Version: 2008
  • On TechRepublic: 10 cool USB flash drive tricks

Comments on: IBM: The 'next big thing' no longer exists

Era of technology breakthroughs for their own sake rather than for profit is over, says innovation exec Nicholas Donofrio.

Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 3 of 4 pages (92 Comments)
The U.S. Patent Office should be shut down!
by akvish March 16, 2006 9:19 AM PST
Why don't IBM help shut down the U.S. Patent Office!
Reply to this comment
The U.S. Patent Office should be shut down!
by akvish March 16, 2006 9:19 AM PST
Why don't IBM help shut down the U.S. Patent Office!
Reply to this comment
Is this guy worth his 20,000,000.00 bonus a yr.
by chien4moi March 16, 2006 12:07 PM PST
this is the guy who on July 20th of last year sold stock and made $20,000,000.00 profit on top of his annual salary????..I work for IBM and haven't had a raise in 4 yrs. and they told me the company couldn't afford it.
Reply to this comment
no raise
by BillWilliams March 21, 2006 7:54 AM PST
same here... more responsibilities, constantly reacting to shifting business models and customer accounts, and no raise in 5 yrs, and 'bonus' gets smaller each year. Mgmt says I need to get "certified", which outside of IBM means nothing.....
Is this guy worth his 20,000,000.00 bonus a yr.
by chien4moi March 16, 2006 12:07 PM PST
this is the guy who on July 20th of last year sold stock and made $20,000,000.00 profit on top of his annual salary????..I work for IBM and haven't had a raise in 4 yrs. and they told me the company couldn't afford it.
Reply to this comment
no raise
by BillWilliams March 21, 2006 7:54 AM PST
same here... more responsibilities, constantly reacting to shifting business models and customer accounts, and no raise in 5 yrs, and 'bonus' gets smaller each year. Mgmt says I need to get "certified", which outside of IBM means nothing.....
cheap personal fabs hooked up to personal computers
by rfielding March 16, 2006 3:12 PM PST
what a boneheaded thing to say.

for example: let some company start selling cheap tools (<$10k) for hardware+electronics+software fabrication and the whole world will get turned upside by the breakneck pace of innovation....yet again. what about good computer algrebra systems to help out with the engineering involved in such endeavors? what about fundamental breakthroughs in computing and materials science (superconductivity, quantum computation, etc.)?

just from personal fabs alont, the current patent/copyright system will collapse from the weight of millions of people making whatever they want, whenever they want it. The big companies that understand will benefit from being able to do large scale implementations of the good ideas that are freely coming in from every direction.

of course, there are some companies that are preoccupied at the moment with farming out maintenance of the status quo to the lowest bidder.
Reply to this comment
cheap personal fabs hooked up to personal computers
by rfielding March 16, 2006 3:12 PM PST
what a boneheaded thing to say.

for example: let some company start selling cheap tools (<$10k) for hardware+electronics+software fabrication and the whole world will get turned upside by the breakneck pace of innovation....yet again. what about good computer algrebra systems to help out with the engineering involved in such endeavors? what about fundamental breakthroughs in computing and materials science (superconductivity, quantum computation, etc.)?

just from personal fabs alont, the current patent/copyright system will collapse from the weight of millions of people making whatever they want, whenever they want it. The big companies that understand will benefit from being able to do large scale implementations of the good ideas that are freely coming in from every direction.

of course, there are some companies that are preoccupied at the moment with farming out maintenance of the status quo to the lowest bidder.
Reply to this comment
IBM may be sitting on the next biggest thing...!
by akvish March 16, 2006 3:38 PM PST
IBM is actually sitting on the next biggest
thing. May be it is not visible from such a high
level innovation post...!

- XBOXs and PS3's will enable common man with
design thinking to deliver designs across
the globe in team collaboration.

That is, turn the Game Machines into
powerful 'team design environment'.

In addition, at the heart of next generation
aerospace & automobile, I see need for powerful
game-machine-like systems.

- Computing will be just digital clay.

Welcome to super-functions & hyper-applications..
...to innovations beyond computing.

-Vish
Reply to this comment
Technology has a limited place....
by Earl Benser March 17, 2006 4:07 AM PST
..... in the Work Team environment. Letting multiple people
coordinate activities on a project is quite useful, as long as the
technology is virtually invisible, and as long as different people
don't conflict in their work.

Any competent manager can quickly set up a cooperative
project, with or without software assistance. An incompetent
manager can't set up anything.

All this hype about software (IBM of MS) provided some magical
capability is just that - hype. The world doesn't work that way,
now, in the past, or in the future. You manage people first, the
project second, the process third.

It's not a game, except maybe for the NFP organizations. The
current 'team' software 'surge' is nothing more than a game.
IBM may be sitting on the next biggest thing...!
by akvish March 16, 2006 3:38 PM PST
IBM is actually sitting on the next biggest
thing. May be it is not visible from such a high
level innovation post...!

