Comments on: Adobe writes FreeHand obituary

Adobe Systems ends updates for the software, meaning no Vista or Intel Mac support, but offers Illustrator upgrade deal.

[boychuk]

Correction

Your article incorrectly states that Freehand's first version was
released in 1998. In fact it was 1988.

[Shankland]

thanks--we fixed it

Thanks for the note. In future, readers should feel free to respond directly to the author, too: the byline is a mailto link.

[ColdMast]

the 5 stages of Grief

1. Denial - The initial stage:
"It can't be happening, CNET is hardly a reliable source."

2. Anger :
"How dare you do this to me Adobe?! I'll never use your stupid products again, I'll tell every one to do the same, I'll kill everyone who did this to Freehand" (perceived, rightly or wrongly, as "responsible")

3. Bargaining :
"Just make it on OSX 10.5 or Vista call it Hand CS3, or import it's functionality into illustrator, or make it open source, I'LL PAY YOU twice as much as CS3"

4. Depression :
"I'm so sad, why bother designing anything?"

5. Acceptance :
"Well it's not like I have to use Microsoft Expression Studio. Adobe canned Atmosphere I guess they can encase Freehand as well; Adobe were still cool right, I didn't mean that whole killing thing... OK... Adobe... ?..."

[umbrae]

Freehand sucked anyway...

Fireworks and Freehand were bad knock-offs of Photoshop and Illustrator anyway. Getting rid of those 2 products were the biggest plus of the Adobe/Macromedia sale...

[SandFarmer]

Freehand was around long before Illustrator . . .

so I don't see how it can be a "knock off"? It anybody copied it was Adobe.

Plus Freehand is billion fold "less" labor intensive that Illustrator will ever be. Here go my hourly rates.

[ColdMast]

SO... YOU NEVER USED FREEHAND?

TRY ALIGNING POINTS IN ILLUSTRATOR, HAVE FUN! Better get out some guides to help you.

I actually do want that easy freehand control combined with illustrator's eye candy and compatibility.

Freehand offers way more user control, Illustrator is like try to draw by holding the eraser of a pencil.

Anyways, everyone and their dog knew it was coming, I just hope Adobe wont though away the functionality instead of just combining the assets they own.

[fritzen2]

Combined tools

I just hope that Adobe will be smart enough to combine the unique aspects of FreeHand with Illustrator so that we don't completely lose the tools we've used for so long. I will miss the speed shoot-outs between the two packages showing Illustrator users just how efficient FreeHand is for 99% of the work designers do. It would also be nice if Adobe would package a 'light' version of Illustrator (or FH) for faculty and non-pro users who can't afford the high price tag but need to make the occasional poster or flyer W/O having to use a MicroSoft product...

[elvis_alien]

well, I've been up and down the first four stages countless times now. But number 5? Never! Adobe has pissed off a lot of people with this clever little move. It's corporate greed over individual free choice. FreeHand was, at the time of it's purported demise, a fully functional application with ongoing marketability. They killed it out of pettiness and as a calculated move to boost their bottom line. We, the people who actually make our livings using FH, don't appreciate it one bit. http://www.freefreehand.org/