Comments on: Bill Gates' syllabus for tech and education

Globalization to allow for more specialization in the way people learn, Microsoft chairman says at Edinburgh forum.

[asdf]

the Econo-terrorist speaks,and I should listen...why?

<snip>A global economy in which people are more connected than ever before is becoming more of a reality each day, he said, and to prepare, government must promote innovation.</snip>

This from the world's leading econo-terrorist. How many companies and how much market value has MS destroyed? How many programmers / companies has he driven out of business through illegal monopolist practices? How many man hours has the built-by-monopoly-trash that Redmond spews cost this nation? The world? What is market value he's trashed? A trillion? Two trillion? Give me a break. Let's not forget MS 100-a-day new software patents they are filing to use to further consolidate their monopolist position. In the words of Steve Balmer- either get out of our way or get your lawyers and let's go to court. --That's MS's new "value add"; that's MS's "innovation".
http://swpat.ffii.org/gasnu/microsoft/index.en.html

I can see why people listen to MS at product announcements, but why does CNET give this less-than-average and not-that-bright guy the time of day when it comes to economic / political or social policy? Do you really think that he's a visionary? How's your paperless office working out for you? Is that here yet? What a joke.

[pjianwei]

I guess he sees more of the world in a year

than most of the others see in a lifetime.

[techie2479]

EU, others are on-board...

At least historically, according to the FFII.org reference; there's been more collaboration with MS than efforts against it (politically or commercially.)

Microsoft is a "big player" in the world; but even they don't own the game.

[ghostofitpast]

What you don't know CAN hurt you

For all the talk about how we are moving from a production economy to a service economy, I feel that, here in the United States, we have shown ourselves to be incredibly inept (if not customer-hostile) in the service sector (which probably goes hand-in-glove with our inability to keep up with the rest of the world in the production sector). I attribute our "service incompetence" to our lack of how to achieve quality in the world's second-oldest profession, which happens to be a service profession; and that, of course, is education. (Isn't it interesting that the world's OLDEST profession is ALSO a service profession?)

As I see it, there are a variety of interrelated reasons why we have made such a mess of our educational system. The most important is that we try to shoehorn it into production-economy thinking, because "that is what we know how to do" (regardless of whether we are kidding ourselves about that justification). What this means is that we believe that the best way to improve the quality of education is to make it more EFFICIENT, a warped way of thinking that has been around at least as long as Taylor started to impose his "scientific" approach to making manufacturing processes more efficient:

http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-Mff23hgidqmHGqbcv.lfskakEtS6qLVHUEMFUG4-?cq=1&p=102

From this position it is a short hop to the premise that the key to efficiency lies in better software, whether that software provides content (as in course material) or conversations (with teachers, students, and anyone else covered by the Cluetrain Manifesto). What is missing from this picture, however, is the assertion that SOCIALIZATION plays a fundamental role in the experience of education, a role with facets too subtle to be "managed" by the software "solutions" of social networking and virtual worlds. What distinguishes socialization is a committed approach to ENGAGEMENT (which, to be fair, IS in Thesis 45 of the Cluetrain Manifesto); and, as we develop an appreciation for just how incapable we have become at social engagement, we see why our failures in education translate into failures throughout the service sector:

http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-Mff23hgidqmHGqbcv.lfskakEtS6qLVHUEMFUG4-?cq=1&p=82

Now we should give Gates credit for a public face that is beginning to appreciate the value of engagement. However, while that appreciation may flow into his charity work, I doubt that anyone would claim that it is flowing into any Microsoft product! So, would YOU trust Bill Gates to "fix" our educational fiasco with a "Microsoft solution!" I most certainly would not!

[Koo Breez]

I don't think he's saying he has all the answers

But at least he's willing to give it a shot. What are YOU doing to make education better?

[mgozaydin]

ONLINE LEARNING

This is my appeal to Bill GATES
If Bill wants to help the world :

1. Set up an ONLINE ENGLISH LEARNING website in 10 levels and at various sectors. it is only $ 10,000,000 for him. But more people will use internet.

2. Set up ONLINE World K12 courses for the whole world on nondebatable subjects such as math, science, That may cost for 12 math course and 12 science course total is $ 24,000,000 again it is nothing for Bill GATES.

UK is not richer than Bill GATES, but UK offers to the whole world free OPEN University ONLINE. Thanks million to them.

If Bill claims he is willing to help the education of people in the world he should do these two very simple things for the world.
Best regards.
Muvaffak GOZAYDIN of Turkey [e-mail]

[HealthyChick]

Online Learning

I fully agree. He also needs to make sure he utilizes the best minds to teach classes from all over the world. Not just hand-pick from the US. That will assure diversity in learning and teaching methods. Best regards. Mary Grimes of USA.

[HealthyChick]

Online Learning

I fully agree. He also needs to make sure he utilizes the best minds to teach classes from all over the world. Not just hand-pick from the US. That will assure diversity in learning and teaching methods. Best regards. Mary Grimes of USA.

[cherald213]

Teaching Teachers

I am glad that Bill Gates has included the importance of the teacher's role in his vision of global technology as it relates to education. "More effort must be put into training teachers in IT"... I am looking forward to seeing what tools (software programs, training initiatives, etc.) Mr. Gates will advance towards this end.