you put it that way, I think you're right. I would also call their AdSense advertising system very innovative, and the best of the bunch (far better than overture). But thats not really a consumer product, nor is it new.

The only really cool product of late was Google Earth, and that was bought from Keyhole.

[df561]

you nailed it!

100% agreed, unfortunately

Underwhelmed

I was looking at it yesterday. Kind of underwhelming. Interface is next to useless. Most of the videos I was interested in were 'rentals', and you had to use their viewer to watch them (thus making the purchase pointless). I really expected something far more innovative from google, but they failed to deliver.

Underwhelmed

I was looking at it yesterday. Kind of underwhelming. Interface is next to useless. Most of the videos I was interested in were 'rentals', and you had to use their viewer to watch them (thus making the purchase pointless). I really expected something far more innovative from google, but they failed to deliver.

[ontarget]

"don't throw the baby out with the bath water"

I respectfully disagree with your generalization attacking the quality of the roll out by Video Google. For those of us who are independent producers of cost and commercial free content we are very pleased to have access to this worthy public service. Currently we have over 12 unique and informative programs on Google. Check out our Caspar Weinberger, Bob Dornan or DNA at 50 shows and see for yourselves what Google and Cutting Edge freely offer to viewers worldwide.
Larry Gilbert, investigative reporter, Cutting Edge a talk show

[The user with no name]

Just What I'm Looking For

Casper freakin Weinberger, Bob Dornan or DNA at 50! LOL

No I'm sorry to say that while a SMALL market may be interested in THIS stuff... most people as can be seen from other comments are looking for MAIN STREAM items... TV & Movies

While this new Google product is certainly a great tool for independant producers to put out their own content. And hopefully they will get some play due to it being on Google instead of some personal web space.

However, I believe that Google's intent was to provide a service that would appeal to the MAINSTREAM CONSUMER... and unfortunately that means episodes from actual TV and a video store selection of movies.

Also iTunes model stops consumer unhappiness by making ALL content available to all USERS... no "sorry this is not available to your country" and no outrageous prices for limited fair and limited interest selections...

Sorry....

[ontarget]

"don't throw the baby out with the bath water"

I respectfully disagree with your generalization attacking the quality of the roll out by Video Google. For those of us who are independent producers of cost and commercial free content we are very pleased to have access to this worthy public service. Currently we have over 12 unique and informative programs on Google. Check out our Caspar Weinberger, Bob Dornan or DNA at 50 shows and see for yourselves what Google and Cutting Edge freely offer to viewers worldwide.
Larry Gilbert, investigative reporter, Cutting Edge a talk show

[The user with no name]

Just What I'm Looking For

Casper freakin Weinberger, Bob Dornan or DNA at 50! LOL

No I'm sorry to say that while a SMALL market may be interested in THIS stuff... most people as can be seen from other comments are looking for MAIN STREAM items... TV & Movies

While this new Google product is certainly a great tool for independant producers to put out their own content. And hopefully they will get some play due to it being on Google instead of some personal web space.

However, I believe that Google's intent was to provide a service that would appeal to the MAINSTREAM CONSUMER... and unfortunately that means episodes from actual TV and a video store selection of movies.

Also iTunes model stops consumer unhappiness by making ALL content available to all USERS... no "sorry this is not available to your country" and no outrageous prices for limited fair and limited interest selections...

Sorry....

[shynes]

Google will legitimize horrendous videos

The "most popular" bit - do we need this? I thought they would do no evil, but the most popular video today is a helicopter crash. Will it be explosive dismemberment tomorrow? Now our darkest curiosities are legitimized by a rating system, which really is nothing more than a rating of human pathology.

Steve Hynes

[shynes]

Google will legitimize horrendous videos

The "most popular" bit - do we need this? I thought they would do no evil, but the most popular video today is a helicopter crash. Will it be explosive dismemberment tomorrow? Now our darkest curiosities are legitimized by a rating system, which really is nothing more than a rating of human pathology.

Steve Hynes