Comments on: DVR technology comes to video iPods

New software and hardware allow TV watchers to record shows directly to their PCs, video iPods and Sony PlayStation Portables.

[Dead Soulman]

Interesting

I'm all for it. But, it won't be long before the studios will start complaing about the portability of their programs. Just like they tried to kill the recording abilities of VHS, and dvd's. They may pull off some trick. Kind of the "blank cd-r tax" record companies levied on blank media purchases. BTW, are we still paying for it?

However, I don't know how they expect for the encoding to take such a short time. Encoding usually takes from 1.5x - 3x the amount of actual length of show. Now, if you go for low quality, then it might work ok.

[just_some_guy]

Did I misread it?

<However, I don't know how they expect for the encoding to take such a short time. Encoding usually takes from 1.5x - 3x the amount of actual length of show. Now, if you go for low quality, then it might work ok.>


Unless I misread, the article says that encoding with this software takes 2x the length of the show. That doesn't seem like a short time to me (and it is within the range you said it usually takes). Here is the relavant quote:



Recording programs using Wing typically takes about twice as long as playback, said Plotkin. For example, a one-hour episode of "Desperate Housewives" would take about two hours to record.

[skeptik]

Not so fast!

He also said that users needn't worry that they're breaking the law when using Wing. That's because the software is designed for personal use only.

"It's like recording to a VHS tape and putting it onto a VHS player," he said. "There's nothing here that helps people if they want to take a TV show and distribute it."

I suspect Hollywood will not agree. By changing the format and preseentation, you are modifying their content and Hollywood will protest, thought their real reason will be that they didn't get to charge you for the portable copy.
In anyevent, the programming will soon include DRM that will make this illegal if still possible. (You can't legally break our DRM and our DRM says you can't record or transfer content, regardless if fair-use says your actions are legal.)

[mcepat]

Microsoft Portable Media Centers?

been doing DVR functionality on the small screen for a few years now, and compared to the IPOD and the PSP has the easiest transfer method, just plug it in a sync your TV