Comments on: Microsoft's 'Cloud OS' takes shape

Once ethereal, Microsoft's plans to try to replicate its desktop position on the Web are starting to become clearer.

[Commander_Spock]

>>> 'Cloud OS'<<<!!! Why...

... don't they just name the thing "WARP" (since that is the Code-Base anyway) and done with it since sooner or later - photons and all get sucked into the Black Holes! Looks like computing at the speed of "light" all over again!

[lesfilip]

Commander_Spock is a talkbot

For those who do not know, it is a program, not a human. I'm not
kidding.

Have a nice day.

[Troll Hard]

I'll tell you why

IBM had Microsoft under contract to develop IBM PC-DOS for the IBM PC. Microsoft did, but there was nothing in the contract that said Microsoft could not develop their own version of DOS. Microsoft made MS-DOS, based on the IBM PC-DOS codebase. IBM got mad and sued, but lost.

IBM had Microsoft under contract to develop IBM OS/2 for the IBM PS/2 series computers. Microsoft did, but there was nothing in the contract that said Microsoft could not develop their own version of OS/2. Microsoft made OS/2 3.0, based on the IBM OS/2 codebase and renamed it Windows NT 3.1. IBM got mad and sued, but lost.

Want to know why? Because Microsoft owns the IP in the codebase used for PC-DOS and OS/2, and IBM does not. Microsoft wrote the code, and it was their ball. So Microsoft took their ball and went home because IBM was not playing fair.

They have a saying, fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice shame on me. Shame on IBM for Microsoft fooling them twice. More the fool you for believing in OS/2, which is still Microsoft IP and Microsoft has the legal right to do whatever they want with that IP.

IBM goofed, twice, and now you are the one who goofed. More the fool you.

OS/2 is now a niche market, used by banks who don't know any better and are in danger of being bought out by larger banks who use something else than OS/2 like Linux or Solaris.

It is evolution, Windows evolved, Linux evolved, Mac OS evolved, OS/2 didn't evolve. Evolve or die, survival of the species that is most adaptive to change. OS/2 is not adaptive to change, so guess what?

Windows evolves into Could OS.

[Commander_Spock]

Hello Houston - Microsoft On Cloud Nine!

While Commander_Spock do not wish to be seen as "knock" these dudes on the Redmond Campus should one venture on an higher orbit then will there not be a "cloudless" environment to be considered (that of SPACE, the final frontier) and here the dudes from the Redmond Campus (often being accused of not being very innovative) are saying that ("Cloud-centric is probably a better way to say it because Cloud OS makes it sound like it is only running on the cloud," said Brian Hall, general manager of Windows Live. "A lot of the data, a lot of the apps, a lot of the interesting things are on the edge. They are on the PCs. They are on the Xboxes. They are on the phones.") while it is quite certain that some smarter folks may very well be focusing on topics like quantum theories, quantum mechanics, quantum physics, quantum computing... Question: Do ya all think that the Redmond Campus is the best place on Planet Three from whence sea-change innovations with regards to the future of computing will come!!!

[shane--2008]

based on the past

based on microsofts past history of "innovation" i suspect that all of
this will be nothing much until a company that actually creates
things has a product that they can either buy or copy (poorly) for
release.

[wildchild_plasma_gyro]

Head up in the clouds

Only kidding there.
Microsoft never ceases to amaze me with their determination to follow through with the advanced options that will make the world we live in tommorow other groups would be wise to follow this lead of believing in dreams(IBM,Sony, maybe Sun (although theres a lot in sun)).
Also a lot of groups would be wise to think collabrativly about this and think about what they can contribte individually to peoples collabrative abilities within the cloud capabilities.
If there's somthing Microsoft need right now its to get a fell of what dreamers and doers are around so that they can make the best package and your group can use and develop with it(win win).

What comes after clouds.
Well clouds are about getting the thunder going and the wok moving while we get a feel for our true potential. They're about allowing us to collaberate technilogically like never before so that groups can gain cooperative cencreat as to provide to best potential to others.
As this world does begin to serment say over the next 27 - 43 years the next stage with the computing power alonside it to achieve such will emerge.

Crystal.

So lets look at this process in form.

Net - power - web - power - cloud - power - crystal.

ok check this out
1961 - 1988 - 2011 - 2028

what does this mean.
Progress takes time.

[Commander_Spock]

>>>"web - power - cloud - power...