- XBOXs and PS3's will enable common man with
design thinking to deliver designs across
the globe in team collaboration.

That is, turn the Game Machines into
powerful 'team design environment'.

In addition, at the heart of next generation
aerospace & automobile, I see need for powerful
game-machine-like systems.

- Computing will be just digital clay.

Welcome to super-functions & hyper-applications..
...to innovations beyond computing.

-Vish
Reply to this comment
Technology has a limited place....
by Earl Benser March 17, 2006 4:07 AM PST
..... in the Work Team environment. Letting multiple people
coordinate activities on a project is quite useful, as long as the
technology is virtually invisible, and as long as different people
don't conflict in their work.

Any competent manager can quickly set up a cooperative
project, with or without software assistance. An incompetent
manager can't set up anything.

All this hype about software (IBM of MS) provided some magical
capability is just that - hype. The world doesn't work that way,
now, in the past, or in the future. You manage people first, the
project second, the process third.

It's not a game, except maybe for the NFP organizations. The
current 'team' software 'surge' is nothing more than a game.
The man is a fool and this will come back and haunt him
by ChrisColes March 16, 2006 11:50 PM PST
Take my word for it, he is a fool and his words will come back and haunt him. IBM is surely slipping backwards into the season of lesser fruitfulness that all large companies eventually reach. All companies live full lives and then die, just like human beings.

Chris Coles.
Reply to this comment
The man is a fool and this will come back and haunt him
by ChrisColes March 16, 2006 11:50 PM PST
Take my word for it, he is a fool and his words will come back and haunt him. IBM is surely slipping backwards into the season of lesser fruitfulness that all large companies eventually reach. All companies live full lives and then die, just like human beings.

Chris Coles.
Reply to this comment
The Next Big thing is NetAlter
by guyfrom2006 March 17, 2006 3:29 AM PST
There is a small obscure company in India which is probably working on the ?Next Big Innovation? in computing.

Recently, they have been issuing press releases on their proposed ?Alternative to the Internet? which promises to be free from Virus, Spam and at the same time offer ?Supercomputing on the Desktop?.

I believe they are also working on an ?Artificial Intelligent Search Engine? which will seek out information from not just public domain but also local databases and provide a ?Domain Free? discovery service for ?Peers? in their network.

From what I gathered after visiting their website, www.netalter.com they have something completely different from the present Internet and one which will combine different technologies within a single browser interface.

I heard that they have already applied for the patent for this technology in the US and elsewhere and are working hard on a New ?Browser? which put to shame the likes of Internet Explorer and Firefox and provide a richer and smarter surfing experience.
Reply to this comment
A very shakey maybe......
by Earl Benser March 17, 2006 11:30 AM PST
NetAlter seems to be very long on hype and very short on
accomplishments.... all promises, no delivery. The web site is nicely
done, but it is no more than smoke and mirrors, if that. NetAlter is
a long way from presenting a real item to consider, and this is as
close as it may get.

Maybe in a couple of years, they will have something. We'll see.
The Next Big thing is NetAlter
by guyfrom2006 March 17, 2006 3:29 AM PST
There is a small obscure company in India which is probably working on the ?Next Big Innovation? in computing.

Recently, they have been issuing press releases on their proposed ?Alternative to the Internet? which promises to be free from Virus, Spam and at the same time offer ?Supercomputing on the Desktop?.

I believe they are also working on an ?Artificial Intelligent Search Engine? which will seek out information from not just public domain but also local databases and provide a ?Domain Free? discovery service for ?Peers? in their network.

From what I gathered after visiting their website, www.netalter.com they have something completely different from the present Internet and one which will combine different technologies within a single browser interface.

I heard that they have already applied for the patent for this technology in the US and elsewhere and are working hard on a New ?Browser? which put to shame the likes of Internet Explorer and Firefox and provide a richer and smarter surfing experience.
Reply to this comment
A very shakey maybe......
by Earl Benser March 17, 2006 11:30 AM PST
NetAlter seems to be very long on hype and very short on
accomplishments.... all promises, no delivery. The web site is nicely
done, but it is no more than smoke and mirrors, if that. NetAlter is
a long way from presenting a real item to consider, and this is as
close as it may get.

