Comments on: Wikibooks takes on textbook industry

Project aims to create open-ended curriculum that would offer a free, licensable alternative to traditional textbooks.

[Jimmu411]

How would this work?

What happens when somone puts out a text on the origin of Man? Seems like you'd have constant alterations by various religious fundamentalists and Darwinian proponents each "correcting" the mistakes of the others, with occasional insertions by feminists demanding that the topic should be the origin of Persons...

[Karios Kasra]

same as wikipedia

backups of every change, admins have the right to revert changes, voting in place for best version, etc.

[hadaso]

"Evoultion" is in the Wikipedia and seems to last (and evolve...)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution

strategy

I think that the strategy for textbook companies is pretty straight-
forward. Instead of hiring authors to write textbooks, hire them to
supply information to a wikitextbook. Restrict editing to these
people. Then sell access to the wikitextbook to students. It's not a
true wiki, but close enough if you have enough editors.

[nasser0000]

This is fine for textbooks, but ...

my wife has grown weary of the constant, download this 40 page except from a book, etc. etc. that she sees at her school. It's like, we pay HOW MUCH? and you aren't willing to print them yourselves and hand them out to us?

Also, what happens if a student does not have broadband or their broadband goes down?

[hollasch]

Reader Requirements

My new PDA has VGA resolution of around 160dpi. The ultimate target for standard reading resolution is around 200dpi. A reading device at that resolution surpases printed reading (particularly with backlighting, search, audio, annotations and so forth). Prototype devices already a few years old easily held around 350 novels. Couple that with continuous or even sporadic broadband/network access, and you have the other end of the story. Imagine a device that completely surpassed what you get with a bookcase, which you could carry with you anywhere, mark up, cross link, and occasionally update when possible. The wait is killing me...

Or what if I want to read elsewhere?

Or what if I want to cram for finals the way I did when I was in college, buried into my hammock between two trees on the other side of campus from my dorm, to minimize distractions? Not the best place to have to read all my "textbooks" off a computer.

[tantrik]

How about a USB Flash Drive

That way you can download what you want onto the flash drive and the kid can take it to school.
Some schools are insisting on this already.

[cjohn17]

Suspect Revisionist History

I've found that many of the search results contain revisionist
history with a noticeable left tilt.

I consider this a suspect product at best. No surprise considering
its open source with little editorial oversight.

http://espellahumanzee.blogspot.com/