... - crystal. ok check this out 1961 - 1988 - 2011 - 2028 what does this mean. Progress takes time."<<< Did you not miss the SPACE-TIME CONTINUUM. How are you going to see other worlds if you cannot reach WARP SPEED!

[hounddoglgs]

What???

Another talk_bot? What the hell are you talking about? What a bunch of gibberish.

[jimcbr]

When pigs fly

Well, given the fact that no-one wants to write software for Windows on the PC anymore, why anyone in their right mind would want to use their web tools when there are pleny of better/free/open source stuff out there is beyond me.

[RagingAura]

woah man

we can tell you don't like ms, jsut don't say absolutes that make you seem stupid.

[JJWhitney]

Complete lack of direction

MS lacks complete direction in its OS development and that comes from the top.

[amanfromMars]

A lack of Third Party Ambition?

"MS lacks complete direction in its OS development and that comes from the top."

Then that simply presents an opportunity for one to provide IT, JJWhitney. And I imagine that one would be very well rewarded.

[RagingAura]

us humans need someone to point the finger at... *NM*

didn't i say no message?

[MaLvaDo39]

Not Heaven

I believe Microsoft is saying this project is dead from inception.

But I'm not sure why they think it's in heaven among the clouds.

I'm sure it's farther down below where their Windows OS resides...

[amanfromMars]

Made in Heaven

MaLvaDo39,
If IT is on Commander_Spock's Cloud Nine, it is probably AI Seventh Heaven, Global Communications HQ thing they're Floating..... which would make IT a project raised from the dead...... although if ur2die4 IT, IT will obviously out of this World and into some Very Ethereal Wwworlds Virtualised.

[justice007]

Sounds fluffy

Sounds very fluffy and marketing-ish so far. From the technical side, it seems to be a scaled up statement of "windows everywhere" talk we heard several years ago. It also implies one can plug only MS-OS based devices into this "cloud" - and with their propensity to not inter-operate with others (and the "E-E-E' practices and resulting reputation), it can be an MS-only cloud. Vapor?

[ralfthedog]

It sounds like Microsoft has discovered Object oriented programing....

It sounds like Microsoft has discovered Object oriented programing and data abstraction. Soon Microsoft will learn to stay away from the goto command.

[bluetachikoma]

Perspective

You are thinking in terms of sitting in front of a keyboard and start getting some coding done. This is not about "components" or "libraries" or "just code". This is about arquitecture, empowering services, heck... is not even about object orientation.

[amanfromMars]

C Prompt.

"Soon Microsoft will learn to stay away from the goto command."

Maybe they've been taught/learnt that what you Give is what you Get.

[rivsys]

You mean as in

"You can goto the library and read up on a little technology called .Net..."

You obviously know shinola about this topic, which, incidentally, has little to do with OOP per se and a whole lot to do with massively distributed computing - and is way beyond anything Java was ever intended to do.

[Llib Setag]

Hey! You! Get off of my cloud!

(The Rolling Stones)

This is how The Matrix started...

[Vegaman_Dan]

Heh.

That was pretty funny, actually. :)

Nice reference.

[WJeansonne]

I second that!

Definitely funny!! All of the titles for these posts are quite amusing.

[henk goewie]

Jedi OS

I picture myself and my dear ones, cloacked and caped , in a galaxy
far, far away. Sitting around a coffee-table like apparatus
displaying yet other galaxies and their inhabitants. I got lame
hands from fiddling with the huge touch-screen. I am trying to
book some flight-tickets on the IInet (Intergalactic Internet...) for
our holiday. The coffee table says: Cloud OS cannot print your
tickets at this time... If you want to notify Microsoft about this
problem, just clap your hands...

[helmycell]

This is funny ! I mean... really funny.

"If you want to notify Microsoft about this problem, just clap your hands..."
And after clapping your hands, the coffee table refuses and says : "Invalid Claps, please follow this Clap Setup prosedur. Warning: Cloud OS will record your ID and your Claps later can be used anywhere as ID."

It's really entertain me. I can't stop laughing.

[LuvThatCO2]

Cue the microsoft bashers!

Uh, a story about MS. Time for the bashers to come out of the woodwork!

Something tells me if this was about an 'Apple Cloud OS' or 'Google Cloud OS', everyone would be singing about how innovative it is.