Maybe in a couple of years, they will have something. We'll see.
You Achieve what you Believe
by dyac March 17, 2006 8:53 AM PST
I believe its obvious that all the "big things" were done by those who believed there was a "next big thing". When a company sets goals, they set them high so that great results are achieved. The same is true for ideas - if you don't believe they exist, then you won't be the one coming up with them. It seems anti-productive to announce that there is no next big thing, and fund the Yorktown Research Center at the same time. It will be interesting to see whether IBM as a company adheres to the premise that "the next big thing no longer exists", or that you "Achieve what you Believe". I expect its actions (or lack of them) will make the statement loud and clear.
Reply to this comment
You Achieve what you Believe
by dyac March 17, 2006 8:53 AM PST
I believe its obvious that all the "big things" were done by those who believed there was a "next big thing". When a company sets goals, they set them high so that great results are achieved. The same is true for ideas - if you don't believe they exist, then you won't be the one coming up with them. It seems anti-productive to announce that there is no next big thing, and fund the Yorktown Research Center at the same time. It will be interesting to see whether IBM as a company adheres to the premise that "the next big thing no longer exists", or that you "Achieve what you Believe". I expect its actions (or lack of them) will make the statement loud and clear.
Reply to this comment
Read Some Sci-Fi, Nick
by markdoiron March 18, 2006 4:37 AM PST
Nick: You've lost your way, Dude! Read some sci-fi and you'll see there are plenty of folks out there who have an idea what the next big thing will be. Just a few I can think of:

1. 100% accurate voice responsive software that does my bidding. I tell my computer to find out some mashed-up bit of info and it just does it.

2. Transporters, Dude! Think of it: If we can do that, that implies replicators, too!

3. Anti-gravity and Faster-Than-Light Travel. What a way to explore the universe!

Sure, some will say (even "prove") these are impossible. But, the truth is that the "next big thing" is limited only by our imagination. Some will just take a little longer to realize.

mark d.
Reply to this comment
Read Some Sci-Fi, Nick
by markdoiron March 18, 2006 4:37 AM PST
Nick: You've lost your way, Dude! Read some sci-fi and you'll see there are plenty of folks out there who have an idea what the next big thing will be. Just a few I can think of:

1. 100% accurate voice responsive software that does my bidding. I tell my computer to find out some mashed-up bit of info and it just does it.

2. Transporters, Dude! Think of it: If we can do that, that implies replicators, too!

3. Anti-gravity and Faster-Than-Light Travel. What a way to explore the universe!

Sure, some will say (even "prove") these are impossible. But, the truth is that the "next big thing" is limited only by our imagination. Some will just take a little longer to realize.

mark d.
Reply to this comment
"Thinkplace" = Suggestion Box
by jmmejzz March 18, 2006 6:15 AM PST
If IBM's big idea is a suggestion box, I would suggest the next big thing won't be coming from IBM. Burst the bubble.
Reply to this comment
"Thinkplace" = Suggestion Box
by jmmejzz March 18, 2006 6:15 AM PST
If IBM's big idea is a suggestion box, I would suggest the next big thing won't be coming from IBM. Burst the bubble.
Reply to this comment
Maybe Microsoft will buy out NetAlter
by guyfrom2006 March 19, 2006 9:45 AM PST
I think the people developing NetAlter have a more superior goal. Just as companies are trying to sell products and services, I guess NetAlter is a company which is trying to sell innovation.

They are hoping that Microsoft will pick up NetAlter from where it left just as it did with groove.

But the problem is, Microsoft is a dead harbinger as far as implementing ideas go...and I wish some sense prevails among those developing NetAlter to sell it to a more brighter company.

From what I heard the latest on NetAlter, they are planning a beta release of their core browser within a year with about 40-60 percent of the functionality they claim to offer.

Which means, they would be introducing a browser with a sanitised peer to peer network (that allows other peers to locate your computer) and a more intelligent search engine that locates resources in this peer and elswhere.

That could be a wise beginning considering that we spend a whale lot of time on searching for information on the net but hardly finding it.

I have recently dumped google for lookupthis which has its own bookmark search and uses vivisimo for web search. I hope NetAlter offers better than this when it is launched.
Reply to this comment
Maybe Microsoft will buy out NetAlter
by guyfrom2006 March 19, 2006 9:45 AM PST
I think the people developing NetAlter have a more superior goal. Just as companies are trying to sell products and services, I guess NetAlter is a company which is trying to sell innovation.

They are hoping that Microsoft will pick up NetAlter from where it left just as it did with groove.

But the problem is, Microsoft is a dead harbinger as far as implementing ideas go...and I wish some sense prevails among those developing NetAlter to sell it to a more brighter company.

From what I heard the latest on NetAlter, they are planning a beta release of their core browser within a year with about 40-60 percent of the functionality they claim to offer.

Which means, they would be introducing a browser with a sanitised peer to peer network (that allows other peers to locate your computer) and a more intelligent search engine that locates resources in this peer and elswhere.

That could be a wise beginning considering that we spend a whale lot of time on searching for information on the net but hardly finding it.

I have recently dumped google for lookupthis which has its own bookmark search and uses vivisimo for web search. I hope NetAlter offers better than this when it is launched.
Reply to this comment
Showing 3 of 4 pages (92 Comments)
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.

More feeds available in our RSS feed index.

advertisement