Comments on: Intel's mantra: Let's make a deal

The chipmaker's pact with Skype highlights how exclusive content and software can outweigh technology or performance.

[njwashor]

Shady

This kind of business practice disgusts me. This is essentially the same thing as Coca Cola not allowing Mc Donalds to sell Pepsi products (which if I recall correctly, was found to be an illegal marriage). This sort of partnership between two unrelated enterprises should be outlawed as it stifles innovation, discourages free trade, and is all around bad for the consumer.

[Intelrules]

Not shady

It is perfectly legal when you read & hear about exclusive deals!! As long as both side's sign an legal contract stating an exclusive deal between each others technology is legal also other company that is being pitched the deal can simply decline the offer & not sign any contract at all!!! Anyway if you read the article you would stumble by them saying several time's it is a limited time deal for an undisclosed time period!!

[Jim Hubbard]

Boycott Skype and others that adopt Intel's practices....

I believe we should boycott companies that enter into such agreements with Intel.

While Skype was the first, well-known player in the VOIP for PC market, it is by far not the last.

No responsible software manufacturer would adopt such a strategy. It seems to me that Skype (a company that has yet to turn a profit) is getting desperate.

Unfortunately for them, desperation usually results in stupid moves that further harm your company.....like this one.

I have long been an AMD fan and this validates my choice even more. Long live AMD!

[mahurshi]

what's the problem ???

just because you're a fan of AMD doesn't mean such deals by Skype are not good.

who knows, maybe they will develop a cool technology together.

besides, if you want to go and boycott Skype because they're making a living out of such deals, you're not letting the company grow. and its not like they said that their software doesn't work at all on AMDs.

Give them a break..

[chassoto--2008]

Firing off an email to Apple

I was planning to buy a new iMac Core Duo. Nope. Not gonna. I'll
stick with my old G4 until Intel drops this. Sorry, Apple. Get in bed
with ******, catch a nasty bug!

[Earl Benser]

Now that's a bit radical....

... shoot yourself in the ass just to make a point that you don't like
a legitimate business maneuver by Intel. You're the one who is
paying the price. Apple won't miss you; there are just too many
other buyers to pay attention.

[Ljanicek]

Intel's deal w/Skype is Pathetic

Intel a powerhouse of American technology and innovation should hang it's head in shame with it's latest gambit to try to stunt AMD with it's exclusive deal with Skype. This pathetic manuever tells the world, if you can't beat them with a superior product, box em out by playing the 800 pound gorilla routine, a la Microsoft. Andy Grove, where are you ?

Good for Intel - Dumb for Skype

As a regular Skype user I think it is a dumb move. I can have a group of 4 on with any CPU so why would I bother buying an Intel CPU system just o get another 2?

For Intel it gives them a bit of publicity and bragging rights but unless Intel gave them a bunch of money I don't see they point for Skype.

There will soon be OpenSource versions that don't rely on centralized web sites so Skype should keep all their options open. Their mistake.

[df561]

it stinketh :-)

this news makes both intel and skype look bad. How shameful.

[sharikou]

Microsoft can kill INTEL in a flash for being in bed with apple

the code
if(CPUID matches "INTEL") P
//you little bastard, sleep with Jobs
say("Sorry, your CPU is slow and dumb, only 5 Windows can be opened");

}else {
say("Welcome to Windows, unlimited Windows");
}

http://sharikou.blogspot.com/

[Earl Benser]

Sure....

... and if the do, it's called a Pyrric victory.

[SystemsJunky]

Just another reason

for AMD to justify their claims that Intel is trying to stiffle its competition. i hope they win that lawsuit. Just like the deal with apple, im sure Intel hooked Skype up with 100's of millions of ad dollars :)

Intel - Bad
AMD - GOOD

[J_Satch]

re: Just another reason

fire BAD
beer GOOD

[chhooks]

Well, geuss I won't be buying that new computer...

I had almost talked myself into the 3 ghz range and was ready to make the switch to Intel from AMD...

Not with garbage like this going on! Forget Intel AND skype! Who needs them!!!

[Earl Benser]

AMD should quite complaining...

... and make its own deals. There are many other VOIP options out
there waiting of for effective conference calling (I think). Or AMD
could just engineer an alternate approach that neutralizes Intel's
edge. Complaining gets nothing done.

[Rolndubbs]

Okay...

Yet if this was microsoft making more deals, I have a feeling you would be singing a different tune. Smart move on intel's part, they have to offer something exclusive since they are lagging behind AMD in performance and efficiency atm. This could change this year, but with the M2 chips coming out and intel releasing its new stuff, it should be a fun year for hardware.

[Intelrules]

RE:

amd only knows how to complain thats all. They are too dumb to do anything about it also amd keeps shooting themselves in the foot by consistently accusing Intel of unfair business practice's when they get the best contract possible. amd keeps on undermining their suit against Intel. amd is just a tiny little cry baby that cannot act on a competitors exclusive deal for a limited time.

[coryschulz]

I'm okay with it...

Just as long as Intel and AMD are both making processors, it's fine by me. As long as we are still pushing for better and better I see only progress.

From what I've read, AMD still has stronger processors then the Core Duo. AMD practically created the market for 64 bit processors and Intel is still trying to catch up after many failed attempts. The AMD architecture is much stronger and has more potential then Intels. But really, all of this is nothing compared to IBM's Cell processor that can have up to 16 processors ("cells") and is equivalent to a 25gig P4 (That's right, a 25 ghz Pentium 4 Processor). Personally, I'm more interested to see how well the Cell Processor performs in the PS3 and what IBM plans to do with it after that.

[Earl Benser]

Honest question....

Previously, there have been comment that the Cell is okay as a
game machine processor, but it is the wrong design for a computer
pprocessor. Now you note that it is apparently the equal of a 25
Ghz P4. I assume that that's a 25 Ghz P4 in a PC, with unspecified
bus speed. But what details can you offer to substantiate the
equivalency?

[atomicpineapple]

Lets make a deal/screw people over

Pathetic. Intel, instead of actually making GOOD CPU's that can beat AMD, decides to try and bully people into buying its inferior rubbish by using its cash reserves to restrict full use of certain programs to Intel. Fair do its only Skype today, but whats next? Intel only games/other apps? These corporate pricks really do annoy me sometimes.

[HKUSP40]

AMD=PERFORMANCE NOT EXCUSES

SORRY INTEL YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO DO MORE THAN PATHETIC LITTLE DEALS LIKE THIS WITH SKYPE. PERFORMANCE IS THE BOTTOM LINE AND AMD IS KICKING YOUR A%^....

[TheTSArt1]

SkypeOut Balance Gone!

I guess they know I have a PowerPC Mac due to my software
version. I made a call about two weeks ago and had a balance left
when I hung up.

Today, my balance is zero. So, I lost about $10 because I don't
have an Intel chip?! That's terrible business!