[Commander_Spock]

Hint for "LuvThatCO2" - The Schism!

"In 1990, IBM and Microsoft were still working together on the development of OS/2. Microsoft, however, had found that Windows 3.0 - released in May 1990 - generated more revenue for them and therefore allotted increasingly more resource to Windows and correspondingly less to OS/2.

By late 1990, Microsoft had intensified its disagreements with IBM to the point where IBM decided that it would have to take some overt action to ensure that OS/2 development continued at a reasonable pace. IBM, therefore, took over complete development responsibility for OS/2 1.x, even though it was in its dying days, and OS/2 2.00. Microsoft would continue development on Windows and OS/2 3.00. Shortly after this split, Microsoft renamed OS/2 V3 to Windows NT"

http://www.os2bbs.com/os2news/OS2History.html

They say that: HISTORY HAS A WAY OF REPEATING ITSELF! So, the big, big, big question is: Can Microsoft Be Trusted - Again? ONCE BITTEN, TWICE SHY!

[t8]

OK, here I am

BTW, they are not innovative, they are just copying again. Problem for them is that the Web is democratic, so they will be one player of many.

Thankfully it won't be like Windows all over again.

[william1779]

Here is one of the unarguable logic of this world

That's what I thought first reading the headline. People around here are sometimes getting paid for being bashers, but somehow sometimes not. And in that last case this is because 1."they are happy worms inside the apple wearing the glasses of exclusivity thus ignorance" or 2. Microsoft was the first to "think" software and give wings to a lot of things that the typical "mass sheep" like to think it has been "stolen". People enjoy actually working in collaboration directly or indirectly for MS because of the potential they have ahead (and let say pushing the worms to another step of jealousy though), and enjoy laughing at the ignorance of the mass. But seriously this world is really beginning to smell the rotten parasite and is really irritating because of this bunch of negative sheeps that cannot get away from polluting everything MS, and by the way also for this very example, the cnet talkbacks. So my reply should stand like: Cut the Microsoft bashers!

[RagingAura]

arqutechtire-mystalk-idiotube

and apple bashers- and the normal people who like to read the comments for a good laugh. i notice one thing, mac users simpler, but ms users make more typos-

wait for it
wait for it
almost

look they are flaming! isn't so adorable how they incessently fight its like having kids and watching them argue for attention!

[cross platform]

The Beginning Of The End

No one is going to go for an OS that resides on line. Even with broadband there are days when your computer can't connect to the internet. If all of your stuff is on line your computer is just a box. I don't believe Apple would propose something like this because it's pretty easy to figure out people won't go for this. Especially after Vista. So if MS does go this way and nobody bites will they become a software company that just doesn't focus on the OS? If this happens who will fill the void? I vote for Apple. They've already shown an ability to run another OS on their hardware. Why not OS X for the PC's that get left behind? In ten years or so the computing landscape could be totally upside down! Let's face it. They're going to have to do something. XP is getting long in the tooth compared to some of the software you run with it. Also it's like Gates has made his money and moved on. I don't trust Balmer to make good decisions. Vista will propbably be mainstream within a year but it's just not enough of a change ( a cheap OS X knockoff and after 5 years ). So what's going to happen?

[Phillep_H]

Oh? Why?

Microsoft blows smoke better than anyone else. They have it down to an artform.

[Ian Joyner]

Vapourware...

is the term that appropriately comes to mind. It's a very old tactic ?
other competing companies generate a lot of interest in their
shipping products, so you announce what you are going to do next,
based on partial and unproven implementations to steal the
marketplaces gaze and hopefully critical sales. IBM did it with the
Stretch vapourware computer to knock out the CDC 6000.
Microsoft has learnt these anti-competitive practices well from IBM.
See Richard DeLamarter's "Big Blue: IBM's Use and Abuse of Power".

[petermpham2003]

No, ...

... it is 'cloudware' to be exact.

[Commander_Spock]

Now we know for sure...

... where some "ideas" come from:

"Cloudscape" DataBase Server you say!

http://www-128.ibm.com/developerworks/db2/library/techarticle/dm-0408bader/

Now it is back to the "Old School" and its; "Got to have" that "innovative" and similar sounding OS name too. Wow!

[Phillep_H]

Understated

That sure is a bunch of bafflegab in that article. "Vapourware" gives it too much credit.

The only solid part is the fingers reaching for my wallet.

[reachx]

yeah, it's called JAVA!!! only oh 15 yrs later

yeah, it's called JAVA!!! only oh 15 yrs later

[Penguinisto]

"What's yours is ours", respond Malware Writers

So they're gonna let developers dig way deep down?

This is going to be... interesting.

/P

[Commander_Spock]

Don't Worry, Be Happy Folks...

... as Space Ship - Enterprise Warp's V 5 engines (eComStation 2.0) about to come online soon you are all guaranteed an exciting journey through "clouds"; space, time (and your economic woes which where thrust upon you by certain folks). Enjoy your weekend like you did before the ".com Bubble" exploded. TGIF and it's Party Time!

[Ramicnet]

Why to wait the cloud, try G.ho.st

I think potencial alternatives to microsoft cloud os are already in the market with a big vision to deal with people who are moving all their data and application to the web (Web mail, Web photo albums, Web documents?etc) and to be available from anywhere.

Check out G.ho.st (The Global Hosted Operating SysTem) at http://g.ho.st. G.ho.st is working to provide a free fully functional Virtual Computer, on the Web, so that every person in the world can do any computing at any time, any place, on any budget.

Just try it...

[RagingAura]

be careful of what you post. what you just said is an ad for that website.

no message

[amanfromMars]

Alternate Reality Games...

G.ho.st has some pretty phishy Terms and Conditions though which would appear to be very self-serving. A Great idea spoiled/not Intelligently Designed?

[mattumanu]

Not very useful

Ghost has a long way to go. Last I checked, you couldn't transfer files easily, you couldn't even open a picture without it asking you do download it first! (Something that isn't a problem in general on the internet).

In fact, I just checked and the photos I had uploaded to my Ghost Storage are there, but I can't even download them for some studid reason.

And by the way, it's just a glorified flash page.

[Commander_Spock]

Why....

... didn't the S.E.T.I folks think about this idea before!!!

http://setiathome.ssl.berkeley.edu/

[wauler]

what is the next big thing in theory...

Actually we are doing it in china and I am sure it gonna make huge sense shortly. I mean the future lies in web-based RSS and user-driven mashup, so the youtubes especially facebook vertically are in the right direction but not enough no wonder sometimes they will lost doing something offend their users. We must reject the concept doing the traditional Internet business let alone Operating systems like WebOs or Webservice Opening API. We must build the web as a platform which has dedicated subject and audience thus we can have control to the customer so that we can grasp the internetlised content and application, there is a chinese saying:皮之不存毛将焉附. something like and Operator2.0, you know they have vendor of network equipment and handset maker help setup the infrastrcture and provide application then customers help themself generate content: voice, data and even more...But ours will quadplay within internet, software, hardware and media industry, like yahoo to media, salesforce to software, apple to hardware, so this is really gonna be future stuff and we are trying to make it in china. And cheers cause definetely we have entered into an era of unified competition totally (同质化全竞争)thanks to the fantastic spurt of ICT and TMT world tend to be flat. I am pretty much sure it will shape the brand new future of this whole TMT&ICT industry.
How:
vision, mission, strategy
vision, focus, execuation
innovation: speed and simplicity
engineering: user experience and security

4more turn to waulerwauler#gmail.com

[amanfromMars]

Only Semantics, I Know, but Important.

Great to hear that China are leading the way with ITs Democratisation, wauler, even if it is up to entrepreneurs to put IT in place and Control IT too.

And "I mean the future lies in international internetworking web-based RSS and user-driven mashup,... " works better for me.

[Phillep_H]

Maybe not

MS is trying to gain total control over everything electronic. Consider how this proposal, web computing under a new lable, would prevent anyone from using a computer without being on line, and paying MS for the privelege. Total centralized control, by someone outside China.

[knightsqr]

Very UNinteresting

Sounds like MS is just trying to recreate MS Outlook for the Web (w/ network file shares). Not very original. I thought it would be something more interesting like Professor David Gelernter's concept of Mirror Worlds, which was a massively distributed processing vision (see Gelernter's C-Linda and Sun Microsystem's JXTA). Microsoft needs to stop trying to find ways to lock users into its 1990's vision of the world.

[i,Jimbot]

Uh, would that be because....

Would that perhaps be because Microsoft has a history of long
delays, vaporware, poor products, etc., whereas Google and Apple
have histories of innovation and cool products? (hint: YES)